Help protect children from gaming harms.

Take our survey

Please or to access all these features

Politics

Andy Burnham

166 replies

Hurrydash · 18/07/2026 01:43

He has a plan. So great to know.
Be even better to know what it is.
Is it cunning?
Does it involve turnips?
Will he present time team when Labour is annihilated in 2029?
Wow the suspense😀

OP posts:
NorthXNorthWest · 06/08/2026 13:11

NorthXNorthWest · 06/08/2026 12:42

It all sounds a bit Brave New World.

In this brave new world of "fairness" are we restricting child birth to machines or the genetically pure? Are we engineering humans based on the role the state would like them to have and to live where the state would like them to live? Will compliance be enforced medically?

People don't seem to care that a cash-poor, lone 85-year-old living in a house valued at £1 million on paper, with four spare bedrooms, is a symptom of a failing system, not the cause of it. As are a couple earning over £100,000 a year who live in a council home under older lifetime tenancy agreements, and a newly arrived undocumented person or family who receives a council home ahead of a UK resident who should be at the top of the housing waiting list.

We need to address the root cause and symptoms, treat everybody as humans not just those in/ in need of social homes.

@C8H10N4O2

HarshbutTrue2 · 06/08/2026 14:04

pointythings · 06/08/2026 09:56

The criteria for social housing are perfectly clear. What @RodneyKitten is saying is essentially the Reform/Restore position, meaning that foreign nationals shouldn't have any access to social housing.

What are the criteria for social housing? I have asked this previously. I didn't get a reply.

Our local social housing is run by a housing trust. There's literally thousands of new houses being built by us. 1,300 estate being built. We have had 2 years of disruption. Most of them are over 500k. There's a few social housing. Once those are built, another 700 are being built 2 miles away.

There's plenty of private housing to rent. What is the difference between renting privately and having a council house?

sunshinesuzey · 06/08/2026 14:16

@HarshbutTrue2 "What are the criteria for social housing? I have asked this previously. I didn't get a reply."

I think it varies according to Local Authority.

This may help - https://www.lincshomefinder.co.uk/content/Using_this_service/Whocanapply

concertinacornflake · 06/08/2026 14:28

What is the difference between renting privately and having a council house?

  • security of tenancy
  • cost
  • rights as tenant
HarshbutTrue2 · 06/08/2026 18:18

EEexpat · 06/08/2026 11:02

@blossomtoes

Because they don’t want strangers in their house.

Is that not nimbynism?

Half of MN won’t even answer their front door or allow a tradesman to use their loo!

Trades persons I have used recently have said their employers don’t allow them to use such facilities and they must use public facilities.

I tell them to go behind my outdoor cabin as it’s out of sight.

What is an outdoor cabin? I haven't got one.

I have got more than one spare bedroom. I worked hard and bought and paid for them. They occasionally have guests in them. They belong to me and I don't want strangers in them. I pay plenty of council tax for them and keep them heated etc.

I don't have spare en suite bathrooms so I doubt anyone would want to rent one of my rooms anyway.

Sometimessmiling · 06/08/2026 18:24

Monty36 · 20/07/2026 13:36

Something tells me whatever he said or did you would find something about it that displeased you. Nanda 66.

Yes let's give him a chance. People just want him to fail how about hoping he will succeed

HarshbutTrue2 · 06/08/2026 18:32

NorthXNorthWest · 06/08/2026 11:29

What I’m saying is the people who used to have a big family and the respective housing have to be asked to downsize.

To where? Who pays the moving costs? What if there isn't suitable smaller accommodation nearby? What about support networks, healthcare or caring responsibilities? Should older people simply be expected to move regardless of the cost, inconvenience or suitability? Whilst some might hold out most people would downsize if practical solutions were available.

People who earn more should also be asked to leave.

Who is going to leave voluntarily? If they don't, how would you legally require them to leave?

People who have another property anywhere also should not be housed.

Do councils currently give social housing to people who already own another property? Surely that is already taken into account. y.

You say it's common sense, but there are practical questions behind each proposal.

I suppose it's easier to view everyone who needs social housing as human while treating everyone else, especially the elderly and the productive, as a problem to be solved by force. Lets just ignore practical constraints, rather that address them.🙄

It's actually far from commonsense.

I actually agree with some of this. I used to know a few people who lived in council houses. Some bought their council houses, some bought a house elsewhere. The most memorable one bought a huge house with land in the countryside, because he couldn't fit his rolls royce on the drive of his council house. He asked the council to widen the drive, but they refused.

People who do not have a big family should not have a large council house. It is social housing. It does not belong to them, it is for the good of society in general. In years gone by oldies got moved from council houses into council flats. I wouldn't really like to see a return to those days.
There used to be small council bungalows for oldies, these seem to be used by disabled persons now. Maybe we need to build more of these.

EEexpat · 06/08/2026 18:33

@HarshbutTrue2

I pay plenty of council tax for them and keep them heated etc.

Council tax might be lower if councils weren’t spending money on hotels if people used the rent a room scheme.

My outdoor cabin is a log cabin. Has enough space for bed, tv, sitting area. Could cook on the log burner if needed.

HarshbutTrue2 · 06/08/2026 18:42

concertinacornflake · 06/08/2026 14:28

What is the difference between renting privately and having a council house?

  • security of tenancy
  • cost
  • rights as tenant

The new laws that Labour are bringing in are guaranteeing all of the above.
Many landlords are trying to get out because of the laws.
I believe a Labour mp was in breach of the laws.

As regards cost, why should some people get cheaper houses than others? Is there a new hierarchy now, those in private rented are somehow better/richer than those who live in council houses?

When Thatcher sold off the council houses it was a very popular move. In the 80s lots of people were aspirational. They were proud to own their own property. They built extensions. I think a lot bought new front doors, to distinguish themselves from their neighbours who still rented.

Unfortunately, Thatcher failed to realise that not all sectors of society had the gumption, aspirations or capability to own their own home.

pointythings · 06/08/2026 21:06

HarshbutTrue2 · 06/08/2026 18:42

The new laws that Labour are bringing in are guaranteeing all of the above.
Many landlords are trying to get out because of the laws.
I believe a Labour mp was in breach of the laws.

As regards cost, why should some people get cheaper houses than others? Is there a new hierarchy now, those in private rented are somehow better/richer than those who live in council houses?

When Thatcher sold off the council houses it was a very popular move. In the 80s lots of people were aspirational. They were proud to own their own property. They built extensions. I think a lot bought new front doors, to distinguish themselves from their neighbours who still rented.

Unfortunately, Thatcher failed to realise that not all sectors of society had the gumption, aspirations or capability to own their own home.

Thatcher also failed, probably wilfully, to understand that everyone should be able to have a safe, warm, affordable roof over their head in one of the richest countries on earth. A house is an essential for everyone. It should never be a cash cow.

BIossomtoes · 06/08/2026 21:11

A lot of those former council house tenants sold up as soon as they could and the houses are now privately let. Not much aspirational about that, more exploitative.

Sometimessmiling · 06/08/2026 21:39

HarshbutTrue2 · 06/08/2026 18:32

I actually agree with some of this. I used to know a few people who lived in council houses. Some bought their council houses, some bought a house elsewhere. The most memorable one bought a huge house with land in the countryside, because he couldn't fit his rolls royce on the drive of his council house. He asked the council to widen the drive, but they refused.

People who do not have a big family should not have a large council house. It is social housing. It does not belong to them, it is for the good of society in general. In years gone by oldies got moved from council houses into council flats. I wouldn't really like to see a return to those days.
There used to be small council bungalows for oldies, these seem to be used by disabled persons now. Maybe we need to build more of these.

Derogatory term Oldies very disrespectful of you.

HarshbutTrue2 · 07/08/2026 06:47

BIossomtoes · 06/08/2026 21:11

A lot of those former council house tenants sold up as soon as they could and the houses are now privately let. Not much aspirational about that, more exploitative.

All the ones I knew who bought their council houses stayed in them. I know someone who is living in her parents council house, which they had bought. She inherited it.

Most of the people I knew with purchased council houses stayed in them until they died. Obviously, their kids usually sold the houses after their deaths. That's what kids normally do when a parent dies.

A lot of those ex council houses in our area are now owned by a housing trust. Some are private landlords, some are bought as family homes.

GMB has just explained that social housing is for people on low incomes. 11% of social housing occupants are foreigners.

HarshbutTrue2 · 07/08/2026 06:54

Sometimessmiling · 06/08/2026 21:39

Derogatory term Oldies very disrespectful of you.

Not nearly as derogatory as all the mumsnetters who hate oldies, wish they were dead, begrudge them their pension and can't wait to grab their in-laws money.

I am an oldie myself. I don't mind the term. I do not see myself as a senior citizen, or a pensioner or any other term you'd like to use. Im simply a person who is older than a lot of the population. But I've still got a long way to go.

I never hated my parents. I never begrudged them the money which they worked hard for. I simply went out and worked hard to earn my own money.

EEexpat · 10/08/2026 11:22

@HarshbutTrue2

I simply went out and worked hard to earn my own money.

Me too. When I was at school I did a milk round four mornings per week Pay was £1.20 per morning (1979) and £2 for Saturdays. So, £5.60 per week. I gave my mother £3 to help with groceries.

During summer holidays, I worked a 60 hour week for £1.93 per hour with uplifts for overtime and Saturday. Take home was about £80 per week (1981). I gave my mother £30

pointythings · 10/08/2026 13:53

EEexpat · 10/08/2026 11:22

@HarshbutTrue2

I simply went out and worked hard to earn my own money.

Me too. When I was at school I did a milk round four mornings per week Pay was £1.20 per morning (1979) and £2 for Saturdays. So, £5.60 per week. I gave my mother £3 to help with groceries.

During summer holidays, I worked a 60 hour week for £1.93 per hour with uplifts for overtime and Saturday. Take home was about £80 per week (1981). I gave my mother £30

Ah, the good old days...

New posts on this thread. Refresh page