katyjo, so sorry to hear about Hamish's chickenpox - hope he's not suffering too badly with it.
Essie, I am absolutely horrified at that woman going into school to bf her 8 year old! I had a mum who used to come in every lunchtime and dose her pathetic child daughter up with calpol every day (no, there was nothing wrong with her!), but to breast feed!!
Mind you, I bet if you posted that on the bf forum they would all tell you it was fine and stop being so judgey!
neenz, you really musn't worry so much about us BLWers! If it's not for you then don't do it - I don't think you need to worry about what other people on MN think, esp on the weaning boards. If you read the bf boards there's women on there who liken giving formula to babies to feeding them rat poison, do you think I worry about it?! BLW is working well for us because Alex enjoys it (and finally today actually ate loads) and it means that he can eat with us rather than me feeding him first then eating my dinner. It's been a godsend over the festive period with all the entertaining. As for sleeping, it's ok, no better or worse than other babies - some BLW, some puree. The best two sleepers in our NCT group are opposites in terms of their feeding: one is BLW and eats loads and one is puree fed and hardly eats a thing! The worse sleeper eats three pureed meals a day and still wakes three times a night at least.
As for the salt, as snowqueen says I really don't think it's any more of a risk with BLW than it is with purees, unless you're going to live on a diet of processed food!
Btw, had to laugh at you quoting Patrick Holford - I'm a big fan of Ben Goldacre's bad science column in The Guardian and he's had a long running feud with Holford and claims he's a complete charlatan!
Holford Watch
His research has been seriously discredited on more than one occasion and he has been found to have been lying about his research credentials!
So I'm with SA on steering clear of books - I just go with what I know and if in doubt do it the old-fashioned way, i.e. ask my mum!
Allnew, of course he prefers Aptamil - it's exactly the same as breast milk!