I'm not a mum, just a 'cat mum' so perhaps I dress cat mumsy, I don't know.
Although I have been know to scoop shit out of the litter tray whilst wearing Isabel Marant.
But, I can see both sides here. And sometimes it's just down to how nature made us, isn't it? Some people manage to look stylish without even trying, whilst some try very hard and fail miserably. And personally, I don't care two hoots how someone else dresses, or whether they wear makeup or not. To me, it's like any other hobby or interest (cars, sport, fine china, interior design, etc), some people care and others just don't, so I can't imagine casting judgement on someone else, especially their mental outlook or health simply by observing their clothes. In fact, if I cast a critical eye over online images of what people wear at Fashion Week, I could definitely pull up a few.....WTF's.
But it's true that the S&B section is mostly helpful and lighthearted. I don't really believe anyone is casting judgement in here, no matter how poorly worded some of the comments may be. I love clothes and makeup, but don't particularly obsess over them, but more importantly I don't think they elevate me or make me intrinsically better than someone who doesn't care at all.
But what is mumsy? I recall thinking about this when I was a preteen, and never gave it much thought since. I think that I considered shapeless skirts, polyester blouses and cheap heeled shoes to be mumsy, but that was back in the day. Not sure what constitutes it now, cos none of the lists on here seem remotely offensive to me, even though I don't wear any of them myself.