Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Politics

Elon musk salute

1000 replies

EasterIssland · 20/01/2025 22:20

Has he really done a nazi salute in the trump inauguration celebration? 🤦🏻‍♀️

OP posts:
Thread gallery
44
StandFirm · 21/01/2025 14:08

Nesbi · 21/01/2025 13:42

I think to understand the culture we’re increasingly living in people need to learn more about the history of Gamergate, pizza gate, 4Chan and the whole approach to trolling and culture wars which has been playing out over the last few years, and which Musk seems to be absolutely steeped in (as his “pedo” comments about the British cave diving expert demonstrated).

Acknowledging that Musk deliberately threw that salute in those circumstances (fully knowing knowing what it would look like) doesn’t mean you have to believe that he is a dyed-in-the-wool Nazi who is finally revealing his true colours.

More likely I think is that he saw it as something more like a dangerous prank, an adrenaline rush, something he could deny but which would be recognised and supported by the audience he now wants to be part of. He knew it would generate a strong reaction, and he knew that it would trigger another round of culture war arguing. He’ll also know that he is currently very well protected by Trump, he is the richest man in the world, and in his own mind he is essentially untouchable.

I think he did it so that when he got off the stage he would get a load of locker room style slaps on the back from his new friends saying “Man, I can’t believe you did that up there, that was SO COOL BRO, the Libtards are going to go MENTAL” and he gets to be the cool rebel and get the bad boy approval he desperately and quite pathetically craves.

Then he can sit back and chuckle at all the comments that are generated, and feel that he is at the centre of the global conversation. Once the fuss dies down he will do something like it again.

These are the times we live in - an Oligarchy in control of the US, a world at the mercy of billionaire trolls, no accountability, no morality, just chaos and profit.

YES! That is why I keep referring to his SM profile. It really says it all. I have personally and very painfully lost someone to the gamer/chan world and its rabbit holes. It's like a fucking cult and it's poisoning our world and our minds.

coxesorangepippin · 21/01/2025 14:09

This gesture has too much weight, that is the problem

^

Scary stuff

JoyousGreyOrca · 21/01/2025 14:09

lazlosaisthistimeiknowsoursidewillwin · 21/01/2025 14:07

The mess in the US about abortion came under Democrat watch. If you care about abortion, start threads on MN about how you think that the US should follow other western countries and ensure abortions are subject to the same rules in all states, maybe following the same rules as apply in the UK for example. This would be far more effective than making the sort of comments you are making here, which come across as scare mongering.

Not scare mongering at all. The groups that campaigned for an abortion ban are quite clear that their next goal is to outlaw contraception.

Salacia · 21/01/2025 14:09

lazlosaisthistimeiknowsoursidewillwin · 21/01/2025 13:54

I don't think that was a very joyous comment, joyous. I also have Jewish family and agree with @sparrowse Hitler's ideology involved killing Jews and Slavs and disabled people and millions and millions died. The inhumanity was staggering. There is no comparison between that and Musk. Nor any of the world leaders who are so often tarnished with ignorant false comparisons.

If Musk starts talking about wiping out entire genetic groups, then you might have something to talk about.

But Hitler didn’t start with that. He didn’t start with talking about or promising the final solution. He manipulated his way into power manipulated the people via propaganda which is why we need to be wise to it happening again. And I think one of the richest men in the world, a man affiliated with the far right, a man who owns one of the largest social media platforms, buying his way into world politics and then shamelessly performing a Nazi salute with the eyes of the world on him is surely a cause for concern.

The amount of users on her defending a Nazi salute is terrifying.

JustSawJohnny · 21/01/2025 14:09

AzurePanda · 21/01/2025 14:02

@JustSawJohnny really? Someone has a different interpretation of something and that tells you “everything” about them?!

As I said, if you want to try to play down TWO blatant Nazi salutes from a man who is heavily linked financially to fascist parties in Europe then THAT IS ON YOU!

Watch GB News and other alt-right gobshites play it down all you want but know people are watching and judging.

He's now saying he was 'throwing out love' - in an accidentally Nazi way, yeah?

Do me a favour.

He's doing what he said he would do.

Not all of us will make excuses for him.

StandFirm · 21/01/2025 14:09

StandFirm · 21/01/2025 14:08

YES! That is why I keep referring to his SM profile. It really says it all. I have personally and very painfully lost someone to the gamer/chan world and its rabbit holes. It's like a fucking cult and it's poisoning our world and our minds.

But having said that, what he is doing IS promoting a very dangerous ideology. Summon up the devil and he will show up...

amoreoamicizia · 21/01/2025 14:12

What tells you definitively that this was a Nazi salute is the way the fingers are held flat on a plane and together. If you were really to make a gesture of throwing out your heart, your hand, palm and fingers would be relaxed. But Musk's palm is flat with his fingers together. Try it. It is a deliberate and undeniable gesture. You cannot do it accidentally; the natural position of the hand and fingers is curled and you must actively use your muscles and tendons to make a flat palm with fingers together. I hope this is informative for those of you who are unsure.

stormy4319trevor · 21/01/2025 14:18

@amoreoamicizia I think so too. Also, his arm is rigid, not relaxed. It really looks intentional to me. Either meant to be controversial/prank or to signal alliances in a way which can't be definitively called out. Has he apologised? If it was accidental one would expect him to be apologetic for causing offence.

fromthevault · 21/01/2025 14:19

rewilded · 21/01/2025 14:03

Thank you for your reply.

Throughout my youth this gesture was used easily without too much weight, to indicate someone who held irrational, controlling beliefs etc Why are we not able to use this gesture now? Who is offended? Is it the Jewish community or is it the Liberals?

This gesture has too much weight, that is the problem. The meaning of the gesture has changed because of censorship. It was ridiculed before and couldn't scare people, now if we use it we are said to be part of a growing movement - we are about to cause another human catastrophy. This is what 'Woke' culture creates - monsters down the road that need to be dealt with.

Make Nazis Normal Again

thepariscrimefiles · 21/01/2025 14:19

lazlosaisthistimeiknowsoursidewillwin · 21/01/2025 14:04

It isn't a question of just getting a right wing party elected for the sake of it at the moment, though.

If Musk starts talking about wiping out entire genetic groups, then you might have something to talk about. Until then it sounds like discrediting for the sake of some agenda. That might not be your intention, but it is how it sounds.

Try to be specific about policies you don't like and why, rather than attack people. You know the phrase - play the ball not the player.

Even Hitler didn't start talking about wiping out entire ethnic groups when he first came to power in 1933. It started with dehumanisation and scapegoating of certain groups, predominantly Jews, but also homosexuals, gypsies/Roma, the disabled. They were blamed for the poor economic conditions so when the violent persecution started in earnest, most Germans went along with this.

It won't necessarily start with the same groups, but certain immigrant groups are already being targetted.

Nesbi · 21/01/2025 14:20

The danger which we will keep facing is that they understand that moments like these can become a compelling focal point for all the anger and frustration, and the ambiguity means that people will be drawn in to endless (and ultimately pointless) arguments about what was or wasn’t intended, or what exactly a Nazi salute consists of - it is exhausting, and deliberately so.

If we take the view that he is behaving like the disruptive kid in class - the one who wants to get one over on the adults, the one who’ll stick his middle finger up at the teacher and then pretend it was a hand cramp - then really we should avoid getting sucked in because the ensuing argument is all part of the disruptive performance.

Our energy and focus should be saved for the things they do that are really significant - the legislative changes, the things that will have lasting impact on the country and on the globe.

If the newspapers and social media are full to the brim with arguments about Nazi salutes, (or the Gulf of America, whatever other ridiculous or insulting thing they say or do tomorrow) what else is going to be happening in the background that isn’t getting talked about enough?

sparrowse · 21/01/2025 14:21

amoreoamicizia · 21/01/2025 14:12

What tells you definitively that this was a Nazi salute is the way the fingers are held flat on a plane and together. If you were really to make a gesture of throwing out your heart, your hand, palm and fingers would be relaxed. But Musk's palm is flat with his fingers together. Try it. It is a deliberate and undeniable gesture. You cannot do it accidentally; the natural position of the hand and fingers is curled and you must actively use your muscles and tendons to make a flat palm with fingers together. I hope this is informative for those of you who are unsure.

Edited

Not really. I don't base my opinions on what others are thinking in their heads on your one true definitive 'proof'. I find this view terrifying.

GanninHyem · 21/01/2025 14:22

ilovemoney · 21/01/2025 00:11

This thread is so bonkers. He was clearly touching his heart and throwing it and he then said he was throwing his heart out there.
he is awkward and has autism.
he is not a politician.
he is a genius and is massively generous to charities.
he has recently visited auchwitz
seriously what are you all on.

His fan boys say he is a genius. A genius would know the significance of such a salute and a be highly aware of the connotation of his actions. So if you're so insistent he is a genius what does that say?

Using "he's autistic" as an excuse is fucking reprehensible.

user22446688 · 21/01/2025 14:23

whereaw · 21/01/2025 13:38

@user22446688 people like me?

Yes. People who seem to not understand everything that's attached to this arm movement. People who argue those who use it, without apology or explanation, whether intentionally or not, are 'against division and hate.'

It's a literal symbol of division and hate.

AzurePanda · 21/01/2025 14:24

@amoreoamicizia does smiling, touching his heart first, saying “thank you, thank you” and then “my heart goes out to you” also definitively make it a
Nazi salute or is it just the fingers?

user22446688 · 21/01/2025 14:25

rewilded · 21/01/2025 13:29

Ok...don't all jump on me for suggesting this but what if he is trying to reclaim or be allowed to move his body how he wants? He knows it's a provocative gesture but why shouldn't he be able to reframe this movement and take the weight out of it - free speech narrative.

John Cleese et al used this in comedy for a couple of decades. It shouldn't have so much power so that everyone is frothing over it.

Disclaimer - Remember I am playing devil's advocate and just trying to break down what has happened and not trying to cause offense/be insensitve or start an argument.

So, your argument is that it's somehow like black people reclaiming the N word?

Wow.

whereaw · 21/01/2025 14:26

@Nesbi I probably wouldn't agree with you on everything but totally agree with what you are saying here too. It feels more and more impossible to actually discuss important things and have real debates, rather than slinging insults.

user22446688 · 21/01/2025 14:27

Nesbi · 21/01/2025 13:42

I think to understand the culture we’re increasingly living in people need to learn more about the history of Gamergate, pizza gate, 4Chan and the whole approach to trolling and culture wars which has been playing out over the last few years, and which Musk seems to be absolutely steeped in (as his “pedo” comments about the British cave diving expert demonstrated).

Acknowledging that Musk deliberately threw that salute in those circumstances (fully knowing knowing what it would look like) doesn’t mean you have to believe that he is a dyed-in-the-wool Nazi who is finally revealing his true colours.

More likely I think is that he saw it as something more like a dangerous prank, an adrenaline rush, something he could deny but which would be recognised and supported by the audience he now wants to be part of. He knew it would generate a strong reaction, and he knew that it would trigger another round of culture war arguing. He’ll also know that he is currently very well protected by Trump, he is the richest man in the world, and in his own mind he is essentially untouchable.

I think he did it so that when he got off the stage he would get a load of locker room style slaps on the back from his new friends saying “Man, I can’t believe you did that up there, that was SO COOL BRO, the Libtards are going to go MENTAL” and he gets to be the cool rebel and get the bad boy approval he desperately and quite pathetically craves.

Then he can sit back and chuckle at all the comments that are generated, and feel that he is at the centre of the global conversation. Once the fuss dies down he will do something like it again.

These are the times we live in - an Oligarchy in control of the US, a world at the mercy of billionaire trolls, no accountability, no morality, just chaos and profit.

Yes, exactly.

Fattyfattybumbumface · 21/01/2025 14:29

Yes, this exactly.

amoreoamicizia · 21/01/2025 14:33

AzurePanda · 21/01/2025 14:24

@amoreoamicizia does smiling, touching his heart first, saying “thank you, thank you” and then “my heart goes out to you” also definitively make it a
Nazi salute or is it just the fingers?

Referring to the gesture made, it is the fingers held rigid on a flat plane with a flat palm which makes it a Nazi salute, yes, because that and the unusual angle of the arm held aloft are the defining and instantly recognisable features of such a salute.

CreationNat1on · 21/01/2025 14:37

The Natzi Solute.

Melania's military inspired fashion.

YMCA - Young Men's Christian Association. (what about other faiths, and women)?

TRUMP dancing with the sword.

This is ALL choreographed. They are normalising this fascist dictatorship. They are brainwashing their audience.

When an abuser shows you who/what they are, believe them.

user22446688 · 21/01/2025 14:42

Oh, look, one of the Jan 6 rioters just pardoned by Trump. Good thing Elon can keep them onside.

To give the benefit of the doubt, I suppose it's possible some of the Nazi salute apologists on this thread don't fully understand the political landscape in the US.

Elon musk salute
AzurePanda · 21/01/2025 14:44

@CreationNat1on seems odd to use arguably the biggest gay icon musical group in history to usher in a facist dictatorship but hey ho.

Marriumph · 21/01/2025 14:45

Nesbi · 21/01/2025 13:42

I think to understand the culture we’re increasingly living in people need to learn more about the history of Gamergate, pizza gate, 4Chan and the whole approach to trolling and culture wars which has been playing out over the last few years, and which Musk seems to be absolutely steeped in (as his “pedo” comments about the British cave diving expert demonstrated).

Acknowledging that Musk deliberately threw that salute in those circumstances (fully knowing knowing what it would look like) doesn’t mean you have to believe that he is a dyed-in-the-wool Nazi who is finally revealing his true colours.

More likely I think is that he saw it as something more like a dangerous prank, an adrenaline rush, something he could deny but which would be recognised and supported by the audience he now wants to be part of. He knew it would generate a strong reaction, and he knew that it would trigger another round of culture war arguing. He’ll also know that he is currently very well protected by Trump, he is the richest man in the world, and in his own mind he is essentially untouchable.

I think he did it so that when he got off the stage he would get a load of locker room style slaps on the back from his new friends saying “Man, I can’t believe you did that up there, that was SO COOL BRO, the Libtards are going to go MENTAL” and he gets to be the cool rebel and get the bad boy approval he desperately and quite pathetically craves.

Then he can sit back and chuckle at all the comments that are generated, and feel that he is at the centre of the global conversation. Once the fuss dies down he will do something like it again.

These are the times we live in - an Oligarchy in control of the US, a world at the mercy of billionaire trolls, no accountability, no morality, just chaos and profit.

Well put. I think so too.

Tittat50 · 21/01/2025 14:45

I agree.

I have found here when posters can be very logical and with evidence say hey look at this, I've grown an understanding and have shifted my position. This works much better. Not always easy though. This situation is potentially very scary.

Someone posted a list of factors that we need to consider. One said - he is Autistic. I believe it's relevant. Loads of other factors are relevant. His questionable history, his apparent drug use, more I don't know about yet.

No one is saying 'Autism made him innit. ' No one is saying anything so simplistic. I think it's absolutely ok to highly some uncomfortable things.

The concept that he knowingly did that and meant it is terrifying tbh. That's going to take time for people to grasp if he did. ( Me too).

I remember the book by Naomi Wolf ' The End of America'. The gradual shift that blindly made people go along with Hitler in the end, without realising what they had agreed to until way too late. I feel that's what posters are shouting out here.

Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.