"@Miflaw- We agree at least that bringing children to meetings is a no-no.Even though for you it is only to be self serving to the members anonimity and not the childrens safety." - No, not os - what I meant is that parents are not reliant on the goodwill of members, the members also have something to lose by encouraging children over the age of 4 to attend.
"The reason that AA/NA are different than other adult venues is that both organizations encourage minors to attend."
I have NEVER, in nearly 10 years of attending meetings between 1 and 7 times every week, EVER seen any sign at all of anyone encouraging minors to attend. We do not WANT minors present because, unless the minor him/herslef is an alcoholic, it is not fair on the children and also puts our anonymity at risk. (Also, most minors are non-alcoholics so are not welcome at closed meetings on that basis alone.)
"They are recruiting teenagers to build there base knowing that they are being sexually abused." I have never seen AA "recruit" anyone, least of all minors. The youngest member I have met in Europe was about 19; the youngest member in a typical meeting will be about 27.
Nor have I EVER heard, even as a rumour, of minors being sexually abused in British AA - the mention of York in PBR's message is the first I have ever heard of this.
"Another reason AA/NA is more dangerous is because you have the judicial system sending violent criminals ans sexual predators to these meetings.
The courts to not send them to those you spoke of." The British judicial system - unlike the US system (bit of cut and paste going on here?) does NOT send anyone to meetings. There is a "chit" system whereby certain categories of criminals (normally where the crime is drink- or drug-motivated or related) can get parole on the basis that they choose to attend meetings - though not all groups operate this. In three years as a group secretary (in three different meetings) I have never issued a single chit. If any of these (apparently very few) individuals are sexual predators then it is coincidental and therefore unknowable.
"Of course sexual predators wont mention their crimes in a meeting for the most part. They want to be anonymous.Correct Miflaw. The point you are missing is that it is because of the anonymity that makes minors vulnerable
to those that attend these meetings.AA/NA has a much higher % of dangerous felons at any one time than your local chess club." That is one of many reasons why minors are not welcome at AA meetings, except, on rare occasions, as toddlers in the company of single parents.
"What would I like AA/NA to do about this? Thanks for asking.
- Stop recruiting minors to meetings!" They don't. I've never seen this. Which meetings have you yourself seen this happen in?
"2) if they want teen meetings," - they don't. I defy you to find me these teen meetings as they are not listed anywhere I know - London, for example, which has 600 meetings a week, including specific meetings for Poles, women, and the deaf, does not have a single teen meeting.
"than be responsible and create teen meetings and have background checks on adults that run the teen meetings.Plus there are a host of other safety guards that they could put in place,similiar to Alateen and many other youth programs do.2 Again, irrelevant because there are no teen meetings.
"3) If there is a crime committed against a minor,or even suspected-call the police. Do not consider it as an outside issue just to protect their image.
Children depend on adults to protect them." I have never seen a crime committed in an AA meeting, except for drunk and disorderly, which we tend to deal with ourselves because it's quickest - we normally get the drunk to leave and come back when he's finished throwing chairs. If crimes happen outside the meetings, obviously the people to report it are those involved.
It is one thing to have a view about whether AA is an effective means of treating alcoholism. It is another to spread lies about its members, accusing them of or implciating them in criminal activity. Start by telling us where these teen meetings take place and how AA (who have a policy of non-recruitment) "recruit" their (non-existent) UK teen membership.
Back up your claims with cases that you have seen or retract them, or I will be reporting you for what amounts to slander.