Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

Would you swap a dream house for a walkable town?

120 replies

Kent2024 · 24/07/2026 08:22

I’d really appreciate some outside perspectives because I feel completely torn.

We currently live in a large bungalow in a semi-rural village in Kent. Over the last few years we’ve completely renovated and extended it, spending £250k plus on top of what we paid for the house. It’s now exactly how we wanted it; four bedrooms, large open-plan kitchen/living space, lovely garden, loads of privacy and some genuinely beautiful views over the countryside (I’ll attach a photo of the view).

The problem is… the location.

We have two young children, and increasingly I’m wondering whether we’re entering a stage of life where lifestyle matters more than the house itself.

Where we are now, you have to drive everywhere. If we fancy a coffee, we drive. Pub? Drive. Park? Drive. Taking the dog out? Drive. The boys can’t just hop on their bikes to meet friends or wander into town when they’re older. It all has to be planned.

One of the biggest frustrations is that although we live in a beautiful setting, we’re on a fast A-road. Our house is set well back behind gates and mature screening, so we don’t really hear the traffic in the house or garden, but it means we can’t simply walk out of the front door. The pavements are either tiny or non-existent in places, so even a casual stroll into a village, coffee shop or pub isn’t really possible.

I’ve started looking at places like Tunbridge Wells because I love the idea of walking out of the front door to independent cafés, parks, restaurants, the station, shops and clubs for the children. I imagine evening walks to get an ice cream, Saturday mornings wandering into town, the boys becoming more independent as teenagers, and generally feeling more connected to where we live.
The other attraction is the secondary schools. There seem to be several highly regarded state and grammar options in and around Tunbridge Wells, whereas where we are the choices feel more limited.

But then I look around our house and think… are we mad?

It’s taken years to create this home. The garden is exactly as we wanted, the house works brilliantly for family life, it’s peaceful and private despite the road, and the view still makes visitors stop and say “wow.” It’s also big enough that our boys will have space as they grow and we aren’t all on top of each other.

I’d describe it as like an island, very safe and private but life is contained within the boundary fences. I grew up in surburbia and didn’t realise how nice it was having the freedom to walk everywhere growing up.

I’m also conscious that perhaps we’re suffering from familiarity blindness, because we see the view every day, maybe we’ve stopped appreciating just how special it actually is. Would we only realise what we’d lost after we’d moved?

Financially we’d almost certainly end up with a less unique smaller house, a smaller garden and less privacy in order to gain the walkable location. I think we’d be lucky to break even and most likely we’d be down about 50k on what we’ve spent after fees etc.

Has anyone made a similar move?
Did moving to a walkable town genuinely improve everyday family life, or did the novelty wear off after a while? Equally, has anyone left a house they loved for the location and regretted it?

I’d really welcome honest opinions from people who’ve been in a similar position.

Would you swap a dream house for a walkable town?
Would you swap a dream house for a walkable town?
OP posts:
Randomchat · 24/07/2026 08:32

My 14yr old is always out by himself. At the local park, the football pitches, he's started using the little 9 hole golf course, walks to a friend's house, they get the bus into town, they'vebooked tickets to the new Spiderman movie next week and they'll go by themselves. He's never home in the holidays for longer than his lunch. He would feel quite isolated I think in your house.
But every kid is different. Yours might be quite happy at home or with only occasional trips out. My older son rarely goes out after school. He has a shed where he builds model aeroplanes so he'd prefer your current house.
So my anecdotal experience is no help to you at all really.

I feel like in general kids want a bit of independence by secondary school and if there really is no scope for that where you are right now then maybe you should think about moving.

Even my older ds likes to walk to the sweet shop or occasionally get the bus to a model shop or something without me having to drive him.

Morepositivemum · 24/07/2026 08:38

It’s the toughest thing op, and something we and parents we talk to talk about regularly. We have kids age 11 to 18. We are country, not insanely rural as we have neighbours, but no paths and getting to the shop on foot means you could get killed. I worry that someday after school/ being in town the kids won’t be able to get through to us and will get into a friend’s car or try walking. I also think for school and work it would be amazing that essentially we could ditch the cars and afterschool drop offs and collections would be a thing of the past.

And yet if we lived in town- it’s not a great town, there’s been the odd attack, there’s groups of young lads that hassle people etc- I don’t know that I want the kids as teens wandering out in the evening etc. Plus our house is great, there’s kids play football and we have a dog they run around with. It’s so hard

HereForFootie · 24/07/2026 08:40

I think it's nice for older children to develop independence. Also useful for their first part-time jobs, building a local friendship group.

Is there an alternative where you can have a beautiful rural house but also access to public transport? You seem to be considering two extremes at the moment.

Tortephant · 24/07/2026 08:47

Stay.

Emoemu · 24/07/2026 08:48

I made basically this exact move a few years ago, and it involved downsizing significantly. I do miss the views and the walks, but life in our nice town is so much better for my children, I don’t regret the move for a second. They see their friends all the time, go to whatever clubs they want, walk to and from school and the cinema and the park. And I can pop out to meet a friend for coffee or for a drink at the pub so easily, it’s made a big difference to my mental health honestly. We have definitely outgrown this house and are currently in the process of moving again though, to a bigger house - just around the corner! I wouldn’t want to change this location at all, I want to stay in this area until our children leave home now because it makes us all happy. I do often see big countryside houses on Instagram with huge gardens and feel a pang for that sort of picture perfect rural lifestyle but then I remember how isolating it felt, and how much I hated having to drive everywhere. Only you know what suits your family but for me, a walkable location surrounded by friends and things to do has given us a significantly better quality of life.

Our old house also had amazing views and I became totally blind to them after a while! I don’t really miss them because I did stop appreciating them.

chirrupybird · 24/07/2026 08:50

I think it would be very difficult to get used to being close to neighbours, and not having a big garden to relax in. Not sure about being right in the centre of a town, noise into the night and all day. We are in a similar position, a really nice big plot on a moderately busy road, but we can walk into town on proper pavements although a few roads to cross and have a couple of corner shops nearby for those things you forgot. Perhaps you could find something like your current house but within easy walking distance of a small town as a compromise.

Emoemu · 24/07/2026 08:50

Just realised I said I both do and don’t miss the views. I mean in the abstract I suppose I think it would be nice to still have them, but really I had stopped noticing them so much day to day that I don’t ever feel a pang for them if that makes sense

SuddenLull · 24/07/2026 08:52

That’s why we moved to be close to a city centre.

WorthySloth · 24/07/2026 08:54

We moved to Devon with 4 small children. Looked at pretty villages etc and then realised that we needed to be in a town. We have schools shops pubs and public transport. I have rarely had to drive the kids around to meet friends or get to places because they can either walk or get the bus.

Both me and the husband can walk to work as can one of the children now. Another 2 get the bus and the other now has a works van because he works all over the place.

16 years on it was definitely the right decision for our family.

Foughties · 24/07/2026 08:54

We are a bit similar and haven't poured money into the house as we know the location is impractical and we need to have more connection, and our local town is beautiful too. I want the dc to have a life and we will want a life too now they are getting older.

However...I have just seen your pics and omg!!!!

Advocodo · 24/07/2026 08:56

Haven’t read any of the threads as don’t want to be biased but no I wouldn’t swap your house. We moved out into a town with everything walkable whilst extensive work was done on our house. A very popular wealthy area with a train station into London. It was lovely being able to walk into town but if we moved there we would have to compromise on space and I think even this town was suffering with a few empty units. Maybe think about it for a while and rethink when senior schools are an issue. Good luck in whatever you decide. Forgot to say that we r in a village where we can go for nice walks and have a great village store and post office and chemist.

Elpheba · 24/07/2026 08:57

We lived on the edge of a village- gorgeous house and lovely views. There was a bus stop out side and you could walk to a newsagent/do a country walk but even then we moved once both kids in primary. You had to drive to school and to anything other than the newsagent and I knew I didn’t want to be a taxi mum. Moved into a city- significantly smaller house but worth it for such a great lifestyle. I lost weight from walking and cycling everywhere, kids barely get in a car and it will be so easy for them to be independent as they get older. I think walking everywhere is such an amazing way to live and I’d never move back out either rurally or to the suburbs.

YorZarad · 24/07/2026 09:00

We are in a village and are basically a taxi service for our teens at the moment, but one day they will leave home and we will still have our nice house. Although the taxi thing is a bit of a pain, I grant you.

JoeTheDrummer · 24/07/2026 09:01

Foughties · 24/07/2026 08:54

We are a bit similar and haven't poured money into the house as we know the location is impractical and we need to have more connection, and our local town is beautiful too. I want the dc to have a life and we will want a life too now they are getting older.

However...I have just seen your pics and omg!!!!

People who live rurally “have a life” too!

OP - how far is your drive to the nearest town?

We live in a village and have to ferry our kids about, but it’s less than 15 mins to a large town so not a big deal. I don’t mind doing it as means we can afford a 6-bed detached with a big garden, and I very much enjoy the peace! It’s very rare that our teens can’t get where they need to be when they want, and the lazy sods prefer being driven than when we lived more centrally and they had to walk or get a bus!

Newgirls · 24/07/2026 09:04

What a view!

all you can do is look at property in your price range and weigh it up - you might find something lovely or not

Tabarnak · 24/07/2026 09:06

All families are different but these things were key to our quality of life during the primary and secondary school years:
-Having a network of school gate friends all within walking distance. Socialising for adults because we just took the kids with us, they were all at the same school and good friends. We still have these friends now that the Dc are grown - and the Dc are still friends.

The Dc having good friends within walking distance

A local park a 2 min walk away

Ditto convenience store. Yes, we did big supermarket shops but sometimes you need to nip out for milk

Independence at secondary age. Walk to secondary , easy bus journey to 6th form. School run freedom is liberty!

Loads of teen activities that they could get to independently.

I watched my nieces and nephews (same sort of location as you) be ferried about by Mum and Dad taxi and then the need to buy them cars at an early age (high cost and worries about young drivers ) while mine were confidently navigating themselves all over the place by public transport. I think dependence on parents infantilises them.

We went camping / hiking/ day trips at weekends to appreciate views!

Ineedanewsofa · 24/07/2026 09:14

I dislike crowded/built up areas and don’t mind driving so I wouldn’t move in your situation (or my current one!)
People on here seem obsessed with teens being able to walk or catch the bus and go out with their friends without parental involvement, personally I’d rather drop my child off so I at least know where I’ve left them and who I’ve left them with, like my parents did with me. I was never allowed to go and ‘hang around’ in town or at the park and we certainly didn’t have money to waste at the cinema/cafe/coffee shop.
Even when we lived within walking distance of cafes, coffee shops and pubs we didn’t really use them, the only benefit was being able to walk to baby group at the church hall when DC was tiny but all the other activities still needed a car as they weren’t walkable.

Foughties · 24/07/2026 09:15

People who live rurally “have a life” too!

I meant the lifestyle we wanted for ourselves and our dc.

OnlyGreenClothes · 24/07/2026 09:16

We moved from a house in a semi-rural location that we had done lots of work to and extended, simply because there was nothing in walking distance. We now live in a smaller house (I lost my home office and lovely big garden) that is within walking distance of shops, pubs, supermarket etc. I don't regret the move, no. I prefer the lifestyle I have now.

AsACloud · 24/07/2026 09:18

I’d give up my children before I’d give up that view OP 🤣

puyr · 24/07/2026 09:24

it’s a personal choice. If you’re happy to drive your teens and young adults everywhere, great. I wanted to live in an area where my children could walk around, use the facilities, like the swimming pool/cinema/retail park/ buses and train station. It was the biggest priority when we moved here. Not just for the benefit of our kids but also for our benefit as we get older and might want friends/community/doctor/dentist etc on the doorstep and not a car or taxi ride away. Gorgeous view though.

senua · 24/07/2026 09:41

I think it's nice for older children to develop independence. Also useful for their first part-time jobs, building a local friendship group.
Depends on your definition of independence. We live semi-rurally, on the edge of town. The DC had to make an effort to get out and about ... so they did. They were used to travelling far and wide to meet up with friends.
They were both amused when they went to (different) University and met people from London who all thought that they were wildly adventurous because they has escaped beyond the M25.Grin

Flowersandthorns · 24/07/2026 09:58

My opinion would be to stay and live your life. One day you might wake up realizing you need to move but you might not ever wake up thinking that. It is hard to predict the future.

mondaytosunday · 24/07/2026 10:16

I wouldn’t have bought a house so rural in the first place, but my dream is to have everything within five to ten minutes walk. I want to be able to look out my window and see where I’m eating brunch!
And to do this I’m willing to sacrifice quite a lot. Currently I live in leafy zone 3 of London in a terraced house. A have good neighbours and parks within walking distance but the shops/tube etc is a 20 minute walk which I just don’t do. I feel in residential suburbia. So I’m happy to sacrifice the garden for a roof terrace or patio, the third bedroom for a sofa bed. I’ve already downsized from a detached five bed house with pool to here, and I’m going to downsize again. Cost will be the same but I want to be where the action is!
So if I was you I’d move.

EverMissWicklowSometimes · 24/07/2026 10:19

You would have to take me out of that house in a box! 😆