hopefully I think it came across as a philosophical observation on parenthood.
carrieon thanks for the suggestions, and foxy thanks very much for the link. That is extremely interesting! I had a long talk with my sister yesterday, and she is a babywise devotee! (born again christian mother of six). I have A LOT of respect for her as a parent, but we agreed to disagree about many of her methods, especially controlled crying - I said I could not do this, esp not to an 8 week old baby. That said, her kids are all well adjusted, outgoing, secure, and independent people I love to spend time with. My conclusion is I am not in a position to criticise what others do, only to inform myself as best I can and decide what is right and wrong for my family.
I think I am now beginning to get to a good place as far as developing confidence in my own instincts as a parent, a la hopefully's comments. If/when I do adopt a routine I feel I will have the courage to make good choices and not be afraid to leave the things I don't feel right about.
My sister and I observed that if we had had to decide pre-pregnancy whether I would be a control/routine mother or a cuddles/on demand mother we would have thought the former. As I have turned out to be a total softie it just shows you really don't know yourself until you are a parent!