Sad evening yesterday. We were having such a nice day. All of our DC were here and DP decided to cook a roast for us all. I offered to help but he said everything was under control. Roast was lovely. We all enjoyed it. He was clearing up then his DD came downstairs looking all folorn (as she is prone to) and said the DS had been in her room shouting and wouldn’t stop or get out when she asked him to.
At this point my DP completely flies off the handle. Stands at the bottom of the stairs shouting for his DS to come to him. DS comes out of his bedroom. DP then proceeds to scream and shout at him. DS not allowed to get a word in edgeways. My DS was in my StepDS’s room and he comes out to see what all the shouting is about. DP then shouts at him to get of his DS’s room as his DS is going to spend the rest of the evening in there by himself. My DC don’t respond to the shouting like his do. His DC are scared of him. Mine just think he’s a knob! So when he shouted at my DS to get out now, my DS just gave him the raised eyebrows and basically laughed at him. Unhelpful. But kind of fair enough really. He was being pretty awful.
DP didn’t respond well to that and shouted at my DS some more. A few mins later DP caught my DS trying to sneak back into my step DS’s bedroom. Well that was it!!!! Now my DS got the swearing and shouting treatment, how dare he go in there when he’s been told not to etc. it was a fair point but delivered badly (as usual by screaming, swearing and shouting!)
My DP then proceeds to have a go at me! How my bad parenting is the problem. Why can’t I just parent my DS properly??? He is rude and disrespectful etc.
I reply that I don’t appreciate being shouted at. If he means “parent better” that I need to parent more like him (by screaming and shouting) I am simply not going to do that. I am not commenting about his parenting and I don’t feel it’s his place to judge mine. We parent differently, that is all. Had he not shouted at my DS in the first place but instead spoken to him calmly and respectfully then he might have got a better response. And that shouting at people will generally in life not get the best of them. Anyway none of this gets through to him. And he continues shouting at me. Despite repeated requests for him to please stop the shouting. He also tells me he thinks shouting at his DS and my DS was a perfectly reasonable thing to do given the situation!!!!!
My DF is the same. Shouting is normal. Shouting is fine. I’m not saying I never shout at my DC. I do. But rarely and only when utterly exasperated! I will always try and handle things calmly and by talking to them.
Later my DD told me she had been in the room when my step DS had “shouted” at his sister and refused to leave. She said he wasn’t shouting at all! Just talking loudly and directing her what to do (which is just how he speaks. He has no volume control and thinks he is in charge). He was probably being a bit annoying and bossy but nothing more than that.
All that shouting and unpleasantness for nothing! My DP could easily have sat down and discussed calmly with his DC what had happened. But instead he thinks the way to parent is to be incredibly strict, refuse to allow anyone else to speak by shouting over them and not allow any different point of view to be heard. It’s the same when he has disagreements with me. He just shuts me down by shouting at me. Louder and louder until I stop talking. He genuinely thinks this is normal, reasonable and proportionate!!!! I do worry his DC will grow up thinking this is how to behave.