M&S high-cut flats, I'm unsure....

[Bejazzled]

Yes or no?

here

Huge hit, but long term. You will all have a pair in a year.

The marmite of shoes

I like them, I think. Next time I’m in M&S I’ll to try them on to decide.

I love them. They make me feel very 1990, just looking at them. They make me want a wrap blouse body combo, a quiff and matte lipstick.

High vamp shoes look shit on me, but my dsis would make them look really chic.

They look like they've been designed by someone who is blind and is having to go by a description of a shoe given by a person with no communication skills.

I like them. Way better than normal ballet toe-scrunchers. Sole look too hard for me though.

I like them.

I had a red pair from Topshop last year and I loved them. They were a bit flimsier than these ones look though so are a bit trashed now - might have a look at the red M&S pair as they really did go with loads.

If you have small wide feet they're probably flattering however for big feet they're going to make them look bigger

High cut shoes are surprisingly flattering.

They just remind me of the type of shoes you’d see in the Telegraph or The Lady small ads back in the ‘80s...

They look nice until you click on the pic of them actually being worn, then they definitely don't look nice imho.

I really like them. Well the white and the lemon anyway, and perhaps the lilac. I'm not too sure about the other colours. I am very unfashionable though, and most of the things I like are described as granny-ish/frumpy on here, so I'm maybe not the best judge!

Not for those with larger feet. They looked so great on the shelf, terrible on my size 7s.

I think the problem is that they are too square at the toe. They might look nice pointed? but as they are they just look like frumpy parcels. They are going back to the shop today...

The red ones look like Marge Simpson's shoes.

They look like you made them yourself in a crafting club.

Oh dogrilla!!! Those are truly horrendous.

averts gaze.

I went and looked at them in the flesh the other day. I had thought they were cool but on closer inspection I think they are ming.

I like them. Nice change to the same old ding dong we've been wearing for the last 20 years. Time for a change.

I love the way people call them granny shoes or for the over 80s only. Does that mean you consider the shoes deeply unstylish? Or does that mean that Grannies and the over 80s are automatically deeply unstylish purely by virtue of their age? I am neither a granny nor over 80, but i dislike being categorised now, and I suspect I will dislike being categorised when I am older (hopefully).

Shedragon - grannies aren't necessarily unstylish, but there is a definite tendency towards comfort over style in the latter years...

Ooh no. Definitely not.

I think they'd be better with a V shaped vamp. The high cut is fine, the rounded shape not so much.

I like them but you'd need the yellow or red to make them work I think, less bright would look frumpy