I really appreciate this, and I think you’re right to call out superiority wherever it appears. Christians absolutely can come across as condescending, often without realizing it, and the “sky fairy” brand of atheism does the same from the other direction. Both are unhelpful.
Where I’d gently push back is on the idea that respecting all ways of living a good life is itself a neutral or framework-free position. That view still requires certain assumptions: that no objective moral truth exists, that sincerity or personal authenticity is what matters most, and that tolerance is the highest virtue. Those are real commitments, not just an absence of belief.
Christians believe there is one correct way to be reconciled to God, because we believe God has revealed Himself definitively in Jesus. That’s not superiority, it’s conviction. But conviction doesn’t require condescension. I can believe Jesus is the only way to salvation while also treating people with dignity, listening well, and respecting their freedom to disagree.
The real question isn’t whether we have convictions about ultimate truth. Everyone does, including atheists. It feels like one question for this thread is whether we hold those convictions with humility, kindness, and respect for others. On that, I think many on different sides would hopefully agree. It seems as though many are asking questions without a genuine curiosity to understand others.