I was listening to a podcast the other night, and the author spoke about the two kinds of silent treatment.
One is done as punishment, and you might even get them to admit they do it as punishment. They will be able to switch to warm and friendly if someone else turns up.
The other type the author said was a form of self protection. It’s a form of flight response.
I suffer from this second type.The feelings the disagreement has generated are so intense you don’t know what to do with yourself. You might temporarily dislike the other person, but you hate yourself even more. I need to go away and calm down before I can even think rationally. As the other poster said, mine is also due to a dysfunctional childhood.
I think it stems from a time when as a child, you weren’t listened to, or had arbitrary rules applied which to your child’s brain were manifestly unfair. The overriding feeling is hurt and sadness and not anger.
I don’t know what the solution is. I know I always wished my mother would come and find me after I had run off to my room. She used to stand in the doorway, ask “what’s wrong” I’d reply “Nothing,” even though something obviously was, and she’d disappear. Eventually I would go back downstairs and everyone behaved as if nothing had happened.
What I wanted was her to come and sit with me, until I could feel safe and confident enough to share my thoughts. Even as a young child I sometimes knew I was being ridiculous. I was a perfectly behaved child except for this.