Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Step-parenting

Connect with other Mumsnetters here for step-parenting advice and support.

My bf is treating my son unfairly compared to his own daughter - rant/help needed

163 replies

EveningCeremony · 24/01/2025 11:36

Hi Everyone,

I moved together with my bf who has a daughter from a previous relationship (turning 5 in 2 1/2 months) and my son who is 9 (turning 10 in two months). I am new to the blending families construct, so I would appreciate any advice and or help given.

My son and I moved to a different city (my's bfs) to live together seven months ago. While intitially the shift was smooth, there have been some difficulties with us adjusting to a different city. My son is still attending school in his own town, but of course it has been a huge adjustment for him. With finding new friends, living with a male adult (this is the first live-in serious relationship that I have had since separating from his father 5-6 years ago) and becoming a big brother to my bf's daughter who stays with us only every other weekend. My son stays with us every other week.

I have some challenges with my son already as it is which is totally normal at his age with food preferences and screen time. But overall he is a good kid. Doing well in school but is a bit sad sometimes due to a bully in school and feeling caught in the middle between his father and I as his dad hasn't quite moved on. He's really sweet to my bf's daughter and really tries his best. I've noticed perhaps since the fall that my bf's attitude towards my son change a little bit. He can be sarcastic towards him sometimes ( I notice immediately but my son doesn't), talks about his father in an indirect matter (calls his father lazy), and discplines my son differently than his own daughter. In fact he doesn't discipline his daughter at all and says that she's only four years old.

It's been a series of things that I have taken note of, but the pot sort of ran over a couple of days ago. First, his daughter's mom accused my son of calling the daughter dumb and ungrateful, which I find to be completely not true. My son adores his "little sister" and does things constantly to be nice and for her to be comfortable (even though it can be a bit much for him that she constantly needs to be the focus of attention, can be spoiled at times, or he needs his space and she constantly wants to be around him). On the otherhand, I've heard the daughter call all of us "dumb" when we have gently tried to correct her. Gently telling her to wear her gloves when it is minus degrees outside, snowing, and she was sick the week before....you get the idea. I have also heard her mother arguing with my bf calling him ungrateful, etc. So I know where this is coming from. Instead of opening a dialogue with all three of us (meaning the mother, my bf and I). He chooses to have a phone conversation with the mother alone in a different room, tells me what my son said to his daughter without me knowing the context of the situation, what was said, when it was said etc. All I was told is that the mother usually talks with the daughter about feelings, and the daughter felt sad because Benjamin called her dumb and ungrateful. When I asked why didn't the mother contact us about it earlier instead of informing my bf the day before the daughter is to come to us, he didn't answer. He didn't acknowledge the fact that the daughter facetimes with my son and the mother didn't bring it up then.

I didnt get a straight answer and was told that we are to speak to our son today about it. When I asked my bf to ask the daughter alone about what happened when he picked her up, I got no follow up with that either.

The pot really ran over last night when she was with us and we were watching television. The daughter had snacks and was smacking with her food really loudly. Normally it doesn't bother me, but it was really loud. If/when my son smacks his food, my bf immediately corrects him, tells him off, and even said one time that if he doesnt stop that he is going to eat in the kitchen alone. I sat and observed what would happen next, and he didn't say anything to his daughter at all and she was sitting in his lap. I kindly asked him to ask her to stop (as I don't think its my place as she only stays with us four days a month and she has her parents to discipline her). He told me that I could tell her. I responded with that I think its best if you tell her. Then immediately (the daughter doesn't speak english so she didn't understand what we were talking about) he switches the focus on me asking if I have a beef with him, or that I have been tense a lot lately, or why am I making a big deal about it. Or where's that warm and loving woman that I know. It left a not so good feeling in my body when he said those things, almost felt manipulative.

I kindly said that I just think that it is only fair that both children have the same set of rules. That he can't get angry at my son for eating his mouth open and threaten him, and not correct his daughter when she does the same thing. He can't get cross for eating all of his dinner but completely skip dinner for her and give her chocolate (when I cook meals for all of us). Or get angry with my son because he eats messy sometimes but he still spoon feeds his daughter at her age. Somethings of course age has to be taken in consideration, but its almost like he's treating his daughter as though she is a toddler and expecting my son to be a full grown adult.

I pointed out that this can cause, if not has caused already discomfort and resentment with my son staying with us as he sees he's treated differently.

My bf hasnt really gotten the chance to raise his daughter as she stays full time with her mother in a completely different city. So I understand that he may not understand the logistics of things. But something is telling me that this is different, based on his reactions and how he always tries to switch things around and say its my fault.

OP posts:
EveningCeremony · 24/01/2025 13:48

Freeme31 · 24/01/2025 13:35

This is difficult OP If you have discussed with bf and see no change you may need to rethink this relationship. Is it possible to go to your own apartment when his daughter is with him hiving your son a break to see old friends and him time to solely spend with his daughter?

Yes it is a difficult situation and like you said, based on the discussion that I had with my bf yesterday it is causing me to rethink everything.

It is still possible to go to my own apartment. It's only 45-1hr away. We do still have playdates with his friends in our hometown so he is not completely cut off from them. Tonight he is supposed to have a sleep over here at home with one of his classmates.

The only issue regarding friends is that I was hoping to establish a network for him here as well. Through sports or extra curricular activities that interest him. The bf wants to do things together as a family, but I have been creating a bit of distance there by wanting us, meaning my son and I to do things on our own and have quality time, or hang out with old friends and their kids.

OP posts:
Perplexin · 24/01/2025 13:49

When your son gets older he will either remember 1 of 2 things.

His Mum choosing her boyfriend and not protecting him from an ass thus making him live a nightmare childhood.

Or

He'll remember when you chose him and saved him living with an abusive ass.

The choice is yours and the choice you make will impact how your son sees you in the future. Choose your son.

SomethingFun · 24/01/2025 13:49

He sounds awful. He can’t keep up a facade of nice guy 24/7 so he’s taking it out on your ds. Loads of people move in together and realise it’s not for them. Go back to your flat and rethink what all this is for.

Snorlaxo · 24/01/2025 13:56

People are saying that you are prioritizing sex over your son because you’re still there. What has stopped you from going back to your home ? I’m guessing that the answer is the time that you’ve invested in the relationship.
You must know that children shouldn’t live like your son does ? The adults in his life should be improving it and he is clearly not

Terrribletwos · 24/01/2025 13:58

EveningCeremony · 24/01/2025 12:12

That was really uncalled for. You don't know the circumstances of how we got into a relationship or what precautions I have taken beforehand.

We dated for almost a year before I even just introduced him to my son. My ex met him first.

I decided to keep my apartment in my old city in case things were to go south (still paying rent and god knows what for an empty place).

We have been together for almost four years now and he has never shown this type of behavior before. As I pointed out, it started happening a couple of months ago.

Well, the fact that he was ok before is irrelevant. He's an arse now and you need to leave. Do you still have the other apartment?

reichs79 · 24/01/2025 13:58

Please think about your son in this. Don't put your partner and his child before him.

Mrsbloggz · 24/01/2025 13:58

EveningCeremony · 24/01/2025 13:44

Thank you for your understanding and your concrete criticism for my situation. And thank you for confirming some thoughts that I had been already feeling at this moment. He sees my son and I inferior to him. Based on his actions and his responses last night to what I had asked him to do.

Families blended or not usually have discussions or work together to find a game plan to how to move forward for the best interest of everyone involved. He was not helping to find a solution but to put the blame on me.

@EveningCeremony
In an earlier post you said:
But I agree that he should never disrespect my son or put him down. I couldn't imagine doing that to his daughter. I have no resentment towards his daughter whatsoever. She is adorable, funny, can be a bit entitled sometimes but that is not her fault.
This tells me that you're a kind, decent, do the right thing sort of person, as such your default position is probably that other people will be similar- you treat them kindly they are kind in return etc. And this (ime) is what leads to the feeling that if you could only find the right words to explain things to him he will understand and he will repay your kindness and understanding with the same.
However, people with dominant personalities (many of whom are men) often have a 'win at all costs' mentality, they don't see a kind person they see a weak person who is easy to exploit.
I'd say that this man is not capable of functioning as an equal partner he will only try to dominate, he will take any opportunity he sees to work the situation to his advantage to make sure that he and his offspring (who he sees as an extension of himself) profit at the expense of you and your offspring. He sees / experiences your son as an extension of you so being unkind to your son is a way of being unkind to you by proxy- if you see what I mean.
I hope that makes sense, I am just speaking from my own experience and understanding of things.

CagneyNYPD1 · 24/01/2025 14:00

@EveningCeremony I think you are right to ask for advice. You know that your bf's behaviour isn't right. You did the right things - waited before introducing him to your son, building a relationship before moving in together.

But clearly, this isn't the man for you. And even more clearly, this isn't the man who will be a decent step father to your son.

It happens to many, many people. With or without children. The reality of living together just doesn't work.

You did something else right - you kept your own place and your son in his school. Move back ASAP.

Terrribletwos · 24/01/2025 14:02

@EveningCeremony oh I see you have retained your apartment. Move back.

You seem to have moved to facilitate your son's activities/sport.

CagneyNYPD1 · 24/01/2025 14:07

Another thought... if you do stay, you risk a serious problem for your son. He will get bigger and more physically stronger as he moves through his teens. I have read many threads over the years where step fathers (and even biological ones) feel threatened by this growing young man under "their" roof, challenging "their" rules and dominance. Toxic masculinity and all that. it never ends well. A crystal ball into your future?

CharSiu · 24/01/2025 14:07

Blended families can work but I think it’s rarer than most would care to admit.

This is not going to work out, you need to break up

Mrsbloggz · 24/01/2025 14:09

One thing that sticks in my mind is a wildlife documentary years ago back in the 1990s. The male lion wins over the female lion by playing with her cubs, she then allows him to mate with her. As soon as she is pregnant he kills and eats her existing cubs so that she focuses all her time and resources on preserving his genetic material.

We often see a form of this behavior with men who get involved with women who have children by another man. He's nice to them at first in order to win her over but when he has her trust and loyalty he gets to work prioritising his genes over those of another male.

Floralnomad · 24/01/2025 14:09

Well , whatever the rights and wrongs , this isn’t working so you and your son need to move out .

Whydoeseveryonewanttoargue · 24/01/2025 14:12

I agree with what most other posters have said but would add a few things.

  1. Stop with the over patience with your BFs daughter and set boundaries that are clear to anyone.
  2. Stop being a passive observer and then complaining because you don’t like the outcome.
  3. Grow a pair and stop letting these things happen and go on in your house. Your son’s happiness is at stake.
  4. And discipline his daughter. You don’t have to be mean or shout a simple ‘darling in this house we don’t smack our food so can you please stop’.

Seriously OP you are enabling this behaviour by sitting idly by. Take control. Have a ‘family’ meeting. Set our clear boundaries with rewards and consequences. Get your BF onboard beforehand. If he says no, you have the answer about the future of your relationship.

I cannot stand this willingness to list a whole enormous rant on what a dirtbag the BF is and how it’s allowed to happen and how it isn’t okay etc and DO NOTHING ABOUT IT. Do something for the sake of your son.

Channellingsophistication · 24/01/2025 14:13

You are right to be upset about this. BF is not treating your son fairly and it’s not going to change. It’s not going to get better. It will be more challenging as your son reaches his teens. BF seems to be showing no consideration either for the fact that your son has had a major upheaval in his life.

Great that you have kept your apartment. I think you would be better off moving back there with your son. I suspect your son will be much happier and probably relieved…

Bigcat25 · 24/01/2025 14:16

Just dump him. It's already hard enough for your son to move cities, and go from house to house one week to the next, as well as living with this immature asshole. He wants your son to act like a grown up without doing the same himself. Your son will feel on eggshells in his own home. Don't do this to him op.

Hopelesscase32 · 24/01/2025 14:23

Yeah I couldn't read all of this. Yet another woman not putting her child's needs first.

ChonkyRabbit · 24/01/2025 14:27

Dump this dickhead, go back to your home, and don't make your son live with any other men.

NiftyKoala · 24/01/2025 14:30

Your son has to come first.

Mummyoflittledragon · 24/01/2025 14:33

Now that you see he’s treating you and your ds as inferior, you really cannot stay in this relationship. It’s become untenable, a toxic mess. Well done for planning ahead and not letting your apartment go. This means you can leave, escape and go back to your old home. I hope you do and your ds will be able slot straight back into where he left off. Perhaps he will miss the little girl. But it sounds as if a little time and distance will heal.

Onlycoffee · 24/01/2025 14:33

It left a not so good feeling in my body when he said those things, almost felt manipulative.
Listen to your insights.
It was manipulative, amd misogynistic..He only wants to hear from you when you are warm and amenable, as if you are there for his convenience only.

Bananalanacake · 24/01/2025 14:33

If you love your DP have a relationship living separately. When the youngest of your 2 DC turns 18 you can talk about living together.

Reducesaltpls · 24/01/2025 14:35

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

N4ish · 24/01/2025 14:37

Feel sorry for both the powerless children stuck in the middle of this mess. Your son would be far happier living just with you in your apartment. This attempt to blend families is not working.

Reducesaltpls · 24/01/2025 14:38

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Swipe left for the next trending thread