Morning all, we all sound tired today don't we? Hope some dc, yummy mummies and mummies-to-be passed a comfortable night. Apart from the bloomin' 'up twice to pee' story mine wasn't too bad. JW, have those pears come through yet?
Tee, it was indeed easier when we were girls, as hedgepig says. You either went to a state or a state-aided (RC or CofE) primary and by the time you reached Junior 4 (Year 6 these days), depending on the politics of your local education authority, you either went to a comprehensive or had to sit the 11-plus exam and go to a grammar or a secondary modern. Or you went private.
I'm still all in favour of a really good comp where you get a complete social and educational mix - with appropriately-skilled teachers to work at all levels - but now that there is so much 'choice', parents who can afford to will move near a good school (as mrsb describes) so you often find that there are essentially middle-class comps and 'sink-school' comps, thus mirroring the grammar school system. If you live in a place where school places are selective on the basis of the 11-plus, many of the 'comps' are inevitably not at all comprehensive because the brightest kids have been creamed off. And if your child is a late developer - lots of kids don't do well at 11 but are much better academically at 14 - they could be stuck there forever and never be given the chance to achieve their potential.
Ofsted hasn't been around for that long, came in around the time the National Curriculum came in. Both good ideas in theory, both problematic in practice. mrsb, you're right that you can't judge a school just on its Ofsted - our DD's junior school got Outstanding in every single area and that's just not true - the Head used to be an Ofsted inspector and I think it's insider dealing. And while they're supposed to judge a school's atmosphere and ethos, they really do focus on results, so a middle-class catchment will almost always get a better Ofsted. You need to look at the range ie. even if the average GCSE points aren't fantastic, are some kids achieving top grades?
Everything is more competitive and more extreme in London and the home counties.
Bailing out private schools who've buggered up their finances makes me . The fact independent schools still have charity status makes me
Calm down now Ermintrude. Have a cup of tea. Do not look at the DM website. Breathe...