Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Accusation By Adult Stepson

85 replies

PollyHutchen · 07/04/2025 21:46

I have an adult stepson, X, in his thirties. I have been with his Dad since he was 7. His Dad and his Mum decided to separate before I came along, and X spent a lot of time in our house.

X had a turbulent relationship with his own mother. He has high functioning autism and this has meant he's experienced all sorts of difficulties related to thinking and feeling in a way that's different.

As a child and as a teenager he could be very challenging and there were a few occasions when I got angry with him, because he would simply push and push till it was impossible. And everything was always everybody else's fault and they were complete unreasonable. (Mostly I stayed calm and or left things to his Dad but there were times when this wasn't possible.) So there were times when I shouted but these were rare occasions. Mostly family life just went on in as ordinary way as possible. Meals holidays, outings etc. Definitely some very happy times. My stepdaughter says life was a lot more turbulent when they were at their Mums. Masses of shouting and at least one occasion - before he got too big - when she pinned him against the wall and completely lost her rags. At other times she just gave up.

Anyway he settled down a lot and has seemed more mature. He has a partner and a young child and they live a couple of miles away. Recently I pressed him a bit about something which would have involved my going round to his house to collected something. He kept putting me off and saying he and his partner didn't know what they were doing and it was so hard with his small son as well.. Commitment management has never been one of his strengths, but I thought, 'Well he's now at a point where he's having to be more responsible for basic stuff.

So I texted him pressing him for an exact time, and mentioned how much time managment I had to do as a parent and step-parent when he was younger.

He sent me a furious reply, bringing up two times when I'd been angry with him in his chiidhood - one that was very ordinary crossness when he'd ignored a warning from me and broken something fragile, and how horrible this had been. But he also brought up a third incident and this was something which my partner and I absolutely know never happened and which I would do. He said that when he was 8 or 9 I sworn at him and called him bastard because he was illegitimate. (Actually his parents got married well before he was born.) He said I was childish and that he owed me nothing.

It's very difficult because there had been an assumption that I would be helping him and his partner before too long with childcare.

But I don't really feel I can do that any more because I feel that he's produced a version of events that is so at odds with what I remember.

I don't know if anyone else has had to deal with accusations like that. If so, how have they processed it?

Obviously I'm not a saint. But I am on very steady terms with my stepdaughter who is very positive about how I relate to her children. And my other child - the one I had since getting together with their Dad is doing well. (The occasional glitch along the way but it's a strong relationship.

OP posts:
Buttonknot · 08/04/2025 16:44

I agree with the posters saying that memory is a funny thing. The fact that you don't remember this incident doesn't necessarily mean he is lying. Maybe he's referring to something that you have forgotten or remember completely differently, or he misinterpreted or misunderstood something you said - this definitely does happen, and it doesn't mean that anyone is lying.

I'm interested in the wording you use about childcare "there had been an assumption that I would be helping with childcare" seems like a strange way to phrase it, rather than "we had previously agreed" or similar. Who made the assumption? Are you happy to provide childcare or do you feel taken for granted?

I wouldn't withdraw a promise of childcare based on one angry text, without having a conversation and trying to smooth things over, but I also don't think you should be providing childcare unless you want to. Not just because someone (your stepson? Your husband?) thinks you should.

JustWalkingTheDogs · 08/04/2025 16:51

Tbh if he’s happy to fabricate situations about his childhood id be very wary of looking after his child for the exact same reason. It sounds like if things don’t go his way he is happy to create a narrative to suit the situation.

walk away and tell your DH to tell him that you don’t feel capable of looking after his child any longer and they need to make alternative arrangements.

Ive been in a similar situation but didn’t listen to my gut and it bit me in the arse big time. You need to preserve your sanity and not put yourself in a situation that he can use his child to force you to do, or not do things he wants. I know it sounds extreme

Streaaa · 08/04/2025 17:35

@PhilomenaPunk it remained very calm from my friends side.
After 15 years of being kept at a firm distance she hadn't a notion of getting emotional or upset.
She told him crack on but obviously she wouldn't be in any way involved as she had lots of plans for her retirement, none of which included childcare for HIS daughter.

Her husband really thought she would crack.
He didn't see her for dust, she was out of the house, gone for days at a time etc.

He had the nerve to be pissed off with her for making plans for her retirement.
He was exhausted after looking after the 10 month old and expected sympathy from her.
She had none, he had agreed to do it.

His grumpiness resulted in her booking an extended visit to Melbourne to see her sister and extended it even further when he was very pissed off on the phone to her one night.

She has quiet steel which he completely underestimated.

She has since said that it was a blessing as it set her up nicely for the retirement she wanted, and she might have been a bit more accommodating of him if childcare hadn't become a factor.

Her annoyance over the presumptuousness over the childcare gave her a great out.

She now takes plenty of time doing things she wants to do, and he is fully aware since counselling that she is open to divorce if that doesn't work for him.

It has taken nearly 20 years of step motherhood for her step daughter to find a bit of warmth towards her.
She very much matches her energy, but there still isn't any childcare involved.

Quiet steel indeed!

Livelovebehappy · 08/04/2025 19:15

Kilroyonly · 07/04/2025 23:52

Being a step parent is an absolutely thankless task. He sounds a nightmare. Just step away & let his father deal with him

But in this case, presumably there has'nt been any need to 'step-parent' for many years. He's very much an adult and I would guess doesn't need to be parented at all.

Sayithowiseeit · 08/04/2025 20:00

You've been really unreasonable. Why bring up his childhood and then get all upset when he does the same.

TheCourseOfTheRiverChanged · 09/04/2025 04:05

"It’s ridiculous isn’t it? Women are expected to just give, give, give."
Then stop giving and learn to say no.
Don't use your sense of martyrdom as an excuse to drag up events from 30 years ago and criticise the parent of a newborn for poor time management.
Strong women are brave and forthright and get what they want. They're not snipy and needling.

toxic44 · 09/04/2025 22:37

Autistic children become autistic adults. Bring pressed and harried to make a time commitment doesn't usually work with autistic people. It makes them anxious, undermines their self esteem and makes them either try to escape or to lash out (verbally or physically) if the escape route is blocked. DP is autistic, high functioning, had a very challenging childhood and reacts very similarly when pressed to commit to a task. Demanding he does this or that is seen as trying to control him, which doubles the negative response. Does your SS have PDA? It's not uncommon with autism. Perhaps you can phrase your demand as, 'I really need xyz, is it okay if I come round for it later today, please?' Give him the space to choose but set the time to call in the fairly immediate future. This works for me, sometimes. DP has said he hates to feel trapped and if his back is to the wall he will always refuse to listen to anything.

Valeriekat · 10/04/2025 09:18

Sunflowerhoneybee · 08/04/2025 06:58

I'm sure he remembers perfectly well.....what youre suggesting is gaslighting.

You don't know any of the people involved!

Sunflowerhoneybee · 12/04/2025 07:49

Valeriekat · 10/04/2025 09:18

You don't know any of the people involved!

Nor do you!! And yet you've insinuated that he's made all of these false memories up in his head!
Pot kettle black.....

New posts on this thread. Refresh page