Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

Will She Come Back?

81 replies

ba2407 · 22/07/2024 16:59

My girlfriend broke up with me on June 15th, completely unexpectedly. We had been together for 18 months, living together for 9. I'm 31, she's 32, I was her first boyfriend. Our relationship was great despite a rough last few months—we never argued and shared the same values and goals. We had discussed marriage, knew our wedding venue, and wanted kids. We enjoyed weekends away and a ski trip in February. Her family and friends liked me, and mine liked her. Her stepdad has even remained supportive and in contact at times since our breakup.

In March 2024, I gambled for the first time in a year, leaving me feeling suicidal for a week and depressed for a few months. This affected my mood and resulted in a lack of activities for us, as I was too embarrassed to let her pay for everything and was struggling myself where to turn to deal with these feelings i has never had before. I then reached out for help. However much I was struggling when I was around her things were better and I still did all I could despite struggling then to be a good boyfriend. I always treated her so well and we were a great team. I know she is the one.

She was supportive when I told her I gambled, and I started therapy and medication. She noticed improvements, but then ended things on June 15th, saying she couldn’t do it anymore, we hadn’t had fun recently, and maybe we needed space. This was a shock, as she had never mentioned any issues or concerns before and there was nothing wrong between us.

The breakup spurred me into action. I started journalism, running, going to the gym, and attending both weekly group and one-on-one therapy. By June 27th, my therapist noted significant progress, and I felt like a new person—confident, focused, motivated, determined, and clear-minded. I had finally found a formula that worked for me.

I texted her on July 2nd, she replied within 30 seconds, and we met for a walk that evening. I shared the changes I’d made, and she noticed how happy and different I was, saying these changes gave her hope for our future. I read her a list of where we went wrong and solutions, including planning our months together. She was very happy and told me these changes gave her hope. I acknowledged where I went wrong, showing her a list ive made of where I went wrong, we went wrong and solutions. She was very pleased with this and liked it. One of my soluations was to get together at the beginning of the month and plan our time together so we are doing stuff and having fun.

We held hands, kissed, told each other we missed and loved each other and agreed to start talking and meeting up again. We both told each other how special this way and we have never had anything like this before. That evening, she texted, saying it was nice to see me. We continued to text on July 3rd, exchanging emotional messages and reaffirming our love for each other.

On July 4th, I went to move my stuff out. She cried the whole 1hr 30 I was there, saying it felt wrong and that she missed living with me. She apologised for not addressing issues earlier and bottling them up . Despite the emotional turmoil, she made me dinner, despite me saying I don’t want to outstay my welcome and got me sweets for my 3-hour car journey after.

Before I left, she asked for three weeks of space. I haven’t spoken to her since then, and I miss her deeply. I’m confused about why she wanted space after agreeing to meet up again.

One concern is her friend who moved in with us in January. My ex admitted she had been comparing our relationship to her friend’s long-distance relationship. She also said she was not surprised we had broken up and told her to be careful going on a walk with me. This has made me wary of what her friend might be saying, despite us always getting on.

The three weeks of space end on Thursday, I have not contacted her and I plan to let her come to me.

I’m seeking advice on whether she’ll come back and how much the changes I’ve made will influence her decision.

Many thanks.

OP posts:
MrsTerryPratchett · 23/07/2024 14:20

She stopped communicating about things that bothered her and let them out all at once and ended it instead of working through and discussing things. Which is surprising given she was always so supportive of anything and everything I did, we rarely got annoyed at each other and never once argued. It was just so natural and peaceful being with her.

My theory about couples that never argue? One of them isn't getting their needs met. She was always so supportive of you, she always communicated (until she didn't), you never argued. I bet there was a lot she was dealing with under the surface.

And stop calling your relapse a 'blip'. It's denial. Call it a relapse. Own it. Minimising is dangerous, which you would know if you were actually doing the work.

Watchkeys · 23/07/2024 15:04

Put yourself in my shoes

This is the thing. You seem to think that we can all do things from your position. Even your list of being a 'good boyfriend' sounds like a list a teenager would make to prove why his girlfriend shouldn't leave him. You don't get to say you're a 'good boyfriend' to her; that's her decision to make, and by her own criteria, not yours.

It’s clear to me this break up was caused by a lack of communication on both parts and my gambling bilp

This is also you viewing things from solely your perspective. You've decided, here, why she left. Looking at it from anywhere other than your shoes, it looks a lot like your girlfriend left you because you're a problem gambler in denial, who can only see things from his own perspective, and whose gambling has impacted the relationship by revealing naivety, and inability to maintain self control, dishonesty (including to yourself; even during the course of this thread you've gone from knowing it'll never happen again to accepting that it may well happen again), and a lack of funds preventing the relationship maintaining the pattern she'd like.

You're going to have to grow up. If nothing else, she's probably wishing you were the man she though you were, rather than the boy you've revealed yourself to be. At least try to offer her that, if she gets in touch.

ba2407 · 23/07/2024 15:22

MrsTerryPratchett · 23/07/2024 14:20

She stopped communicating about things that bothered her and let them out all at once and ended it instead of working through and discussing things. Which is surprising given she was always so supportive of anything and everything I did, we rarely got annoyed at each other and never once argued. It was just so natural and peaceful being with her.

My theory about couples that never argue? One of them isn't getting their needs met. She was always so supportive of you, she always communicated (until she didn't), you never argued. I bet there was a lot she was dealing with under the surface.

And stop calling your relapse a 'blip'. It's denial. Call it a relapse. Own it. Minimising is dangerous, which you would know if you were actually doing the work.

We got annoyed at each other but never turned into full blown arguments because she communicated things and learnt what each others needs were.

it seems like she was, which is upsetting.

you clearly don’t know the difference between a relapse and a lapse/blip. I have 100% owned it which is why I have acted and continued making the changes I have since the break up. I could have gone the other way but that’s not me or what I want for myself. I am doing lots of work and not minimising for one second. Maybe we use different lingo but we are on the same page.

OP posts:
Flyg · 23/07/2024 16:40

"you clearly don’t know the difference between a relapse and a lapse/blip."

I must admit i also dont know the difference, what is it?

MrsTerryPratchett · 23/07/2024 20:14

Flyg · 23/07/2024 16:40

"you clearly don’t know the difference between a relapse and a lapse/blip."

I must admit i also dont know the difference, what is it?

One is owning it, the other is denial.

Flyg · 24/07/2024 12:26

MrsTerryPratchett · 23/07/2024 20:14

One is owning it, the other is denial.

Sounds about right, unfortunately for OP.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page