Meet the Other Phone. Child-safe in minutes.

Meet the Other Phone.
Child-safe in minutes.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Relationships

Mumsnet has not checked the qualifications of anyone posting here. If you need help urgently or expert advice, please see our domestic violence webguide and/or relationships webguide. Many Mumsnetters experiencing domestic abuse have found this thread helpful: Listen up, everybody

FIL let DS run onto busy road

107 replies

anotherglass · 26/10/2010 20:01

The in laws have been looking after our 2 DS's during half term. When I came home from work today DS1 (7) told me that DS (4) ran onto the road while out with granny and grandpa. In laws who overheard said 'now don't be telling tales'. Ds 1 didn't say anything but later I asked him what he meant and he said that DS 2 had run onto the road while grandpa was walking them home. Now, I was pretty shook up about this and went back to ask In Laws. I was quite concerned as we live in a very busy inner city area and always tell MILs too keep hold of little one's hand and that the adult with him should be able to chase him as he can be defiant and want to walk on his own. But in laws went into the shopping area today and then while MIL stayed in shops, FIL took it upon himself to walk back to the house (about 1 mile) with the two boys. Now, he is 72, in need of a hip replacement and cannot run. I confronted him about this and he says he held DS2 hand all the way until he became too uncontrollable and he let him go. DS2 just then set off and ran onto an intersection near our house. FIL was unable to chase him. My MIL says that FIL walked off on his own back against her wishes but she knows how Little One can be a handful. They are now upset at me for being 'hysterical' and claim that the little one isn't disciplined firmly enough. FIL wants to hit him to control him. DH heard all this and said nothing to support me, other than telling me to shut up and to stop bullying his parents. I don't feel able to go to work now and leave them in the care of the in laws, with such poor decision making. DH is absolutely no support whatsover and says that I am a hypocrite as I have let my son run onto the road on one occasion! I cannot understand that if they were responsible about their physical limitations FIL should not have attempted to walk back on his own with the 2 of them. I am on my own upstairs while they are all downstairs - with me blowing up because my son could have been run over!

OP posts:
Lougle · 28/10/2010 10:14

"I have conceded time and time again to them that LO can be defiant, the adult with him must be able to hold his hand or be within arms reach"

"My point is that every occasion I express to MIL that little one needs to be restrained - that he should be with an adult who is able to keep up with him ( ie here )."

"Why would you in your right mind suggest... that he takes a highly active defiant 3 year old to the park for a couple of hours?"

"He.has road sense. He is not a troublesome child who has behavioural problems"

Which is it, OP. What message would you get from those three quotes above??

Lougle · 28/10/2010 10:15

And is he 3 or 4? You keep changing your mind.

anotherglass · 28/10/2010 10:37

My son is nearly 4 and a half. He has road sense as otherwise he would not be able to walk 1.5km to school every day, crossing busy roads etc with me and his big brother. He does not like his hand to be held all the time, as he is very, very independent. He does not wander off on each and every occasion we go out. If he did this he most certainly be in reins or restraints.

I am calling an end to this thread as the tone of the posts has become very attacking. When I first posted I was very very upset and needed help to calm down and get through a confrontational episode, which I have with in laws.

This really is the last post as am now leaving for a day out with the in laws and the boys.

OP posts:
Lougle · 28/10/2010 10:47

anotherglass, that isn't the way MN works Hmm - people don't get to call time on threads.

I think it is very telling that you think of your 4½ year old as 3, to be honest.

I do hope that you can sort out a responsible and sensible solution. I think that you sound quite conflicted, because you contradict yourself throughout the thread about your son's abilities, behaviour and needs.

You say that you warn your MIL that he needs to be restrained, yet you say he is very, very independent.

Until you really know what your DS needs, then you can't expect anyone else to.

mumblechum · 28/10/2010 10:52

Your FIL is probably quite upset, firstly at what happened, but also your reaction.

I once had ds's friend with us in the park, (later diagnosed with adhd) and he ran straight across the road, making a car screech to a halt. Massive adrenaline rush, tearfulness etc. My ds would never have dreamed of doing something like that, as he was always disciplined appropriately at that age.

I think children behave in a way you expect them to behave a lot of the time. So if you expect your child to be sensible, then by and large they are, if you expect them to be defiant and silly, then they pick up on that expectation and act it out.

LIZS · 28/10/2010 10:55

Agree if he has to hear others told how he is a handful etc, especially if in a resigned or light hearted way, then it will become a self-fulfilling prophesy. Is he at school himself yet if he is 4 1/2 ?

diddl · 28/10/2010 12:09

"He was fine on the walk to the shops with In Laws but started to play up on the way back - when his hand was held by his grandfather. Normally, he will walk by my side as he is very independent and most likely objected to being restrained."

But you told them that they had to restrain him??!!

New posts on this thread. Refresh page