Today has been an incredible day for me. After my last few posts on this thread and reading all your responses and comments I began analysing my feelings (or lack thereof) for my DD more deeply. I realised that what I actually lacked was an ability to empathise with my DD. So when she was crying because she was upset or had hurt herself I didn?t feel her pain myself; like I?ve already said I just felt cold or numb inside when she cried or needed me to comfort her. By contrast, when my DS cried for any reason (he?s not a big crier I would say, he?s generally happy and only cries occasionally) I would also feel his pain as if it was my pain and I absolutely couldn?t hold myself back from comforting him because, in actual fact, in easing his pain, I was actually comforting myself and easing my own pain.
Anyway, this morning I realised that I had a complete lack of empathy with my DD, but only when she was upset/crying/needy. I have noticed in some of your posts that some of you mentioned that your mothers seemed to be able to be there for you when you needed comforting/support but that they almost turned against you when something good happened to you. I suppose in my case the reason I can?t/couldn?t empathise with my DD when she?s upset is because that was exactly my experience with my mum, both as a child and as an adult; basically she was never there for me whenever I was upset/down/needy but she would pop up like a jack in the box whenever there was something good going on in my life. I used to think of her as a ?fairweather mother? and it used to really upset me that she wasn?t there for the bad times yet she wanted to share my happiness during the good times. I felt she didn?t deserve to share any of my happy times if she didn?t want to be there for me during the unhappy times.
Anyway, to get back to my day, after yesterday?s posts, I knew that I still had a major part of my journey ahead of me in that I had to somehow access my suppressed feelings in relation to my mum which began I suppose from the moment I was born. In hindsight it was of course going to be much easier to access my feelings in relation to my dad as his abuse started when I was around 11 and the memories of what he did and how I felt were very clear in my mind. My feelings about him were also very close to the surface, ie not buried particularly deeply as I was always quite rude and snappy with my dad and I knew why even though at that time I may not have remembered all the particular details of the abusive incidents especially clearly.
My feelings towards my mum were much harder to access as the emotional neglect and feelings of abandonment must have started the moment I was born and so must necessarily have been buried much much deeper and not really in my conscious mind. And also my mum, unlike many of your mothers, has never been verbally or physically abusive, she has always been quite pleasant and so it was much harder to even realise she had mistreated me. Although now I have so much more of an understanding of her behaviour I don?t even know if I can call it mistreatment as I believe now that she was acting entirely unconsciously.
I think that she clearly did not have her needs met during her childhood and so she was unable to meet my needs after I was born. But unlike her, when my DD was born, I think that I was given a gift, as so many of us on this thread have too, and that is the gift of insight and self awareness. It is only because of this gift that I was able to be aware of my lack of feeling towards my DD and because of this awareness I was able to consciously go against my true feelings and act in such a way so as not to hurt my daughter in so far as I was able. My mother did not have this insight or self awareness and so was absolutely unable to act in any other way than how she in fact did ie with no empathy or understanding for me when I was hurt or needed her to comfort me. I use the word gift as I think that?s what Alice Miller means in her book ?The Drama of the Gifted Child? ie gifted child meaning a child who has been given the gift of awareness.
Also since yesterday?s posts I was wondering today how I would actually be able to access my feelings towards my mother, I seemed to be able to access my feelings towards my dad almost spontaneously ie I didn?t try to access those feelings, it just seemed to happen, and although feeling the pain from my childhood was terrible, afterwards I did feel I had been released and felt a huge sense of peace.
This morning, as I worked out why my mother was emotionally distant towards me, I felt my numbness about my DD almost melting away. It was as if my greater understanding about my mother was somehow re-connecting me with my DD. And with this re-connection I just started crying as I suddenly felt my DD?s pain, the pain she surely must have felt in her short life feeling that her mother, ie me, doesn?t love her. As however much I pretended to try and be there for her when she was upset I just don?t think I fooled her at all as children are such instinctual creatures, I think it is impossible to fool them with mere words. And whilst crying and feeling my DD?s pain, I knew I was also feeling my own pain from my own childhood and it was exactly the same pain that my DD must have felt.
So, I?m sure I haven?t explained all this very well at all, but I honestly feel now that I have re-connected with my DD and the numb feeling has gone away and at the same time I feel I have released my own childhood pain. What Smithfield said about my DD somehow being a portal to my own childhood pain is absolutely 100% spot on. I am amazed at what happened to me this morning, it is almost surreal.
I also felt this morning that I need to write a letter to my DD to say sorry for how I must have hurt her and that is something I will do in the next few days. It may seem silly and I may not even read the letter to her, but I will keep it and if this subject ever arises in the future I will show her the letter.
I have written all the above in some detail in the hope that it will help some of you on this thread, perhaps in understanding your own mothers, as I feel that if I had not been given this gift of self-awareness and insight, I could perhaps have gone on to have the kind of relationship with my DD that many of you have with your mothers.