Help me choose which dress please! For a wedding

[Weddingoutfit]

Which one, out of the two, for a wedding. It's a (not very close) friends wedding. Thanks

Do you have a third option? If it must be one of those two the first, they're both nice but not very weddingy

Honestly? Neither.

First one is far FAR too skimpy and short for a wedding and the second is too evening-y.

Any other options?

No just these two! Thanks I think the first one myself.

Do you have a blouse you could wear under the first one? What sort of wedding is it? How formal and that.

The first is too skimpy for a wedding. If you're just going to the evening do the second is ok.
I got a bargain dress from Oasis for a wedding today. Was £65, tag said £25, got to till and was £18!

The second is more formal, although more of an evening dress than a day time dress, iyswim. I prefer the first but would probably go for the second.
I agree with Enchanted that neither are very weddingy, but they are both very nice and I think either would do - they are inoffensive and I have seen people wear far worse things at weddings.

I was thinking with a pretty cardy sort of thing over the top it wouldn't be as showy for the day. It's a traditional wedding, but I'm not very close to the people so don't have a 'part' in the wedding

If its a traditional wedding, then go for the second dress. The first is really lovely, but not really right for a traditional wedding.

You look lovely in. It's but they aren't really wedding appropriate.

The first is way too short and too ordinary. The second looks too dark and formal.

You really need another option.

First one with a cardigan.

Sorry that should be "you lol lovely in both, but .....

Ok. Then it has to be the second one. Silver bag and shoes.

At the risk of sounding like an old fuddy duddy, the first one is too short and too revealing.
The second is just a bit meh.

Do you have a friend or relative you could borrow something off?

Neither I'm afraid. The first one is inappropriate, too short and too casual, too low necked
The second is an evening dress for a black tie event not a wedding.

You have a gorgeous figure. I would suggest borrowing something from a friend, sales or a good charity shop x

Agree with the others. You look lovely in both. And it might just be the photos but the first one does look too skimpy for a wedding. Can't see a cardigan make a big difference. The other would be lovely for evening do.

You have such a lovely figure, you would look lovely in a bin bag, but that wouldn't be great fir a wedding

Don't you have any other option, or as dontpoke says, borrow a dress off someone?

It doesn't have to be a dress, do you have a suitable skirt and top?

Add a fitted jacket the first one and you'll be fine. The second one would see you mistaken as a bridesmaid.

Do you have any pretty sandals? Because that might be a way to make the second dress look less eveningy (as long as this doesn't make it drag along the ground).

The first looks like a dress for a day on the beach. The second is an evening dress. Both are v nice, but I wouldn't wear either to a wedding. What else have you got in your wardrobe?

Personally neither, first one to short and skimpy, second one not at all suitable for a wedding imho. Sorry, think you need a third option.

My friends and I often swap evening wear or wedding outfits as they're never used that much anyway. Could you call a friend for options?

If not then the first dress with a nice cardigan over the top

Agree with everyone else. Neither.
Go borrow from someone, or mooch round the charity shops.
You can do a lot better.
Really, the short one is entirely wrong - nowhere near enough of it for a wedding outfit, and the long one is evening wear. Very nice, but evening wear.

I have another option from a friend but she is very booby so the pic doesn't do it justice, and we totally have different body shapes

This is the other option. But on me the boobs wouldn't be on show.