Charlotte I recognise myself in much of what you have said there especially about not knowing who you were after the relationship ended. I spent the first couple of years trying new things, new hobbies, putting myself out there etc. I felt more confident that I had ever done before. And, initially, really hopeful about the future. I felt like my whole life was starting all over again in the most amazing and positive way it could have done. I approached every day with hope. I started new hobbies, got a new job, met new people and made new friends... but the hobbies couldn't be maintained financially or timewise, the new job changed, but that's ok, it was for the better, just more demanding, and the friends didn't become any closer/deeper/more meaningful.
I've also taken, and still take, the approach of, "hmm, no one has texted me, I'll text them" and remembering when people have mentioned an ill parent or a job interview or just a comment in passing, and have asked how things are. But it isn't reciprocated.
I wonder if I don't do it as much as I think, or if I'm sending out 'vibes' that keep people at bay. I do worry that when people get to know the 'real me' that they won't like me anyway. I try to silence the voices that criticise me, but I'm not sure which of them are right and those that aren't.
I was going to type that I've managed to get a handle on a lot of the character/personality flaws that I was criticised for. But, actually, I think it's more that I think I've become better at concealing them and perhaps that's where the 'keeping people at arm's length' comes from. I know that I'm really fearful of people discovering "the real me".
But I'm having a much harder time dealing with the physical/appearance based criticisms because she was right. The things she was saying weren't made up or invented. So, as far as romantic relationships go, how can I ever be loved, when I'm not even genuinely fanciable? No one is ever going to get that close to me.
I think all I've become better at doing is concealing the aspects of myself I don't like. But the only way i can successfully do that, is to keep myself away from other people so that they don't see it...
Sorry, not really asking you for your input/feedback, I'm just musing...