I don't think I really mean night weaning as in, never feeding her or giving her a drink in the night - I just mean trying to stop her waking up and wanting to suck a boob every 2 hours. For example, if she's had 210ml of formula or a full double boob feed at 11.30, she's not actually hungry at 1.30am when she wakes up, but she'll cry until she gets put on a boob... at which point she'll suck for maybe 5 seconds, then pull off and fall immediately asleep. Dummies don't work in the same way (although they will sometimes, probably one time in every ten - I try them more often, and sometimes she'll try herself).
So I feel that she does need to be 'denied' a feed really - not all the time, not every time, but definitely some of the time. I have water in both a bottle and her sippy cup by the bed, but trying to give her that just ramps up the crying.
Up until now I'm pretty sure she's been genuinely hungry in the night - she's small, and gets distracted during the day when eating - but we've addressed a lot of the distraction stuff, and obviously now that there is a fair amount of formula involved, I know how much she's getting.
I would just like to sleep for more than 3 hours at some point before she turns 5. Ha.