I cooked a meal for you Monday evening so it can’t be 5 days
This is exactly the sort of thing H would say. Both completely missing the point and centering only himself by defending himself.
In our one disastrous counselling session, H insisted he did listen to me in our relationship. I asked him to name one thing I had asked him to do in our relationship. He couldn’t. But dismissed this with ‘I admit I don’t remember everything but’. And he was completely unperturbed by this. There was no realization that in ten years of me intensely bringing to him issues, and him not being able to name one, was actually quite remarkable, and maybe he was doing something wrong after all.
Afterwards I said to him that he had said, ‘ I admit I don’t remember everything’ with such lack of emotion or insight, that it was as if I had accused him not always remembering the beans when he did the shopping.
His actually reply was an angry, indignant, ‘ I’ve never forgotten the beans!’
!
And I’ve just realised that he was actually more emotional at being accused of forgetting the beans than he was at being exposed as not being able to remember a single thing I’ve asked him to do for the sake of our relationship.
I guess because the importance of listening to and nurturing the person he is married to is not something that has any meaning to him, but remembering the beans does.
FFS, relating to me is less meaningful and real to him than a bloody shopping list! Wow. I’ve just realized that.