Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Property/DIY

Join our Property forum for renovation, DIY, and house selling advice.

Would you swap a dream house for a walkable town?

120 replies

Kent2024 · 24/07/2026 08:22

I’d really appreciate some outside perspectives because I feel completely torn.

We currently live in a large bungalow in a semi-rural village in Kent. Over the last few years we’ve completely renovated and extended it, spending £250k plus on top of what we paid for the house. It’s now exactly how we wanted it; four bedrooms, large open-plan kitchen/living space, lovely garden, loads of privacy and some genuinely beautiful views over the countryside (I’ll attach a photo of the view).

The problem is… the location.

We have two young children, and increasingly I’m wondering whether we’re entering a stage of life where lifestyle matters more than the house itself.

Where we are now, you have to drive everywhere. If we fancy a coffee, we drive. Pub? Drive. Park? Drive. Taking the dog out? Drive. The boys can’t just hop on their bikes to meet friends or wander into town when they’re older. It all has to be planned.

One of the biggest frustrations is that although we live in a beautiful setting, we’re on a fast A-road. Our house is set well back behind gates and mature screening, so we don’t really hear the traffic in the house or garden, but it means we can’t simply walk out of the front door. The pavements are either tiny or non-existent in places, so even a casual stroll into a village, coffee shop or pub isn’t really possible.

I’ve started looking at places like Tunbridge Wells because I love the idea of walking out of the front door to independent cafés, parks, restaurants, the station, shops and clubs for the children. I imagine evening walks to get an ice cream, Saturday mornings wandering into town, the boys becoming more independent as teenagers, and generally feeling more connected to where we live.
The other attraction is the secondary schools. There seem to be several highly regarded state and grammar options in and around Tunbridge Wells, whereas where we are the choices feel more limited.

But then I look around our house and think… are we mad?

It’s taken years to create this home. The garden is exactly as we wanted, the house works brilliantly for family life, it’s peaceful and private despite the road, and the view still makes visitors stop and say “wow.” It’s also big enough that our boys will have space as they grow and we aren’t all on top of each other.

I’d describe it as like an island, very safe and private but life is contained within the boundary fences. I grew up in surburbia and didn’t realise how nice it was having the freedom to walk everywhere growing up.

I’m also conscious that perhaps we’re suffering from familiarity blindness, because we see the view every day, maybe we’ve stopped appreciating just how special it actually is. Would we only realise what we’d lost after we’d moved?

Financially we’d almost certainly end up with a less unique smaller house, a smaller garden and less privacy in order to gain the walkable location. I think we’d be lucky to break even and most likely we’d be down about 50k on what we’ve spent after fees etc.

Has anyone made a similar move?
Did moving to a walkable town genuinely improve everyday family life, or did the novelty wear off after a while? Equally, has anyone left a house they loved for the location and regretted it?

I’d really welcome honest opinions from people who’ve been in a similar position.

Would you swap a dream house for a walkable town?
Would you swap a dream house for a walkable town?
OP posts:
VictoriaEra · 27/07/2026 16:00

Voting for walkable. Now I can no longer drive, its non negotiable. Its better for children too as they grow and need to access places/friends.

CatherinedeBourgh · 27/07/2026 16:16

My kids were brought up in the middle of nowhere. When they became teens, we decided they would need more access to the world. We moved a few times, trying to find something that worked for everyone. They got to try village life, market town with everything walkable and good access into London, and semi rural but with a good train station a shortish drive away. They are now young adults, and desperate to move back to the middle of nowhere.

Some of us just prefer the rural life.

RedGreen2 · 28/07/2026 03:27

Your view is beautiful OP. However it comes down to personal choice and having lived in a semi rural property with a stunning view across countryside, I'd choose urban or suburban convenience and community.

I love being able to walk to shops and a town centre. DC walk to and from school. Older dc walks to and from her part time job.

There are still beautiful walks and settings in the suburbs, just not open countryside views like you have. It's a personal decision though and I can see why you may prefer to stay put.

GarlicEverywhere · 28/07/2026 03:53

Kent2024 · 26/07/2026 10:22

Thanks everyone for your comments. We visited TW yesterday and spent the whole day there, it was lovely. We walked all over town and the boys seemed to enjoy the freedom of being there. Viewed two houses and one is a contender although about 400 sq ft smaller than our current home with one less bedroom, no separate office, garden gym etc, but we could improve it over the years…

also felt nice coming home at the end of the day.. and this morning I’m quite emotional and torn about the whole thing. Maybe in time the right decision will become clearer.

What a lovely update. Wishing you well!

My reply was/is going to be: stay. Buy the kids really good bikes, teach them really good roadcraft, and give up your 21st-century angst. Become the amazing host to hordes of kids coming for weekends and sleepovers.

And this is despite the fact that I'd hate to live where you do! The place looks beautiful but I have learned I need pavements, street lights and shops. I was, however, A-road competent on two wheels by the age of 9.

Pipsquiggle · 28/07/2026 06:26

I grew up in the countryside. Loved it. My mum and dad ferried us everywhere and our mates stayed over. When we were 17 and got our driving license, our parents bought us a car - I think they were ecstatic that we passed our tests. We also went to private schools as the local secondary wasn't great.

Now I have my own DC, I do recognise that them being able to walk to stuff and get to school and back is super important. We live in a village but it's pretty easy for them to get to the next town.

We also live near very good schools which is a reason why we moved here. Doesn't Kent have the 11+ /grammars? You really need to do your research around this in terms of prep, admissions criteria and what's the backup plan should they not get the marks?

Ultimately this is the age old property dilemma of space v location which only you can answer.

hayyouuu · 28/07/2026 09:37

My husband and I have had the same dilemma. We’ve almost just moved to a rural location with our 14 and 10 year old, from a fairly affluent suburb of a small city in the south west. When it’s come to it, I just can’t do it. The village has a few small amenities but no fixed buses to nearby towns, my commute would have doubled, if not trebled, and the school runs for the next couple of years would have been torturous. Particularly for 10 year old who hates being in the car. Thinking ahead the 16+ study options were far more limited and transport to them limited also. Husband and I work full time in pressurised roles.

That said, I’d love to live in a quiet location with larger grounds and slightly more space. But the trade off for me isn’t worth it (husband vehemently disagrees).

I do wish we’d done it when the kids were small as they, and we, would know no different and that would just be our lives. So you may find that your lives will adapt and it’ll just be what it is. Don’t rush into anything and enjoy what you have, would be my advice ☺️

I’m hopeful that once our dc are older, husband and I may get escape to the country then. To enjoy our 50s and onwards in a quieter location, but for now I’ll make the most of what we have.

hugasaurus · 28/07/2026 09:44

It’s a tricky one. We have discussed upsizing but realistically to get an increase in size we would need to move out of our fairly sizeable village with lots of amenities to somewhere nearby that would require a car for almost everything and I can’t bring myself to make that move.

I love to walk, I love that the kids do lots of walking, I like that I can walk them to school and back, to the local shop for milk, to the coffee shop to meet friends, drop my car at the garage and walk home and then walk back to collect it, walk to extracurriculars in the evenings, walk to the train station, pop round to see pals on foot. I don’t want to drive everywhere, it’s not the lifestyle I want. But other people don’t seem to mind it. And it’s hard when you have such a lovely home you’ve worked so hard on. But I do think that with young kids, it’s not a location I would want for me despite the lovely view.

Grannydorey · 28/07/2026 10:08

I’ve been on both sides of this. As a child, my family lived fairly rurally on a busy country road, had to drive everywhere as nearest shops were at least a 15 min drive away. Mum had to do every single school run by car, morning and afternoon. Trade off was we were able to keep lots of animals, and friends loved visiting our house! However as a teen I felt very isolated and left out of many spontaneous social gatherings with friends as they were all within a few streets of each other.

When I had my own children I deliberately chose to live within a few mins walk of their primary and secondary schools so they willl be able to do all those things I missed out on! We could move further away and have a much bigger home, but for me the benefits of being able to walk to shops/schools/leisure centre/parks far outweigh the pleasure a nicer home would bring. We live in a lovely town with a strong community feel and I wouldn’t change it. Admittedly I never had your amazing views though!

Mymyi · 28/07/2026 10:14

Location, location, location.

I'd feel like I was in prison if I couldn't walk anywhere.

Milly16 · 28/07/2026 21:25

Grew up in a big house in the country - i really love the countryside, nature and walks. However, now live in zone 3 in london near big parks and my 2 teenage children are having a considerably better time than i did and are far more confident. And i get to do my thing rather than ferrying them around. 10 minutes drive and i'm out into nature reserves etc. A view is lovely but doesn't make you happy, any more than a pretty vase or picture does. It's nice to look at! Time to do your own thing, friends and hobbies, happy teens. All more important.

supercrone · 28/07/2026 21:38

That's a fabulous view. On the one hand, I'd love it. On the other I live right in the heart of the inner city in a capital city. My God I love it. Rarely if ever get the car out. Walk and cycle every where. My son has had pretty much complete freedom from 13 or so, daytime I mean, to wander as he wants. Pubs. Restaurants cinema theatre markets. Gigs etc. At weekends we go the country. Picnic. Swim. Walk. For me, the perfect balance. Living somewhere I would have to drive everywhere would be like a prison to me, but I know from being on Mumsnet that village life is the dream for most people. Definitely not for me though.

theresnolimits · 29/07/2026 08:07

We moved to the small market town. Kids walked to school, walked round to friends, walked or biked to shops and activities, took the regular bus service to the nearest big town …. They feel they had a blessed youth and have chosen similar locations for their families.

Don’t underestimate the worry of teens driving along country lanes when they’re older. You may trust yours, but do you trust anyone else who is giving them a lift? My kids could go to the pub or a party and walk home ( it’s very safe here).

And now we’re older, we can walk to the doctor, dentist, restaurants, weekly market. It won’t be a worry if we can’t drive. Maybe do the views and space on holiday? Love your house but couldn’t live there.

senua · 29/07/2026 09:09

A view is lovely but doesn't make you happy
I was up the top of the garden very early this morning, sitting in the arbour with a cup of coffee. The arbour is carefully positioned so I can watch the morning sunshine bursting over the hill. There was just me, the clear china-blue sky and the birds. It made me very happy.

Chickoletta · 29/07/2026 09:22

I live in a rural smallholding with no neighbours in sight and have teen DCs (16 and 13). They still love the space and peace and spend a lot of time outdoors despite so many people telling me that this would change when they got older! I do have to be quite generous with lifts and we often host their friends here, but none of us would swap our lifestyle for being in town. In our situation, most of their friends are also quite rural and far flung as they go to an independent school with pupils from all over the county, so maybe it would be different if everyone else was strolling into town and they weren’t. In your position, I certainly wouldn’t be giving up my beautiful, peaceful home any time soon!

Birchwoods · 29/07/2026 11:22

We’re considering the opposite, moving from the edge of town to a more rural location in a hamlet just outside a village, but still only 5-10 mins from town. Children are 4 and nearly 11, eldest starts secondary school in Sept, which is walking distance from our current house. I have always wanted to live rurally, I don’t like being surrounded by houses, cars and people, but I worry about hampering my eldest’s independence and we are right next to a huge common now anyway. I’ve come to the conclusion that even if we lived 5 or 10 mins out of town, she can walk to friends’ after school still (although she doesn’t currently have any friends within walking distance) and we can pick her up later. As we’re on the edge of town we’d likely still have to give her lifts anyway, so what’s an extra five minutes? It will mean that I have to do school drop offs and pick ups, and I was looking forward to her being able to walk, but DD2 starts school in Sept so I’ll be having to go out to do the school run anyway so may as well do an extra drop. I think it’ll be worth the extra hassle to live more rurally. We both work from home and have a small garden, so the extra outside space for us and the kids will be worth it. I have really been back and forth about it though and previously concluded that we need to stay in town, but I just won’t ever feel completely satisfied here.

MrAlyakhin · 29/07/2026 15:29

I think your current house looks amazing and I think your kids are still young enough that outdoor space is lovely to have.

I've got 3 kids and really the going out with all their mates independently has only really started from 15/16. Before that they still wanted ferrying places despite their being public transport. A mix of confidence, ease and also you might have one friend who is allowed to use the bus but another who isn't so end up getting a lift from parents. Also, depending on your kids you might even if you move find they do a hobby / sport etc that means you're still ferrying them everywhere anyway. So unless the secondary options are a real driver I would stay put for a few years yet and make the most of your current location.

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 29/07/2026 19:00

Go for the potential for teenage independence.

Seeingadistance · 30/07/2026 00:02

To be honest, I don't understand why you choose to live in a location which means you have to drive everywhere. As I child I lived in a similar location, but that was because it was a farm - our family business and livelihood.

As a teenager, I hated, hated, being dependent on my parents for lifts for every and any activity, and I missed out on so much that friends from school did - and that applied to primary school as well. I would hear about all the fun they'd had together - and I was always an outsider.

Children don't care about views.

hotmumshit · 30/07/2026 00:08

Any update, op? @Kent2024

Not to be a dick, but how difficult is it to get cabs to and from your place, after a night out etc?

The kids can learn to drive when theyre 16!

WeAreNotOk · 30/07/2026 22:05

I was a teen in a village and I hated it and I vowed never to put that on my DC. I can honestly say it hampered my devolvement as I was simply not independant or exposed to life outside the village.
The freedom to walk your DC to school, go the the shops, the swimming pool, cinema, restaurants and numerous parks far outweighs 'lovely views'. Since my DC has been a teen, I've never had to drive him anywhere. He has freedom.
I'm not sure even when I'm older and DC has flown the nest that I'd want to live back in the country for the space and views. As you get older, you tend to need the easy conveniences your DC needed, lol.
A sea view wouldn't go amiss though.

New posts on this thread. Refresh page