@SashaTaught , I honestly don’t think pictures tell me too much as it’s such a momentary fragment of what you deal with over a long period of time. Sometimes I can see something that a GP should probably take a closer look at but beyond that, I tend to take people’s own assessment of their skin and work from that. So I don’t really want to get into the ‘your skin is not as bad as it sounds description’ (though it’s meant in an encouraging way here), IME those who post on here with the most troubling skin tend to downplay it a lot out of social habit and those with what most would consider not problematic at all, tend to be the most vocal about their unhappiness with it. It doesn’t really matter to me what’s ‘accurate’, in my book anyone struggling with their skin can describe it as problematic or not as they like without having to measure it against other people’s conditions or for us having to define what’s ‘normal’ or ‘perfect’ skin and what isn’t. I am having a hard time spotting any broken capillaries though and would say with some reserve that your expectations for good skin may possibly be unrealistic.
First of all your skin sounds/appears very sensitive/reactive (which isn’t all that unusual in the deathly pale) but I have to take in consideration most digital cameras greatly exaggerate redness. However, your history of eczema and the Liquid Gold fiasco suggest as much, whether you were always sensitive or if that’s a result of the LG will remain a mystery but I think it’s best to start treating your skin as ultrasensitive. Which would mean eschewing the most common triggers like fragrance, alcohol, colourants, essential oils, possibly silicones, etc. and since you seem especially clog prone and found balms not working for you I’d avoid solid fats at room temperature (so shea butter, cocoa seed butter, coconut oil, etc.) and waxes (synthetic or otherwise).
It may very well be that you permanently damaged your skin with LG, leaving it compromised, your retelling of product issues is somewhat worrying as you appear to push your skin further than it wishes to be taken, not taking the initial warning signs as such. That coupled with your expectations of your own skin can lead to unpleasant results so it's something to mindful of if that's the case (I can only make assumptions on the basis of the comments on here and the form so can equally be completely off the mark here). I feel it best to really focus on a very gentle, low-irritant approach to get your skin to a less sensitised/reactive state.
As for diet, I don’t know if it will solve your skin problems outright. You mentioned it did little when you went low-carb/no fat/no sugar (which I assume means high fat and high protein which in my book isn’t all that balanced either so a difficult comparison model of a healthy/not healthy diet but does give some indication on food sensitivities and your skin) but it would be remiss to say there are plenty of other benefits to a healthy diet beyond skin health. As mentioned many times over on this thread, dehydration in your skin won’t be solved by drinking more water, but like a healthy balanced diet, drinking plenty of water is a great contributor to general good health which is always beneficial to skin, but it’s a myth that can drink your way out of skin dehydration.
The majority of products you’re using now contain some form of potential irritants (probably in the makeup too, think Clarins contains fragrance) so I do think it’s sensible to start cutting those out. Yes, it’s the lean French pharmacy diet that can feel more like punishment than delight sometimes. LRP Toleriane Dermo Cleanser, HA Serum, Eucerin UltraSensitive for Combo Skin, SPF with the possible addition of PC Resist Anti-Aging Skin Transforming Multi-Correction Treatment with Azelaic Acid + BHA and a non-fragrant oil cleanser. Tacking on P50 (or another gentle AHA -not glycolic) if the PC Azelaic/BHA combo isn’t the one for you, a low irritant Vit C (so not L-AA), reintroducing the PC Nia and a gentle form of retinol (the Redermic is not the one I’d go with for you) in the very distant future. Keep the number of products to a minimum and the standard advice applies about introduction and building up acids/Retinoids/Vit C/etc.
My Morning Routine:
Soap and Glory Ultimelt Cream Cleanser washed off with a flannel post shower I don’t hate this as outright as most of S&G stuff but it does contain essential oils so, for now, I’d keep away from this and for an AM cleanser it’s a little heavy.
Nip Fab Dragons Blood Pad
Vichy Aqualia Serum contains fragrance and Paula’s Choice Resist 10% Niaminacide Booster mixed together - you could continue to use the Nia in the AM orPM routine
Indeed Labs Hydraluron Moisture Jelly - how is this working for you? Can’t remember if this is a heavy silicone formulation or not
LRP Anthelios SPF 30 Lotion ← is this the body lotion version? If so don’t use it for the face it’s probably too heavy or Nivea Anti-age suncream ← contains fragrance or Kiehls Daily Defence
My Evening Routine:
Body Shop Camomile Silky Cleansing Oil or Vichy Beautifying Cleansing Micellar Oil- Flannel Both contain fragrance and/or irritating essential oils/extracts
CeraVe Hydrating Cleanser - Flannel It doesn’t sound like you’re getting on well with this so stop before it actually further irritates your skin.
Paula’s Choice 2% BHA. (Either the Skin Perfecting Liquid or the Clear Extra Strength Liquid as I have both in a trial size. The ingredients seem to be the same so I don’t understand what the difference is) Those two are indeed the same IIRC, there are several PC products with the same INCI but with different names, unfortunately. The PC Resist Azelaic would slip in here if you were to go with this so you’d need to hold back on these in the interim, how has this worked for you so far?
Indeed Labs Eyesilix or Kiehls Powerful Strength Line Reducing Eye Cream
Elemis HydraNourish or Origins Make A Difference Night Treatment OR one of the below moisturising treatments depending on what my skin is doing.
Aesop Parsley seed mask, LRP Serozinc, Origins Overnight moisture mask, Kiehls Midnight Recovery Oil, Una Brennan Probiotic Night Treatment, soap and glory Hot Pore declogging mask.
You may be able to reintroduce some of these 'banned' products later again but for now it's important to suss out what exactly triggers and clogs your skin.