Hypocrisy is a MASSIVE problem in our house. It’s the single thing which drives me insane more than anything else. How can someone criticise people for x and yet be completely unaware of themselves doing this more than the person they’re criticising!
I have pondered this a lot! And I think there are several factors at play: lack of self awareness, an element of delusion and a good deal of projection.
First the lack of awareness. They just don’t see what we see. They don’t see fault in themselves and don’t spend a lot of time questioning or examining their own behaviour.
Second is the delusion factor. Eg. my DP criticises ME for always having the last word. And yet I am very careful not to do this. In fact it is HIM who cannot stop himself from having the last word. And I’ve wondered how can he not realise he’s doing it? He is so critical of me and yet has zero awareness he himself is the one doing it!
I think perhaps in his head, and I suspect in your DH’s, the thing they criticise isn’t what they think they’re doing. So you can see DH is being a rubbish conversationalist. He doesn’t ask anything or show any interest when you speak. And I can see my DP has to have the last word. But to them what they’re doing has a different justification. So your DH isn’t showing a lack of interest, in the way he criticises others for, he simply isn’t responding to questions. Because there were none to respond to. I can see and you can see that the flow of conversation isn’t just sitting there waiting for a question and then responding. That it involves an amount of “oh really? Did you?.. Then what happened?…..I see” etc. but to him, he simply isn’t responding to questions. And that’s different to not showing an interest or not asking about someone’s day. You and I know they’re part of the same thing. But he has made a distinction and is therefore deluding himself to en extent that what he does is different to what he dislikes in others.
Same with my DP. When he has the last word he is simply expressing his view at the end of a conversation to finish it off, having silenced me with his “well we shall agree to disagree then” Me: “ok that’s fine”
DP: “all I’m saying is bla bla bla” .
Me: “I thought we were agreeing to disagree?”
DP: “we are! I’m just saying bla bla bla”
Me: “but you’re not agreeing to disagree! You’re shutting me up so you can have the last word as you always do!”
DP: “you just have to have the last word don’t you?”
Me: “me?”
DP: “always the same!!!”
Me: “no, I am pointing out that you couldn’t leave the conversation without having the last word! It’s you who was having the last word”
Although I can see that saying “agree to disagree” and then immediately following it up with “all I’m saying is….” is precisely him having the last word. But he can’t see it. To him he is just expressing his view at the end of the conversation and somehow this is different to having the last word.
I think there is also an amount of projection going on as well. I know from my experience my autistic DP finds any form of perceived criticism utterly intolerable. Even the thought that he might potentially be criticised, so he projects onto others as a preemptive defence strategy.
Do I think there is any merit in you giving him a taste of his own medicine? Honestly no. My gut feeling is he won’t see it that way. When HE shows a lack of interest this is just him not responding to a question, but when YOU do it, you’re being deliberately unkind and not taking any interest in him. I suspect he would be unlikely to draw a parallel. (See: lack of awareness + delusion).