Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Step-parenting

Connect with other Mumsnetters here for step-parenting advice and support.

My bf is treating my son unfairly compared to his own daughter - rant/help needed

163 replies

EveningCeremony · 24/01/2025 11:36

Hi Everyone,

I moved together with my bf who has a daughter from a previous relationship (turning 5 in 2 1/2 months) and my son who is 9 (turning 10 in two months). I am new to the blending families construct, so I would appreciate any advice and or help given.

My son and I moved to a different city (my's bfs) to live together seven months ago. While intitially the shift was smooth, there have been some difficulties with us adjusting to a different city. My son is still attending school in his own town, but of course it has been a huge adjustment for him. With finding new friends, living with a male adult (this is the first live-in serious relationship that I have had since separating from his father 5-6 years ago) and becoming a big brother to my bf's daughter who stays with us only every other weekend. My son stays with us every other week.

I have some challenges with my son already as it is which is totally normal at his age with food preferences and screen time. But overall he is a good kid. Doing well in school but is a bit sad sometimes due to a bully in school and feeling caught in the middle between his father and I as his dad hasn't quite moved on. He's really sweet to my bf's daughter and really tries his best. I've noticed perhaps since the fall that my bf's attitude towards my son change a little bit. He can be sarcastic towards him sometimes ( I notice immediately but my son doesn't), talks about his father in an indirect matter (calls his father lazy), and discplines my son differently than his own daughter. In fact he doesn't discipline his daughter at all and says that she's only four years old.

It's been a series of things that I have taken note of, but the pot sort of ran over a couple of days ago. First, his daughter's mom accused my son of calling the daughter dumb and ungrateful, which I find to be completely not true. My son adores his "little sister" and does things constantly to be nice and for her to be comfortable (even though it can be a bit much for him that she constantly needs to be the focus of attention, can be spoiled at times, or he needs his space and she constantly wants to be around him). On the otherhand, I've heard the daughter call all of us "dumb" when we have gently tried to correct her. Gently telling her to wear her gloves when it is minus degrees outside, snowing, and she was sick the week before....you get the idea. I have also heard her mother arguing with my bf calling him ungrateful, etc. So I know where this is coming from. Instead of opening a dialogue with all three of us (meaning the mother, my bf and I). He chooses to have a phone conversation with the mother alone in a different room, tells me what my son said to his daughter without me knowing the context of the situation, what was said, when it was said etc. All I was told is that the mother usually talks with the daughter about feelings, and the daughter felt sad because Benjamin called her dumb and ungrateful. When I asked why didn't the mother contact us about it earlier instead of informing my bf the day before the daughter is to come to us, he didn't answer. He didn't acknowledge the fact that the daughter facetimes with my son and the mother didn't bring it up then.

I didnt get a straight answer and was told that we are to speak to our son today about it. When I asked my bf to ask the daughter alone about what happened when he picked her up, I got no follow up with that either.

The pot really ran over last night when she was with us and we were watching television. The daughter had snacks and was smacking with her food really loudly. Normally it doesn't bother me, but it was really loud. If/when my son smacks his food, my bf immediately corrects him, tells him off, and even said one time that if he doesnt stop that he is going to eat in the kitchen alone. I sat and observed what would happen next, and he didn't say anything to his daughter at all and she was sitting in his lap. I kindly asked him to ask her to stop (as I don't think its my place as she only stays with us four days a month and she has her parents to discipline her). He told me that I could tell her. I responded with that I think its best if you tell her. Then immediately (the daughter doesn't speak english so she didn't understand what we were talking about) he switches the focus on me asking if I have a beef with him, or that I have been tense a lot lately, or why am I making a big deal about it. Or where's that warm and loving woman that I know. It left a not so good feeling in my body when he said those things, almost felt manipulative.

I kindly said that I just think that it is only fair that both children have the same set of rules. That he can't get angry at my son for eating his mouth open and threaten him, and not correct his daughter when she does the same thing. He can't get cross for eating all of his dinner but completely skip dinner for her and give her chocolate (when I cook meals for all of us). Or get angry with my son because he eats messy sometimes but he still spoon feeds his daughter at her age. Somethings of course age has to be taken in consideration, but its almost like he's treating his daughter as though she is a toddler and expecting my son to be a full grown adult.

I pointed out that this can cause, if not has caused already discomfort and resentment with my son staying with us as he sees he's treated differently.

My bf hasnt really gotten the chance to raise his daughter as she stays full time with her mother in a completely different city. So I understand that he may not understand the logistics of things. But something is telling me that this is different, based on his reactions and how he always tries to switch things around and say its my fault.

OP posts:
Choccyscofffy · 24/01/2025 15:30

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 24/01/2025 15:28

I couldn't get past the first paragraph.

Why have you forced your young son to live with this man, far from his school and friends?

Why do you only have him every other week?

The dad must have his son every other week.

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 24/01/2025 15:31

@Choccyscofffy unpopular opinion but over my dead body would my ex get 50/50

arethereanyleftatall · 24/01/2025 15:33

You got the harsh responses because this shouldn't need to be a question. It should be obvious without strangers help. You have somewhere to go, and your son is getting treated badly,it's surely pack your bags and go? No need to go via mumsnet.

Blending didn't work. Your boyfriend can't do it. Can't treat another child like his own. That's fine - neither could I. Neither could most people. that's why we don't do it in the first place Now you know.

Choccyscofffy · 24/01/2025 15:34

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 24/01/2025 15:31

@Choccyscofffy unpopular opinion but over my dead body would my ex get 50/50

If both parents love and care for their child then it’s fine. Is your ex a Disney dad?

lunar1 · 24/01/2025 15:35

You still have your apartment, a safe place for your son to grow up without being bullied in his own home. Your instincts are telling you that this situation isn't right, both you and he are really lucky that you can leave the situation for your apartment l.

Trumptonagain · 24/01/2025 15:36

This man is your boyfriend...

My son adores his "little sister.
and becoming a big brother to my bf's daughter
Your BF's DD is not your DS "little sister
she's your boyfriends daughter.

I've noticed perhaps since the fall that my bf's attitude towards my son change a little bit. He can be sarcastic towards him sometimes ( I notice immediately but my son doesn't), talks about his father in an indirect matter (calls his father lazy)

Your DP should be man enough to never be sarcastic or criticise your DS father while in your DS presence.

Sounds as though you need to move back out to your own place if this is what living together after 7 months is like already.

My son stays with us every other week.
This is confusing, are you the main carer, does your DS only stay with you EOW?

NiftyKoala · 24/01/2025 15:39

arethereanyleftatall · 24/01/2025 15:33

You got the harsh responses because this shouldn't need to be a question. It should be obvious without strangers help. You have somewhere to go, and your son is getting treated badly,it's surely pack your bags and go? No need to go via mumsnet.

Blending didn't work. Your boyfriend can't do it. Can't treat another child like his own. That's fine - neither could I. Neither could most people. that's why we don't do it in the first place Now you know.

I can't agree with this enough. The fact that you have to ask shows who comes first in your life and it sure isn't your poor boy. Your child should life in a home that's his safe place. Not a place where clearly he is not being treated right.

Chuchoter · 24/01/2025 15:39

Your poor son.

Please get out of this awful relationship and move back so that your little boy is back with his fri Mrs and well away from this hideous man.

Whachamacallit · 24/01/2025 15:47

I’m sorry op that it’s working out so badly. And I think you know yourself that it’s not going to get any easier as your ds becomes we a tween and a teen.

The poor kid has a lot to contend with already and your dp just isn’t up to the job of raising a sc. I don’t think you have any choice but to leave.

WoolySnail · 24/01/2025 15:47

Paisleyandpolkadots · 24/01/2025 15:03

I am not quite sure about the lion analogy - it's not as if OP is out hunting for fresh prey while the lion of the pack lolls at home.

My husband grew up with a "blended" family. He has warm relationships with both his stepmother and stepfather. His stepmother introduces me as her daughter in law. He refers to his half sisters as his sisters and they refer to him as their brother. So successful blended families really do exist.

In your case, it sounds likes your partner's true nature or parenting style is being revealed. He is not getting better. In fact, he sounds to be getting much worse. You say he can be sarcastic towards your son sometimes and talks about his father in an indirect matter calling him his father lazy). He has one set of rules for his daughter (whom he feeds with a spoon at age 5 while she sits on his lap?) and quite another set for your son. Apparently he is now working himself up about whether or not your son called his daughter dumb and ungrateful because the believes his daughter implicitly.

Comments like, "where's that warm and loving woman that I know" are designed to keep you in your place while he is being increasingly snide and sarcastic, especially to your son..

You've tried but I think you have to give up on this relationship. It is not healthy for either you or your son. Your partner is not a good and fair man or parent and he is getting worse rather than better..

If they are your DH's half siblings as opposed to step siblings why wouldn't they call each other brother and sisters , that's what they are!

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 24/01/2025 15:49

@Choccyscofffy I wouldn't say that. He's loving and caring, but I was always the default parent as he worked away when DC1 was small and we split around time DC2 was born. They're still young (4 and 2) and whereas I have a lovely house with their own bedrooms, he's in shared accommodation. He's accepted one overnight and one contact per week and I thank God for that. It would kill me to lose them half the time.

DaisyChain505 · 24/01/2025 15:51

If you have your own place just get out now. Every extra day you spend living with this man is effecting your son.

You did everything right but dating this man for a longer period of time before introducing him to your son and I’m sure it all seemed to be going well but unfortunately he has now shown his true colours 7 months into you living together and you need to protect your son. This man’s mask is slipping and it’s only going to get worse.

WoolySnail · 24/01/2025 15:52

Trumptonagain · 24/01/2025 15:36

This man is your boyfriend...

My son adores his "little sister.
and becoming a big brother to my bf's daughter
Your BF's DD is not your DS "little sister
she's your boyfriends daughter.

I've noticed perhaps since the fall that my bf's attitude towards my son change a little bit. He can be sarcastic towards him sometimes ( I notice immediately but my son doesn't), talks about his father in an indirect matter (calls his father lazy)

Your DP should be man enough to never be sarcastic or criticise your DS father while in your DS presence.

Sounds as though you need to move back out to your own place if this is what living together after 7 months is like already.

My son stays with us every other week.
This is confusing, are you the main carer, does your DS only stay with you EOW?

You've literally quoted her as saying she has him eow, but are asking if she has him eow? It's not confusing, he spends the other time with his father 🙂

JimHalpertsWife · 24/01/2025 16:02

Move back to your apartment. You can always come and stay with bf (if you aren't prepared to end rhe relationship) during the time your son is at his dad's.

Vaxtable · 24/01/2025 16:09

You put your child first

Go back to your old place as you still have it. Blending doesn’t work here and he is not going to change

up to you if you continue the relationship without living together, but you need to take your son away from this situation and put him first

tsmainsqueeze · 24/01/2025 16:10

EveningCeremony · 24/01/2025 12:12

That was really uncalled for. You don't know the circumstances of how we got into a relationship or what precautions I have taken beforehand.

We dated for almost a year before I even just introduced him to my son. My ex met him first.

I decided to keep my apartment in my old city in case things were to go south (still paying rent and god knows what for an empty place).

We have been together for almost four years now and he has never shown this type of behavior before. As I pointed out, it started happening a couple of months ago.

Thank God you have your own place , please go back ,your son deserves so much more than this.
I read that your boyfriend is sarcastic towards your son , no need to say anymore ,that alone is enough .
If you stay your sons self confidence will be slowly chipped away by that bully of a man.
This little boy has a right to a happy childhood.

bluegreygreen · 24/01/2025 16:33

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 24/01/2025 15:31

@Choccyscofffy unpopular opinion but over my dead body would my ex get 50/50

OP is in Scandinavia - as I understand it 50/50 is usually the default. It is one reason why posters are querying the small amount of time that her partner sees his daughter.

MeridianB · 24/01/2025 16:39

spoonfulofsugar1 · 24/01/2025 11:46

If this is what its like after 7 months, I can only imagine it getting worse. Your son's childhood is too important to risk all of this for the sake of living with your bf.
You dont mention how long you have been with your partner ?

This - esp the point about it being only 7 months in and will almost certainly get worse. This man has shown true colours now you are living together.

Your son is at a really crucial age. And the balance of power is off here because you have moved to a different area and into his home. I'm really glad you kept your own home.

Wonderi · 24/01/2025 16:39

Obviously a 4yo and 10yo are going to have some different rules.

A 4yo is going to struggle a lot more with eating with their mouths closed than a 10yo would for example.

But I am absolutely shocked that you let someone treat your son this way.

He should not be disciplining your son at all.

What were you doing when he was telling your son off and threatening to make him eat alone?

I’m not sure which one of you I’m more disgusted at tbh.
I can’t imagine my bf ever speaking to my DD like that!

Your poor son has had to move home, deal with school bullies and now a bully at home.
It’s absolutely awful.

Well done for keeping your apartment (but it does tell me that you obviously had concerns about this man).
Move back there.

Sometimes blended families don’t work.

Wonderi · 24/01/2025 16:42

Notmycircusnotmyotter · 24/01/2025 15:31

@Choccyscofffy unpopular opinion but over my dead body would my ex get 50/50

Unless your ex is abusive to his kids, then that’s not putting your kids needs before your own though.
Which is what OP is doing too.

Sometimes you have to put your own needs/wants second to what’s best for your kids.

Donttellempike · 24/01/2025 17:04

AmethystRuby · 24/01/2025 12:18

i think now dont quote me - but OP was actually looking for some advice rather than someone telling her she's putting dick above her child. absolutely vile comment.

And one I didn’t make. But if the cap fits

AmethystRuby · 24/01/2025 17:14

Donttellempike · 24/01/2025 17:04

And one I didn’t make. But if the cap fits

didnt say you did. but you commented under that head so one can assume that you support it

catin8oots · 24/01/2025 17:46

I made the comment about OP choosing dick over her kid, before you all start arguing.

Can anyone prove me wrong?

MyGhastIsFlabbered · 24/01/2025 17:46

For all those people saying OP should move it's not that simple. DH and I were going through problems and on the verge of splitting up. But DCs were traumatised at the idea of their stepsister leaving and we had three children to consider. It's never black and white. And if OP wasn't concerned she wouldn't have posted here would she?

DiddlyDiddly · 24/01/2025 18:10

@EveningCeremony The best thing I read in all your posts is a) your concern for equity in terms of how your son is treated by your partner and b) that you have kept your own, separate home on. That is brilliant.

Please leave and go live in that home again with your son.

This situation is never going to get better and will only get worse. Your DP is petty and unkind, showing favoritism and unduly punishing your son in small, micro-aggressive ways. This is no good for your son.

Please leave as soon as you can.

Ignore harridans attacking you. That's just a waste of your time reading that crap.