I read the therapist / client conversation. And I can see how it appears neutral. However, to a highly suggestible person or someone, who deals in absolutes this could imo trigger a person to cut contact. Wouldn’t it be better to steer the client to more grey thinking rather than absolutes?
EG in response to the client saying they want to cut contact. Respond if the client wants, they can work this out together so that she makes the decision, that is right for her. And it’s ok for a lot of this work to be about discussing her mother. Because what is going on in the relationship is important to her. Her childhood is important to her. Something like this.
Telling her things like she’s in charge without elaborating can also potentially be problematic. Yes, she’s in charge of herself. And of her life and her decisions. It could be taken she’s in charge of herself and her mother now. but I don’t like in charge btw. I prefer things like she gets to decide what happens to her and her life. And that they can talk about that and see how the client would like that to look.
I’m thinking the more neutral option. Soft. Not knee jerk in any way. And as someone myself, who’s had a lot of therapy, the comment about cutting contact could just be frustration, throw away and the therapist has picked it up and run with it as a possible outcome. (I don’t have a child, who’s cut contact btw.)
The therapist on hearing ‘I’d just rather cut contact’ should also be hearing that person’s fears. Cutting contact doesn’t necessarily change those fears. And they should know their client very very well, have explored a lot of possibilities before having this type of conversation. And from the way this has been written, that doesn’t seem to be the case.
At times I felt like cutting contact. I didn’t. I was encouraged by my therapist after years of working on myself to put a very firm boundary in. This was led by me and brought on my not wanting to resume contact until my parent apologised for saying something to me, which triggered me to put the phone down. It was one of many conversations, where I’d put the phone down but this was the one that broke the camel’s back. And once that happened, the therapist explained to me how to make a change.
Not to look at the big picture but to use this one specific thing to seek change. And it changed everything. That actually taught both me and my parent far more than going NC. And If I’d done that it would have been a short cut. But it wouldn’t have helped me. It wouldn’t have made me the person I am today. Because we put all the work in before we got to that point.
And I’m still now in contact with my parent. And although I’ve had to reinforce boundaries at times, I have never since felt the need to put the phone down or to temporarily cut contact again. That’s effective therapy in action.
NB I appreciate the outcome will be different for different people. However, the process should never be forced or expedited as the conclusion may be wrong for the client. But I get that takes resources that many people don’t have. And clients want results…