Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Secondary education

Connect with other parents whose children are starting secondary school on this forum.

GCSE in year admission in Harrow

201 replies

SuratNuJaman · 15/09/2025 03:06

For a kid starting their GCSE year, can he/she travel from Europe and join an English Government run school a month before GCSE exams. Does the Government/Council have a "duty of care" which requires them to place the kid in a school and get them to take thir GCSE exams?

Is there any cut off deadline that the kid must be in a school by say December, for them to take their GCSE exams?

Happy to read legislation myself. If someone here has Administrative experience in a Council with admissions, would love to hear from them. The council for the kid will be Harrow.

OP posts:
HarrietBond · 16/09/2025 06:29

SuratNuJaman · 16/09/2025 06:27

Yes, unforuntate and sad and this we suspect is to make the whole system "fair", and the computer nerds have taken over. But this is why parents can have an advantage because of knowledge they possess.

It sounds highly unlikely to be honest. And likely to result in longer term problems. Contextual schemes usually require a combination of factors.

SuratNuJaman · 16/09/2025 06:31

HarrietBond · 16/09/2025 06:26

You misunderstand ‘privately’. Not through a private school but private entry directly to exam boards via exam centres. Your initial request was how to obtain GCSEs rather than iGCSEs I believe?

I understand, the fee is ~£150 per exam with some centers charging more and some charging less.

OP posts:
HarrietBond · 16/09/2025 07:16

So that’s your answer. You just need to make sure the child has studied the right syllabus for the exams.

MBL · 16/09/2025 07:41

You haven't really addressed some of the points here. Unless your child takes a very narrow range of subjects there is stuff to do before the exams so they would need at least one year to 18 months doing the course. Unless they do igcses. State schools don't take igcses, they aren't permitted to.

HarrietBond · 16/09/2025 07:46

I though they could but can’t include them in their reporting, so obviously don’t as it then affects their results?

TeenToTwenties · 16/09/2025 07:55

English Language has a speaking and listening component done in advance.
Science has practicals that the school need to sign off as having been done (doesn't it?).
MFL speaking exams can happen outside of the main exam timeframe, as does food tech practicals, drama.
Geography has a paper on a field trip (or something).

For too long things like internships have been about who you know and whether you can afford to work for no pay. I'm not sure I entirely agree with the 'state school only' approach but it certainly balances out the years where private school pupils have been disproportionately able to access them.

RampantIvy · 16/09/2025 07:56

HarrietBond · 16/09/2025 07:16

So that’s your answer. You just need to make sure the child has studied the right syllabus for the exams.

Edited

This ^^

And the right topics within each syllabus.

@SuratNuJaman You are under the misapprehension that all year 11s take the exact same exams.

We have different exam boards covering different topics, the main ones being AQA, OCR, WJEC, CCEA and Edexel. The syllabi may be similar but not exactly the same. Then there are different topics within each syllabus. Then a choice of different topics within each exam board, especially for humanities subjects.

I lifted the following from an AI explanation which explins it very well:

It's crucial to know your specific exam board so you can access the correct revision materials and past papers. Using papers from the wrong board can lead to confusion and poor preparation.

The phrasing of questions and the specific way content is assessed can differ significantly between boards.

Knowing your board helps you understand the specific format and style of questions you can expect in your exams.

labradorservant · 16/09/2025 08:01

SuratNuJaman · 16/09/2025 04:28

Here the post GCSE world has been mapped out. It is just this GCSE from a State School which is the point.

Some on this thread have alluded to "Gaming the system to save ~£3000 of private GCSE fees". Actually, if anyone knows of a way that the parents can pay the council ~£3000 and kid gets to sit GCSE exams then it is win win. The kid will not attend one day of school and thus no additional school resources will be used. And Council will make a profit as I am sure that the cost billed to council from the various boards for exams is less than £1500 per kid.

So you want to go on roll, do the GCSEs but not turn up to school except to do the exams?
This will trigger all sorts or attendance alerts. Also working as in invigilator I am not sure the exams office/head of years will be happy having an ‘unknown’ student just turn up on the day. It’s not a pick and mix service.

OccasionalHope · 16/09/2025 08:01

SuratNuJaman · 16/09/2025 06:27

Yes, unforuntate and sad and this we suspect is to make the whole system "fair", and the computer nerds have taken over. But this is why parents can have an advantage because of knowledge they possess.

Hinestly though, I’m not at all sure they do have this knowledge. This is why I would like to know what it is they wish to apply for, because I would be very sceptical indeed that sitting the exam at a state school without having been educated there would even work, while the child’s results will undoubtedly be worse than they would otherwise get because of not having studied for the correct syllabus, quite apart from any Coursework or practicals. I would be willing to bet they would need a reference from the school for a start.

EG the Sutton Trust Pathways to Professions specifies that the child must have ON!Y attended state schools their entire education.

HarrietBond · 16/09/2025 08:08

TeenToTwenties · 16/09/2025 07:55

English Language has a speaking and listening component done in advance.
Science has practicals that the school need to sign off as having been done (doesn't it?).
MFL speaking exams can happen outside of the main exam timeframe, as does food tech practicals, drama.
Geography has a paper on a field trip (or something).

For too long things like internships have been about who you know and whether you can afford to work for no pay. I'm not sure I entirely agree with the 'state school only' approach but it certainly balances out the years where private school pupils have been disproportionately able to access them.

Absolutely. To counter the chuntering about the state school only internships for the civil service, my own corner of the public sector used to give paid internships to friends of the boss’ children, who attended a specific public school. We’re on a journey and I’m very pleased to see it.

Dearover · 16/09/2025 08:23

I really do feel sorry for "the kid" unless of course they are also a robot like the adults in their life. The adults appear to be under the misapprehension that "the kid" will shine again every other applicant. Let me assure you, they won't.

SuratNuJaman · 16/09/2025 08:35

HarrietBond · 16/09/2025 08:08

Absolutely. To counter the chuntering about the state school only internships for the civil service, my own corner of the public sector used to give paid internships to friends of the boss’ children, who attended a specific public school. We’re on a journey and I’m very pleased to see it.

Jobs for the Boys. A global phenomenon.

OP posts:
HarrietBond · 16/09/2025 08:49

SuratNuJaman · 16/09/2025 08:35

Jobs for the Boys. A global phenomenon.

And one that is being very slowly dismantled in the UK. It will never disappear but things can and will be better. The fewer mediocre posh men at the top the better for us all.

clary · 16/09/2025 09:29

Yes agree strongly with @TeenToTwenties and @HarrietBond – even if we go down the route of "these opportunities will only go to xxx students" where xxx indicates some level of disadvantage (and yes I know it will be a blunt instrument) then that must be a positive thing in terms of addressing the years of inequity of opportunity.

I’m also in favour of positive discrimination to try to address the appalling gender pay gap in some sectors (the NHS for example). But that's another thread.

OP you don’t seem to be fully understanding what people are saying here as you politely thank them for telling you that this is a Very Bad Idea. Please try to dissuade the parents from this as it will not benefit “the kid” in the end.

And yy, tho there is not much coursework in GCSEs now, there is some; MFL speaking exams are often done in April, practical CW is done in advance as well.

ConBatulations · 16/09/2025 09:31

Agree with most of this. Schools will do different exam boards, different syllabus, different topics. English language has a spoken language requirement that some schools will do in year 10. Sciences have a practical element that needs to be signed off. Languages have a speaking exam that is before the main exam season and not all schools offer the same languages. Subjects like PE and music have non examined assessments. Geography has fieldwork, case studies and pre release resources. History has literally hundreds of topic combination possibilities. Maths probably ok.

Without knowing which school the child will go to then how will the child be prepared even if a school accepts them and puts in the extra time to get them through? If the parents have such intimate knowledge of the requirements of this mystery career then they should have moved the child before year 10 to maximise their chances of doing well in their exams. There are some excellent state schools in England where top students get multiple grade 9s.

Allthefruit · 16/09/2025 09:34

I'm curious who this child is @SuratNuJaman who you state is not your own child yet you are wildly overinvested in their career?

Comefromaway · 16/09/2025 09:54

OP, what they want is not possible. Even if the child is allowed to sit the exams at a state school, they will not be classed as a state educated student. The liklihood of a school agreeing to enter them AND that school entering them for the same syllabi as they have previously studied is minimal. You might just about get away with it in maths and possibly English Literature if the set texts align but English Language requires a speaking test taken a lot earlier in the year and as others have said science practicals etc.

Schools are judged on how many young people on roll pass 8 or more GCSE's. Therefore 8 subjects is usually the minimum number of subjects to be taken which needs to include maths, English, all three sciences (combined or single) and a humanities subject (history/geography/computer science).

In my local area if a child appeared in the spring of Year 11 the education authority would find them a place at a local college via something called Alternative Provision that offers a 14-19 route. They would be placed on a 1 year GCSE pathway aimed at young people who have either been home educated or come from abroad with the aim to take enough subjects to then progress onto A levels/Level 3 btecs.

Comefromaway · 16/09/2025 09:58

Harrow council say for their in year admissions that consider a student for a year 11 place they have to have a very strong, valid reason for changing school at this stage of their education.

titchy · 16/09/2025 10:11

SuratNuJaman · 16/09/2025 04:23

The "other ways" have been taken care of.

Even this algo hiccup if can be taken care of, will be done.

Are you going to say what this programme is at all? Because I can virtually guarantee you there is no such algorithm.

HarrietBond · 16/09/2025 10:13

I assume whatever it is doesn't allow for iGCSEs and there is a filter that means no CV/transcript including them will go through. But I agree that it seems highly unlikely that this is the end of any selection.

titchy · 16/09/2025 10:14

I do feel sorry for this (fictional?) kid though, having his career already mapped out at 15, by parents and others who think they have insider information, but do not.

Eccle80 · 16/09/2025 10:59

@SuratNuJaman what GCSE subjects are they planning to take? As already said by others, it’s hard to see how this won’t impact on the grades due to syllabus being different to what they have studied, and also be very stressful for them.

TaTuirseOrm · 16/09/2025 11:12

SuratNuJaman · 16/09/2025 04:16

There you go. For all the posters here. If this situation existed post-Industrial revolution, Britain would not have had an empire.

That would be a good thing! Maybe then some of us would still be speaking our own language 😒

NutButterOnToast · 16/09/2025 12:32

There's a better chance of obtaining a Y11 place if the parents apply now.

The deadline for funding is Thursday 2nd October.

If "the kid" can be enrolled somewhere on or before that date at least the school will obtain funding for them. After that date they won't get any money, and GCSE exams are expensive.

TheHazelCritic · 16/09/2025 17:00

RampantIvy · 15/09/2025 21:45

Given that the child will have been studying iGCSE syllabi if they are not in the UK and will likely have studied different topics with in each subject it seems like the child is going to be set up to fail or do rather badly.

The whole idea is badly thought out and pointles.

I think @SuratNuJaman thinks that all 16 year olds sit exactly the same exams everywhere. They don't.

Depends on the subject, Igcse math isn't much different from gcse math. Even if it is different they could catch up since they have already finished studying the Igcse.

Swipe left for the next trending thread