Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Should I end our engagement over his refusal to manage his health?

301 replies

Omron · 06/09/2026 13:34

Engaged for 6 months, been together over 2 years. Don't know if I'm getting the ick or being picky or what it is. I've known how he was about his health pretty much from around 6 months into dating him, I hoped he would take a different stance, but it's driving me up the pole now.

This will be the second time around for both of us. Both divorced. We are in our early fifties. I am in fairly good shape, very sporty, decent diet with the occasional night of a few drinks and a takeaway, but mainly lots of healthy food and have cut right back on sugar earlier this year. Well woman check last year showed everything to be good, the only medication I am on is HRT, otherwise I would be homicidal. Don't quote me on that 😂

Fiance has high cholesterol and is borderline diabetic. It keeps pushing over into type 2 numbers but then goes back down, The GP is checking it once a year, which I personally don't feel is enough. He has been on a statin for nearly 18 months and it got his number right now from 6.5 to somewhere in the just under 4 region, which is brilliant. Howwwwwwever, a few things are happening.. still happening.... and he is so stubborn about taking advice and taking care of himself that I am on the brink of ending the engagement.

His sugar and fat consumption are ridiculous. They have been for many years since before we met, so it's nothing to do with me or my behaviours. Despite knowing he has high cholesterol and is on the statin, it's almost as if taking the statin leaves him free to just consume as much saturated fat still as he wants. He fries chips in beef dripping, which he hasn't changed in over 2 years, he refuses to drink semi-skimmed milk, eats entire packets of salami for lunch, washed down with a pint of full fat milk, pours all the fat from meat onto his plate, even if he has grilled bacon, he pours the fat onto his bread. This is why his cholesterol was 6.5. I've tried to explain to him that the statin is getting the number down, but ideally he should do it himself. My Uncle had the same issue and we helped him change his diet and he didn't need a statin in the end.

He refuses to change and makes vomiting sounds and pulls a face when I put skimmed milk into my tea.... which leads me onto..... his sugar consumption. When I met him, he was putting 4 heaped spoons of sugar into his tea, which he makes super strong in quite a small mug, no teapot in sight... and of course puts full fat milk into it. He drinks over 10 to 15 cups a day like this, sometimes coffee, which he puts lots of sugar into as well. If a packet of biscuits are in his house, he will eat them all. Same thing for a cake meant to feed a family.. think the Asda boxed cakes. He has a compulsion to finish them.

I know a fair bit about diabetes as I lost a good friend to complications of the disease, and I hate to go on about it, but I suppose I'm trying to make him realise that yes, he could lose a leg, his eyesight, his kidneys could pack up. Right now his kidney function is OK, but if he keeps on keeping on, it won't be. His blood sugar is 47, which I believe is right at the top end of the borderline range. He has cut back the sugar in his tea, but is still consuming half a jar of jam per day on bread, smeared with thick butter. Yesterday he finished a large jar of jam that he only bought 2 days ago.

His attitude is that there is a pill for it and if he does get diabetes, he will be OK if he just takes it. I've tried to explain what can happen on that pill, and that your pancreas can eventually give up and you end up on insulin for the rest of your life.... or worse. He says he will do something about it if it gets worse, but this is already the 11th hour in my mind, or for anyone with an ounce of common sense about their health.

The latest development is he has jaundice in his eyes, which I noticed a few days ago. He noticed it too. He also has blurred vision. Of course it can mean many things. But the statin could be damaging his liver, it could be a bile issue, something else. But jaundice should never be ignored. I've urged him to see a GP. He hasn't made an appointment. He also has extreme fatigue that seems to be getting worse and worse. I almost drove him to A&E yesterday as I was so worried.

I'm sure I don't even need to mention the ED that happens due to diabetes, but he doesn't even seem bothered about getting the number down for that. I thought that might sway him, a reason to change, but it hasn't.

Today I have decided to back off. I woke up and felt so angry that he doesn't care enough about our shared future to take care of himself better. I'm starting to feel like his mother and not his partner and that's not what a relationship is about.

OP posts:
WellThatIsABitMad · 11/09/2026 17:16

Good for you, let him get on with it. Enjoy the peace.

Ileithyia · 11/09/2026 17:32

Omron · 11/09/2026 15:00

He has an eye problem but it's nothing serious. He finally got an appointment and did the right thing.

I've broken it off though.

He did the song and dance about not doing anything about his blood sugar unless he gets symptoms and all the usual bla bla bla I've heard countless times before. Made him a coffee and he pulled a face over one sugar and complained. I told him be my guest, can't be doing watching someone be so reckless and pig ignorant about their own health. Crack on.

“He did the song and dance about not doing anything about his blood sugar unless he gets symptoms and all the usual bla bla bla I've heard countless times before.”

Oh for goodness sake. By the time he's symptomatic there’s been significant damage done to his health. What an idiot.

Well done for not tolerating his wilful stupidity any longer. I hope you feel liberated, you deserve to live a good life, and he would’ve dragged you down into being a nursemaid.

MagicalBagPuss · 11/09/2026 18:48

Well done, you need to be free to look after yourself and live your own life without a human millstone pulling you down.

EvieBB · 11/09/2026 19:37

As per usual for MN, there is so much empathy on here for people with addictions/compulsions 🙄NOT

Meteorite87 · 11/09/2026 20:36

Well done on making the decision that will best protect your own stress levels @Omron

Itsthewoluff · 11/09/2026 21:46

How did he respond?
How are you feeling, even though you know it’s for the best?

EvieBB · 12/09/2026 00:40

Meteorite87 · 11/09/2026 20:36

Well done on making the decision that will best protect your own stress levels @Omron

Indeed. OP absolutely must do what is right for her own mental health ...but in the meantime she might want to direct her soon to be ex to www.radiantrecovery.com for practical tips on how to physiologically help him with his out of control sugar cravings

Bananacrepewithnuts · 12/09/2026 04:06

hattie43 · 06/09/2026 13:37

I think your attitudes to diet and health are so different there’d be conflict . Whether that can be overcome only you know but one of you’s going to have to compromise.

Edited

I agree your views on diet and lifestyle are poles apart and it's only going to get worse as he gets older.

Get out now before you drive yourself mad analysing everything he puts in his mouth. Over time he will become less and less attractive to you.

My DH has been overweight for years I've tried coaxing/nagging you name it but he won't change. Oh and yes ED too.

Leopoldd · 12/09/2026 07:40

EvieBB · 11/09/2026 19:37

As per usual for MN, there is so much empathy on here for people with addictions/compulsions 🙄NOT

As per usual no understanding of how addictions / compulsions are a ‘family disease’ AA define alcoholism not by what, why, where, when someone drinks but solely on its impact on the important relationships in that persons life. The OP will literally be shouldering the physical, emotional and financial inevitable consequences of this man’s choices for the rest of her life. Surely she has the right to choose, as much as he does, to not have a life wiping someone’s arse, funding their life when they are incapacitated to work as well as all her spare time drained as a carer as she enters older age.

AAlon also encourage ‘Detach with love’ - which is that not everyone in the family needs to get their lives hijacked and sucked down into the spiral of the chaos and dysfunction of the addict and to step away emotionally and/or physically is import also for the addict so that you are not inadvertently enabling.

The OPs partner is in some sort of emotionally stunted toxic pathological demand avoidance standoff with the OP which is distracting from his sole responsibility and inadvertently entrenching his addiction. I suspect there is/was some sort of dysfunctional dynamic with his parents in childhood which is unconsciously being re-enacted here. OP would be doing him a favour to pull the comfy rug from beneath him - so he can get on with dealing with his issue alone seeking professional help if needed which is seemingly life long and has nothing to do with OP.

Many addicts have notoriously selfish behaviours driven by their compulsive and impulsive needs which preoccupy them. No benefit for anyone (as AA endorse) for the OP to be another cog inadvertently turning the wheels of his issues.

The OP needs to reflect on her own sense of self, emotional capacity etc to understand how she has drifted into this co-dependent role more than once - best to explore this in therapy and fix this clink sooner rather than later.

Soontobe60 · 12/09/2026 08:41

Omron · 11/09/2026 15:00

He has an eye problem but it's nothing serious. He finally got an appointment and did the right thing.

I've broken it off though.

He did the song and dance about not doing anything about his blood sugar unless he gets symptoms and all the usual bla bla bla I've heard countless times before. Made him a coffee and he pulled a face over one sugar and complained. I told him be my guest, can't be doing watching someone be so reckless and pig ignorant about their own health. Crack on.

Op, whilst you’re clearly worried about him, in many ways you are being very controlling. Telling someone whom you supposedly love that you will leave them if they don’t change their diet is extremely controlling. Presumably he has been like this ever since you met him - if you find it off putting now that’s ok, it’s time to leave.

Soontobe60 · 12/09/2026 08:42

Leopoldd · 12/09/2026 07:40

As per usual no understanding of how addictions / compulsions are a ‘family disease’ AA define alcoholism not by what, why, where, when someone drinks but solely on its impact on the important relationships in that persons life. The OP will literally be shouldering the physical, emotional and financial inevitable consequences of this man’s choices for the rest of her life. Surely she has the right to choose, as much as he does, to not have a life wiping someone’s arse, funding their life when they are incapacitated to work as well as all her spare time drained as a carer as she enters older age.

AAlon also encourage ‘Detach with love’ - which is that not everyone in the family needs to get their lives hijacked and sucked down into the spiral of the chaos and dysfunction of the addict and to step away emotionally and/or physically is import also for the addict so that you are not inadvertently enabling.

The OPs partner is in some sort of emotionally stunted toxic pathological demand avoidance standoff with the OP which is distracting from his sole responsibility and inadvertently entrenching his addiction. I suspect there is/was some sort of dysfunctional dynamic with his parents in childhood which is unconsciously being re-enacted here. OP would be doing him a favour to pull the comfy rug from beneath him - so he can get on with dealing with his issue alone seeking professional help if needed which is seemingly life long and has nothing to do with OP.

Many addicts have notoriously selfish behaviours driven by their compulsive and impulsive needs which preoccupy them. No benefit for anyone (as AA endorse) for the OP to be another cog inadvertently turning the wheels of his issues.

The OP needs to reflect on her own sense of self, emotional capacity etc to understand how she has drifted into this co-dependent role more than once - best to explore this in therapy and fix this clink sooner rather than later.

The OP knew what he was like when she decided to fall for him - it comes as no surprise.

ladyofroo · 12/09/2026 08:57

EvieBB · 11/09/2026 19:37

As per usual for MN, there is so much empathy on here for people with addictions/compulsions 🙄NOT

Empathy doesn’t require you to remain in a sexual or romantic relationship with someone, does it?

You can have empathy for someone’s struggles and understand why they behave the way they do, while still setting a boundary around what you are and aren’t willing to tolerate in a relationship.

Or, are you suggesting that having empathy obliges someone to remain in a relationship indefinitely, even when they’re unhappy and their partner is being rude and disrespectful towards them? Because according to the comments, that is exactly how OP’s partner is treating her.

Please don’t use “empathy” as a stick to beat people with when they’re in dysfunctional relationships. It’s incredibly unhelpful. Having empathy for someone does not mean you have to sacrifice your own wellbeing or remain in a relationship that is making you unhappy.

moderate · 12/09/2026 09:52

Soontobe60 · 12/09/2026 08:41

Op, whilst you’re clearly worried about him, in many ways you are being very controlling. Telling someone whom you supposedly love that you will leave them if they don’t change their diet is extremely controlling. Presumably he has been like this ever since you met him - if you find it off putting now that’s ok, it’s time to leave.

Telling him she’ll leave him if he doesn’t change gives him much more control than just leaving him.

Leaving someone is saying “I’m out of this relationship and there’s nothing you can do”. Giving them an ultimatum is saying “Here is my boundary. Want to meet me there?” If you don’t want to meet them there, fine, it’s over. That’s your boundary.

moderate · 12/09/2026 09:52

Soontobe60 · 12/09/2026 08:42

The OP knew what he was like when she decided to fall for him - it comes as no surprise.

Falling for people is a decision for you?

Leopoldd · 12/09/2026 20:47

Soontobe60 · 12/09/2026 08:42

The OP knew what he was like when she decided to fall for him - it comes as no surprise.

That’s true - but the issue may be with her where she was maybe wishful thinking he would sort himself out over time which he didn’t so maybe she hoped he would respond positively to her support……and as we all know someone can only do it themselves and if they haven’t done it by 50 - it’s ain’t happening. So suggestion to OP is to work on herself so she doesn’t get drawn into another delusional co-dep RS.

EvieBB · 13/09/2026 12:07

ladyofroo · 12/09/2026 08:57

Empathy doesn’t require you to remain in a sexual or romantic relationship with someone, does it?

You can have empathy for someone’s struggles and understand why they behave the way they do, while still setting a boundary around what you are and aren’t willing to tolerate in a relationship.

Or, are you suggesting that having empathy obliges someone to remain in a relationship indefinitely, even when they’re unhappy and their partner is being rude and disrespectful towards them? Because according to the comments, that is exactly how OP’s partner is treating her.

Please don’t use “empathy” as a stick to beat people with when they’re in dysfunctional relationships. It’s incredibly unhelpful. Having empathy for someone does not mean you have to sacrifice your own wellbeing or remain in a relationship that is making you unhappy.

I never said it did.
Where did I say she has to stay with him?
I'm merely pointing out the lack of understanding around these issues.
OP is free to leave if she chooses for the sake of her own health.
My issues is that there doesn't appear to be a wider discussion about why her ex partner acts the way it does. My issues is the lack of understanding about their addiction/compulsion. But what OP chooses to do is up to her. Of course, nobody is obliged to stay - I never said they were.
I think you misunderstood my post.

moderate · 13/09/2026 15:37

EvieBB · 13/09/2026 12:07

I never said it did.
Where did I say she has to stay with him?
I'm merely pointing out the lack of understanding around these issues.
OP is free to leave if she chooses for the sake of her own health.
My issues is that there doesn't appear to be a wider discussion about why her ex partner acts the way it does. My issues is the lack of understanding about their addiction/compulsion. But what OP chooses to do is up to her. Of course, nobody is obliged to stay - I never said they were.
I think you misunderstood my post.

You very clearly implied it.

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · 13/09/2026 18:22

moderate · 13/09/2026 15:37

You very clearly implied it.

No, she didn't. She said there should be more empathy. You literally said that having empathy doesn't require the OP to stay.

KarenNextDoor · 13/09/2026 19:52

Oh no op. One for the bin!

moderate · 13/09/2026 20:47

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · 13/09/2026 18:22

No, she didn't. She said there should be more empathy. You literally said that having empathy doesn't require the OP to stay.

Where did I literally say that?!

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · 13/09/2026 21:11

moderate · 13/09/2026 20:47

Where did I literally say that?!

Apologies, it was another poster who said that.

EvieBB · Yesterday 10:44

WhatHappenedToYourFurnitureCuz · 13/09/2026 18:22

No, she didn't. She said there should be more empathy. You literally said that having empathy doesn't require the OP to stay.

Thank you!

EvieBB · Yesterday 10:44

moderate · 13/09/2026 20:47

Where did I literally say that?!

Ladyofroo said it.

EvieBB · Yesterday 10:45

moderate · 13/09/2026 15:37

You very clearly implied it.

No, it's merely how you interpreted it....

moderate · Yesterday 11:17

EvieBB · Yesterday 10:45

No, it's merely how you interpreted it....

But that’s “you” plural, which should give you pause for thought at least.