Meet the Other Phone. Flexible and made to last.

Meet the Other Phone.
Flexible and made to last.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Politics

Reform party seems to be ahead in my area.

237 replies

Moier · 20/06/2024 18:55

Any of you voting Reform?
My area was always labour..( I've never voted labour).. but according to what I'm reading.. it's surprisingly gone the other way.
Will have to wait and see.
Did him being in I'm a Celebrity make him more popular..or is the extreme right the way to go?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Noddedoffagain · 23/06/2024 08:55

Validus · 22/06/2024 13:24

Thank you for engaging on a point of policy rather than the usual hyperbolic dross seen on these threads.

I’m going to assume the policy you present in such negative terms is the plan to replace the equalities act. Next to that aim, in the ‘contract’ it is explained that they want to stop positive discrimination on the basis that it is best for the economy if people are hired based on ability and merit, not quotas.

Bluntly, I don’t see a problem with that. Eg I want my doctors to be the best, not selected for their skin colour or other protected characteristic.

Now, perhaps they want to make other changes to it as well - but a spot of googling has not revealed a stated desire to scrap “women’s rights, and protections for gay people, disabled people and ethnic minorities”. In fact various of the contract promises are clear that women’s rights are to be protected far more than the other parties (excluding the shitshow that is the Tories) could even countenance.

I would be very interested to read statements, by farage and reform - not ‘interpretations’ by others - as to what else they would change on the equalities act. If you have any links, please do share.

Unfortunately, most commentators on this site prefer to say ‘go and google it’ - which I note I have done. Often it turns out that they are not basing their opinions on fact, but are instead simply repeating a position that someone fed to them. They then try to hide that lack of foundation by calling anyone who doesn’t fall in line with them a racist, bigot or other names. Which is of course tedious and fails to move the debate on in any meaningful or useful way.

My points stand. If the policies are bad and the intentions poor, they can be defeated via debate. But to have that debate, the other ‘side’ has to engage properly, rather than acting in an arrogant and supercilious manner towards those they clearly see as inferior in many ways.

Positive discrimination doesn’t mean you get a shoe in as a person with a protected characteristic- it means if two candidates come neck and neck, the white male will miss out, because white men are massively over represented in lots of areas, but especially top jobs. As a woman, I feel that this is something I want to continue. It’s still hard and we still get paid less for the same work. I imagine it’s the same for people of colour. Until we have true equality I’m happy to keep
it.

Anonym00se · 23/06/2024 09:03

@Validus I would add to that, that the media needs to tell their interviewers to shut up and allow long form answers. Then think about the answer and ask proper follow up, open questions (rather than the antagonist, ‘gotcha’ statements they are now prone to). Most interviews these days seem to just be the interviewer interrupting and then pushing their own views.

I agree completely. The standard of the ‘debates’ has been an embarrassment.

Validus · 23/06/2024 09:48

@Noddedoffagain the thing is - I don’t think there’s ever a situation where they are neck and neck. Ever. There’s too much variability in humans.

There’s also the problem that employers misunderstand the concept and apply it as ‘hire the woman’ even if the man is better. Which does happen (am a lawyer, have literally seen this occur and not one off).

But that’s fine. You have a view. So do I. I would like the EA to be redone to make it better. You may also wish to rejig it. I’m sure that reasoned discussIon in Parliament, the people paid to do this could teach a compromise position that works.

Froglight · 23/06/2024 12:37

Validus · 23/06/2024 08:36

their economic proposals mean that anybody voting for them is swimming at the shallow end of the gene pool in terms of brain capacity

And again with the insults. It’s this kind of discourse that needs to stop. It’s - completely unnecessary attack on others and does nothing to move a debate on. What it does is get everyone’s backs up and causes entrenchment. Please stop.

All parties claim they have fully costed plans, and it always turns out to be fantasy. I would expect that Reform voters don’t care about that because they don’t expect Reform to be the governing party. However, what Reform offers is, in the long term, very attractive to many people. they’d quite like someone in opposition (or at least in Parliament) to be raising these things and making the governing party address them rather than sweeping them under the carpet.

How can they demand the governing party address these issues if they have no credible plan to do so themselves? Just shouting about how much you hate things with no viable solutions to suggest to your perceived problems is pointless and dishonest.

And I'm afraid that Reform's economic proposals are far more delusional than those of the other parties, which is saying something! Being overly optimistic is one thing, deliberately deceiving people is another. And for you to state that you think their voters don't care that their proposed policy solutions are not realistic or remotely viable rather proves the point made in my earlier comment.

justasking111 · 23/06/2024 14:43

Look if a private company hires a person to tick an equalities box rather than the best candidate that's their business. I'm only concerned if it's a public service that we're all paying for.

In our business I interviewed regularly. It's a male dominated industry heavy construction equipment. She set off alarm bells at interview with an aggressive vibe. I chose someone else.

A year later there she was in the local rag suing the council who hired her for sex discrimination. She won a five figure sum.

Jakers we dodged a bullet 🙈

yellowspanner · 24/06/2024 21:46

I will be voting Reform as will members of my family

Noddedoffagain · 24/06/2024 21:49

yellowspanner · 24/06/2024 21:46

I will be voting Reform as will members of my family

Why? And have you seen the video shared above of Farages key moments?

Noddedoffagain · 24/06/2024 21:55

Validus · 23/06/2024 09:48

@Noddedoffagain the thing is - I don’t think there’s ever a situation where they are neck and neck. Ever. There’s too much variability in humans.

There’s also the problem that employers misunderstand the concept and apply it as ‘hire the woman’ even if the man is better. Which does happen (am a lawyer, have literally seen this occur and not one off).

But that’s fine. You have a view. So do I. I would like the EA to be redone to make it better. You may also wish to rejig it. I’m sure that reasoned discussIon in Parliament, the people paid to do this could teach a compromise position that works.

I guess it depends on what you mean by ‘better’. I’m not saying you have done this in your post, but I have seen again and again, white men assuming they are better, promoting themselves as better, talking as if there is certainty when there isn’t and actually being a bit shit. Whilst women humbly and quietly get on with the job, hold onto complexity and a ‘safe uncertain’ position (in my profession there is no clear right and wrong so similar to law in that sense) and doing a damn good job but not crowing about it - more likely picking holes on their own work and then working hard to do even better next time. I’ve seen this loads of times in my 30 year career.

Men are often much better at self promotion rather than being better at the job per se IME.

Sweden99 · 24/06/2024 22:32

@Noddedoffagain I wonder sometimes if traditional environments choose macho, self-promoting men over hard working and diligent women. Brining in monitoring starts to mean that the promotion goes to macho, self-promoting women over hard working and diligent women

MsJinks · 25/06/2024 12:04

Their immigration solutions are unworkable- but very focussed on the excessive restriction of visas for legal migrants, and the turning back of what the rest of the world would call asylum seekers. I’m not convinced U.K. workers will fill the gaps of working visas, or that universities will survive without international students. I’m not convinced the plan for small boats would work either, as France won’t ’take them back’ and alternate solutions are surely too horrific for the majority of the public to accept (I hope!). It does strike me that there are no plans for the actual illegal migrants such as those who don’t (or didn’t ) go home after a visa expired- more I imagine than enter on boats - of course we prefer to hate on the folk on the boats, as it’s an easy and visual dog whistle for some. Folk - again - are voting for a ‘vibe’ a vision of a happy 50s U.K. (that never was anyway) - would there be uproar if this ‘vibe’ didn’t happen? I expect it would be someone else’s fault though!
I am equally concerned about the NHS privatisation as it must be obvious that Farage would ultimately sell out to US insurance companies- he talks of EU models but they don’t run for profit (and don’t help his US mates either). We heard of Norway models pre referendum but that wasn’t going to happen and didn’t.
There are also other policies and members of the party (aka Ltd company) that are concerning.

I am interested in why people would vote for this? Happy to struggle with impact of immediate net zero migration, and probably particularly the healthcare model as that would impact nearly all the population adversely for sure? And are people voting as a protest and not expecting them to get in? If so what do you want out of the protest? Or are you Voting hoping they’ll become a bigger party? Voting hoping they’ll get in? Voting and looking forward to such policies being implemented? Expecting a better life for most of U.K. if such policies were put in place?

Obviously, Reform won’t be in Government this time, and for me I don’t want any of them in, continuing to stir up things, attract bigger names, become ‘mainstream’ etc because of the absolute horror show that would be unleashed in the U.K. if they got in or held too much sway in future parliaments in my opinion. But interested to discuss how and why Reform and their policies are expected to improve U.K. happiness and wellbeing.

Mycatsmudge · 27/06/2024 08:27
Chocoloca · 27/06/2024 12:36

LifeGivesYouOranges · 21/06/2024 17:51

@Anonym00se to add, you say why would I vote for someone with horrible views - Keir Starmer has the most awful view of all - that men can be women. It makes an absolute mockery of women and girls rights. He must really hate us. I cannot vote for this utter denial of basic truth.

Starmer does not hate women and girls. You have a comprehension problem there. He is a family man respecting his wife and mother, thoughtful about his kids including daughter unlike Bojo or Farage, who were using women.

justasking111 · 27/06/2024 12:53

Chocoloca · 27/06/2024 12:36

Starmer does not hate women and girls. You have a comprehension problem there. He is a family man respecting his wife and mother, thoughtful about his kids including daughter unlike Bojo or Farage, who were using women.

So he looks after his family , medal time I think not.

Noddedoffagain · 27/06/2024 13:31

Chocoloca · 27/06/2024 12:36

Starmer does not hate women and girls. You have a comprehension problem there. He is a family man respecting his wife and mother, thoughtful about his kids including daughter unlike Bojo or Farage, who were using women.

He actually was very involved with thinking about violence towards women.

Noddedoffagain · 27/06/2024 13:32

justasking111 · 27/06/2024 12:53

So he looks after his family , medal time I think not.

Hes been a big advocate for law change around violence towards women/domestic violence. He’s a better bet than Farage if it’s women’s rights you prioritise.

Mycatsmudge · 28/06/2024 06:26

Chocoloca · 27/06/2024 12:36

Starmer does not hate women and girls. You have a comprehension problem there. He is a family man respecting his wife and mother, thoughtful about his kids including daughter unlike Bojo or Farage, who were using women.

I wonder what Mrs Starmer who is Jewish and who is bringing up their children in the faith thought when her husband stood by the anti-semite Jeremy Corbyn and said he would make a great prime minister and watch as Jewish MPs such as Luciana Berger were abused and hounded out of the party.

I also wonder whether Victoria Starmer is ok with Keir being unable to define what is a woman and has produced a manifesto which erodes women’s rights and puts their safety at risk

Chocoloca · 28/06/2024 12:55

Meadowtrees · 22/06/2024 08:27

He has also studied and learnt from the people he admires - trump and putin. Not my idea of role models!!

But she didn't say he is a good role model. Your post is arrogant because it is all about your own feelings about Farage but you have dismissed what the poster said which was - why some voters get lured by politicians like Farage, and that it's important to listen to their concerns as well.

Chocoloca · 28/06/2024 12:56

Mycatsmudge · 28/06/2024 06:26

I wonder what Mrs Starmer who is Jewish and who is bringing up their children in the faith thought when her husband stood by the anti-semite Jeremy Corbyn and said he would make a great prime minister and watch as Jewish MPs such as Luciana Berger were abused and hounded out of the party.

I also wonder whether Victoria Starmer is ok with Keir being unable to define what is a woman and has produced a manifesto which erodes women’s rights and puts their safety at risk

Sunak and Farage are not better. I also wonder what their partners think of their corrupt and self serving ways. Their partners actually benefited from that.

Chocoloca · 28/06/2024 12:59

justasking111 · 27/06/2024 12:53

So he looks after his family , medal time I think not.

No one is saying he deserves a medal for that. I responded to a poster justifying reasons to vote for reform, saying Starmer hates women and girls.

TomPinch · 28/06/2024 19:10

Reform are predicted to win two seats only. Both have peculiarities. First, Clacton, where Farage is standing and which previously was held by Carswell who prior to that election defected from the Tories to Reform's previous incarnation UKIP. The other is Ashfield, the current incumbent defected from the Tories to Reform.

The better question is what happens next.

Reform could become the main challenger in a host of deindustrialised seats that Labour will win this time, ie, pick up the votes of people who are socially conservative but economically left-wing. Lots of those seats would have been Tory targets in previous elections, ie, ones they would need to win to govern.

If a Tory right-winger replaces Sunak they could court that vote (and Reform could even infiltrate the Tories) meaning making that party more socially conservative and economically centrist. But I agree with a pp who said if the Tories did that they'd shed votes.

The alternative is that the Tories move to the centre socially and economically, to try and win back Lab and LD votes. They would win this way but would leave a vacuum on the social and economic right for Reform to fill. That could be a trap for Reform.

verdantverdure · 29/06/2024 16:16

I see a lot of what they used to call "astroturfing" fake social media posts about Reform but I don't think there's anywhere gullible enough to actually elect them.

You can see who the MRP polls predict to win in your constituency here:

inglesp.github.io/apogee/

verdantverdure · 29/06/2024 16:18

yellowspanner · 24/06/2024 21:46

I will be voting Reform as will members of my family

To help vote out a Tory?

verdantverdure · 29/06/2024 18:22

Moier · 20/06/2024 18:55

Any of you voting Reform?
My area was always labour..( I've never voted labour).. but according to what I'm reading.. it's surprisingly gone the other way.
Will have to wait and see.
Did him being in I'm a Celebrity make him more popular..or is the extreme right the way to go?

Reform are not ahead anywhere that I've seen. They've just got a lot of social media astroturfers. .

You can look up the aggregated MRP predictions for your constituency here:

inglesp.github.io/apogee/

justasking111 · 29/06/2024 18:43

verdantverdure · 29/06/2024 18:22

Reform are not ahead anywhere that I've seen. They've just got a lot of social media astroturfers. .

You can look up the aggregated MRP predictions for your constituency here:

inglesp.github.io/apogee/

Jakers this is interesting. We're predicted labour and the adjoining constituency.

verdantverdure · 29/06/2024 19:57

justasking111 · 29/06/2024 18:43

Jakers this is interesting. We're predicted labour and the adjoining constituency.

I’ve no idea how much credence to give the polls. Where they agree they might just all be labouring under the same wrong assumptions.

All we can do is cast our one vote in our one constituency and hope we wake up in a better situation on Friday.

Swipe left for the next trending thread