My feed
Premium

Please
or
to access all these features

Wondering how to stop worrying about your grown child? Speak to others in our Parents of Adult Children forum.

Parents of adult children

Daughter living in USA.

88 replies

LindyLou2020 · 08/11/2021 13:35

I wanted to NC for this but don't know how to. And I fear I'm not going to like some of the answers.....but I'm allowing myself to become quite depressed about this and need your help This may well be a long post, sorry! Please don't read if it will bore you. I am in the UK.
My daughter, now aged 30, has lived in the USA since 2012. She had previously spent 3 summers working in summer camps there whilst at uni here. She met and fell in love with a fellow camp worker, an American, and went to his university in mid-west USA to further her studies after graduating here - in 2012.
We got used to making trips there, interspersed with her trips home. We've obviously got to know (I'll call him Fred), very well, and get on with his parents.
They got married in the USA in 2019. I was privately hurt, but I knew it made sense for them as that's where their home is. But the guests consisted mainly of Fred's parents' family and friends, and friends of the couple, as only a few of our family and friends were able/willing to make the trip from the UK.
That hurt too, but I wasn't expecting anyone from here to attend at all, so I was thrilled when they could. And right from when the wedding date was announced, I was determined not to be a Mumzilla, so interfered with nothing, and helped with what my daughter wanted me to.
My daughter landed her first permanent job in academia this summer, after a couple of time-limited research posts. (I don't want to be too specific in case it's "outing"). She is very career-focussed and has worked extremely hard.
She chose it because it is at a good university, and it is on the east coast, meaning less of a time distance, and a direct flight. She and Fred moved there this summer
She knows I miss her terribly and wish we were in the same place, but also knows that I'm proud of her, and think it's so important to do work that you love, if you can.
I coped with her being there reasonably well, but with many wobbles, until this summer. The job itself has lent an air of permanence to everything, whereas before I think I was in denial and hoped she may come back.
What has really hit me so hard 'though, is that they are now living around a one and a half hour drive away from Fred's parents. I just can't get past this, and am ashamed to be consumed with jealousy.
They are good people, very family-orientated, but quite overpowering.
Fred's mum has already referred to my daughter as her daughter, and told her she loves her, on Facebook. But, they are quite openly and verbally affectionate in general, and tell DH and I they love us too!
So I try to accept that's how they are.
Fred has quite a large extended family, whereas my only family are my DH, DS, and DD. DH has siblings but they are not close at all and meet up rarely.
Already Fred's parents have seen Fred and my daughter around half a dozen times since the move. They mind the dog when the couple are away. Now that UK-USA travel is open again, we'll be able to visit. DD and Fred came here for 3 weeks in the summer, and will be here for Christmas.
My DD and I had, and have, a close, loving, relationship. We did so much together when she was a child/teen. She can tell me anything, and I can tell her how I feel, whilst assuring her it's for me to own and deal with, not her. She is aware of her in-laws' propensity to possessiveness and assures me they won't replace me and DH!
Because my own family of origin was lonely and unhappy, I invested heavily in my own children to ensure their childhood was different. I was very aware of being in danger of wanting them to meet my emotional needs, and be my antidote to loneliness, so I've deliberately encouraged them to be their own people and be adventurous.
I've read so much stuff regarding the "empty nest syndrome", and regarding people who are in similar situations, in places like Gransnet and the like, to try to help myself.
I know all the theory. We give them wings to fly. Let them go. They have their own lives, etc, etc.
But theory does not ease my feelings of bereavement.
I am trying to turn a skill into a career. I have started a new exercise regime. I keep in touch with friends. I'm learning a new sport. We Facetime, WhatsApp, etc. I'm trying so hard to forge my own life. I've been having counselling since August because I couldn't sort this out myself. I don't have any other family. I don't want to be this jealous person who could easily become bitter.
I swing between catastrophising - "DD will become closer to Fred's family to us and I'll lose her", and fantasising - "We'll go and live there and be together all the time". Please don't accuse me of being childish - I already know that I am and need to grow up.
I'm embarrassed to think I've opened myself up far too much by posting all this. But I would just love some thoughts as to what else I can do to make things better for myself.
DH and I have talked about spending more time there, maybe even moving there eventually. But not to cling to her, but to have our own life and interests too.
We have a DS aged 33 who has come back to live with us due to a health issue, so we are unable to make any moves now anyway.
I'd be grateful not to be told to "get a grip" or similar. That's what I've been trying to do.
I just feel so lost and don't know which way to turn.
I need to thank you in advance for getting to the end Flowers

OP posts:
Report
LindyLou2020 · 08/11/2021 14:41

Bump

OP posts:
Report
SweeneyToddler · 08/11/2021 14:48

I’m not going to tell you to get a grip because I know you’re upset but, what struck me as I was reading was a thought of “would she prefer the opposite?” ie, your daughter in an unhappy marriage, with ILs she disliked, and bo support?

It sounds like she’s very happy and enjoying life. Be happy for her.

Report
Bagelsandbrie · 08/11/2021 14:48

I would feel exactly the same way as you (in fact I’m struggling with my dd aged 18 going off to university 3 hours away - she started in September and I’m feeling bereft, which I know is ridiculous and I certainly haven’t voiced that to her)! But the thought of being in your situation makes me feel awful, so I can certainly empathise. Personally I would make long term plans to move there, with Ds if his health recovers, and that’s the only way I could cope with it. I don’t believe we have to be completely okay with our adult dc living on the other side of the worlds- no one has children for them to move abroad and hardly see them!

Report
Chargreen · 08/11/2021 14:53

Hi,

I’m your DD in this scenario and all I can say is that I’m closer to my UK-based parents than ever. The last couple of years have of course been a struggle but that aside, we have spent many happy times together on both sides of the Atlantic since I immigrated to the US. We appreciate the time we spend together very much these days and we’re only a relatively short flight away from each other.

Start making plans for a trip where you can all be together, things are always easier when you’ve got something booked in. Do you have a family Whatsapp group? Being in contact daily helps, even if it’s just a “Good morning” to check-in. Family groups are fun. Regular, weekly Zoom calls have been good for us too.

I also think you need to stop worrying about your in-laws “taking over”. You are her mum and dad, no one will ever come close. Be happy she has people who love her and looking out for her but remember you two will always be number one.

Report
LindyLou2020 · 08/11/2021 16:23

@SweeneyToddler - You are right, of course I would absolutely hate her to be unhappy in the scenario that you describe. That's why I own up to not wanting to feel the way I do.
@Bagelsandbrie and @Chargreen - thanks to you both for your kind support,

I'm going to give my post another BUMP as I just want to get as much wisdom from MN as possible.

OP posts:
Report
LindyLou2020 · 08/11/2021 16:24

Bump

OP posts:
Report
verymiddleaged · 08/11/2021 16:31

We live on another continent to our parents.
Excepting Covid times I don't think it makes a huge difference unless the family were living in your immediate vicinity before.
By investing in travel we saw mil as much as we used to when we lived a few hundred miles away.
I have never seen much of parents since I left home.

If you want to be closer could you consider buying a vacation apartment close to your dd?

Without living close by you aren't going to have the relationship moving forward that the nearby in-laws have although this won't mean your dd loves you less.

I agree that a family WhatsApp is a good way for everyone to keep in touch and post little things. Our family is very spread out and it is something we all use.

Report
Classicblunder · 08/11/2021 16:36

We are a geographically spread out family on both sides and it is hard. It sounds like your DD is really close to you and committed to spending time with you which is great - my DH sees his parents every 2-3 years in comparison.

Are you close to your DS? Would you really want to move away from him?

People I know in similar situations move towards long - like 3 months - visits (usually renting a place) to be able to spend more day to day time together

Report
TaraR2020 · 08/11/2021 16:37

Oh op I don't think you're bring childish at all! You sound like a wonderful mum and I think you're feelings are completely natural.

What's key here is that you're not letting them rule your behaviour.

I find think it would any harm to seriously consider moving there when you're able to; but also consider what this will mean for you and your son. Are you going to start feeling the same way about him?

I wonder how much worse it's been for you with the travel restrictions of the last couple of years and maybe you just need a good trip - when did you last visit her?

I'd also try and be specific about the things you feel like you're missing out on with her and whether you can find a way round them with how you both communicate now (video calls etc).

Or are you feeling like you can't be a mum to her in the active sense? How might you be able to change this and feel more involved? Flowers

Report
TaraR2020 · 08/11/2021 16:38
  • I wouldn't think it would do any harm to consider moving

    ..was what that was supposed to say!
Report
Nesbo · 08/11/2021 16:44

There seems to be a huge emotional investment in the ins and outs of DDs life whereas DS almost seems like an afterthought.

It sounds as if, we’re it not for DS’s illness you’d be leaving him behind to be closer to DD - is that right? If so it feels a little…unbalanced.

Report
mathanxiety · 08/11/2021 17:07

Speaking as someone who moved from Ireland to the US:

  • Don't move there yourself.

  • Make a full life for yourself and your DH in the UK - bloom where you are planted. This will help with your depressed feelings.

  • Plan on spending a solid three months per year in the US every year if you can afford it, or if your DD can put you up. Choose a season you love, and go every year. If you do this, don't wait for your DD and son in law to chaperone you around. Be independent.

  • A note on American use of language here:
    Your daughter's mother in law is not trying to supplant you or take her over for herself as her daughter.
    Americans, as you have noticed, tend to be more demonstrative than your family is, and I would venture to day, more demonstrative in general than English people tend to be. They use words like 'love' more than you are used to. It doesn't mean your daughter will jump ship, so to speak. It doesn't mean your opposite number is trying to take over. She is trying to be welcoming, trying to tell your DD that she has her back. There is nothing more implied there.

    Don't be possessive. Don't be jealous. You clearly equipped your DD with all the attributes and skills necessary to create a very nice life for herself, to form solid connections, and build relationships. Pat yourself on the back for that.

  • Use technology to stay connected.

  • Remind yourself that covid has created an unusual and unnatural hiatus in many relationships, and may have caused you to catastrophise. Connection is going to resume. Life will feel more normal. It will get its rhythm back.

  • If your spell of the blues persists more than a few weeks, please see your GP about depression
Report
hennybeans · 08/11/2021 17:11

I am from the US west coast and live in the UK. My mum visits 3 weeks every year and when she's here, her time is 24/7 devoted to my DC. She even shares a room with DD when she visits. Conversely, my MIL lives about 1hr15 away and we see her maybe once a month, usually with other cousins/ family, for just an hour or two.

My DC actually spend more days and more quality time with my DM than DMIL.

Even if I lived near to my DM, I would still be getting on with my own life, as would she. My DC are dual citizens and could easily move to the US when older. That would make sad I think, but also for them to have an opportunity that others don't.

What also jumped out at me about your post is that you actually have your ds living with you but that doesn't seem to come into play at all. Wouldn't he be alone and sad if you moved and all his family lived in the States? Your seem to be very focused just on your DD.

Report
TaraR2020 · 08/11/2021 17:20

What also jumped out at me about your post is that you actually have your ds living with you but that doesn't seem to come into play at all. Wouldn't he be alone and sad if you moved and all his family lived in the States? Your seem to be very focused just on your DD.

I thought this too. I wonder if the op feels she has missed put on key bonding events/times with her dd which is contributing.

Report
Porseb · 08/11/2021 17:52

I live 8000 miles away from my mother and family.

My ex-MIL lives 20 minutes away.

My DC FaceTime and speak to my mum more often than my MIL (only because their dad doesn't make the effort to encourage the relationship with his side of the family).

We FaceTime my family weekly and my mother every other day.

I haven't lived with my mum since I moved for boarding school at 17 and my DD is now at boarding school.

It's tough but I don't love my mother any less, I probably feel more guilt that I don't live closer.

I wouldn't like my DD to feel guilty for pursuing her own dreams even if that meant moving away from the country I live in.

Report
LindyLou2020 · 08/11/2021 18:13

@verymiddleaged @Classicblunder @TaraR2020 @Nesbo @mathanxiety..........
Thank you so much for your replies. You've given me different perspectives which was what I was hoping for.
Yes, my DS is a big consideration in all of this - sorry if it seemed otherwise. He has a GF, and he is trying to learn to live with his health issue, get back into work, and buy a house. So things may be very different for him next year, and he could well be living away from here as his GF does not want to leave London. So we could be waiting to make sure he is ok, then he pisses off anyway!
I've always likes the idea of having our own holiday home in the USA - but not affordable atm. And spending longer stretches there, like 3 months or so, also appeals.
I hear you, @mathanxiety, about American demonstrativeness. But the MIL also once said that when the couple have kids, PILs will move in, or nearby, and "do the childcare". That was so insensitive and bloody well hurt, but my daughter has no intention of allowing that. And I need to start to let all that stuff wash over me and be more thick-skinned.
I do not WANT to be possessive or jealous. This was a big reason as to why I asked for help on here.
So, thanks again guys - you've given me much food for thought Flowers

OP posts:
Report
Classicblunder · 08/11/2021 18:19

So we could be waiting to make sure he is ok, then he pisses off anyway!

But it's interesting that it doesn't sound like you would consider moving within the UK, likely not that far, to live near him but are considering a transatlantic move to be with your DD. Would it bother you if his GF's parents did childcare for his kids?

Report
LindyLou2020 · 08/11/2021 18:25

@Porseb

I live 8000 miles away from my mother and family.

My ex-MIL lives 20 minutes away.

My DC FaceTime and speak to my mum more often than my MIL (only because their dad doesn't make the effort to encourage the relationship with his side of the family).

We FaceTime my family weekly and my mother every other day.

I haven't lived with my mum since I moved for boarding school at 17 and my DD is now at boarding school.

It's tough but I don't love my mother any less, I probably feel more guilt that I don't live closer.

I wouldn't like my DD to feel guilty for pursuing her own dreams even if that meant moving away from the country I live in.

@Porseb,
You are right - I would hate my DD to feel guilty, 'though I know she does sometimes. This is where I agree with all the theory but the reality hurts.
And @TaraR2020, yes we do miss out on "bonding" events like birthdays, whereas PILs don't. And when we ARE together, my DD wants to make up for things by packing in fun stuff, bless her, whereas sometimes I just want to do boring stuff like painting each others' toenails!
But again, I appreciate all your replies and I know I have a lot to "suck up" and learn to accept and adapt to.
OP posts:
Report
HollowTalk · 08/11/2021 18:28

Maybe she is closer to her daughter, though. I can completely understand how much you miss her, OP. I would, too.

I think her MIL is very insensitive.

My son is married to a lovely woman who's from another country, several thousand miles away. She's got a lovely family. My son and DIL live 40 miles from me. It struck me the other day that her mum and I will never be totally happy at the same time. She misses her now. I missed my son when he lived there for several months. I would never ever call her my daughter - I would go crazy if someone did that to me!

Report
HollowTalk · 08/11/2021 18:29

Is your daughter able to come home every year?

Report
LindyLou2020 · 08/11/2021 18:31

@Classicblunder

So we could be waiting to make sure he is ok, then he pisses off anyway!

But it's interesting that it doesn't sound like you would consider moving within the UK, likely not that far, to live near him but are considering a transatlantic move to be with your DD. Would it bother you if his GF's parents did childcare for his kids?

Very good point @Classicblunder!
The scenario you describe regarding GF's parents is actually what GF would want.
So anything can happen, and I also try to stop futurising for this very reason. It's pointless isn't it?
OP posts:
Report
Cantthinkofaname21 · 08/11/2021 18:35

Be proud and happy for your daughter! She’s been accepted and supported by her husband family. This does not mean you are replaced by them - it means she is loved.

Not sure moving or buying a place over there would be a good idea? Longer stretches maybe a good idea? But say 6 weeks maximum and plan things independently from them (explore the area yourselves with your husband, extend the invite but with work etc it means they will feel less guilty trying to entertain you ) you run the risk of suffocating them the other way!

My neighbours family come from America - when they come over it was sweet to see her Dad doing things for her (painting fence, cutting the grass) it made him feel closer to them as he would help them do these things if they lived in America! But the one thing I noticed they gave them space so would disappear for a few days to London or they even took the grandkids to centre Parcs. Parents carried on working but had a proper break!

Report

Don’t want to miss threads like this?

Weekly

Sign up to our weekly round up and get all the best threads sent straight to your inbox!

Log in to update your newsletter preferences.

You've subscribed!

Classicblunder · 08/11/2021 18:35

I mention this stuff because my DH was in a similar situation with his parents who have always made it totally clear that they love his sister more than DH or his brothers. When they lived in the UK, they were constantly talking about his sister in the US. They moved back without even really talking to him about it - literally offered on a house near his sister without mentioning it. It has been very hurtful for him that the favouritism has been so obvious.

Report
LindyLou2020 · 08/11/2021 18:37

@HollowTalk

Is your daughter able to come home every year?

Yes, she can @HollowTalk, except when we had restrictions banning travel between both countries. And we can go there as from today!
And yes, we were and are very close, and I miss her terribly because I LIKE her as well as LOVE her!
OP posts:
Report
Motnight · 08/11/2021 18:39

You sound like a great mother to your dd, Op. It is ok to miss her. Xx

Report
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.