Are your children’s vaccines up to date?

Set a reminder

Please or to access all these features

Parenting

For free parenting resources please check out the Early Years Alliance's Family Corner.

No-presents party for 8 year-old

84 replies

HotCrossBunplease · 19/08/2024 12:23

We’re just about to host DS’s 8th birthday. It’s an activity with about 12 kids. All costs covered by us but it is a 30 mins drive from where most of us live so a bit of effort needed by parents of guests.

We’ll be giving out party bags.

I would like to say “no gifts” as in previous years I’ve seen people spend up to £20 on things like Lego but DS is getting more and more picky about what he likes so presents do often go unplayed with, plus he has loads of stuff. He’s mostly into computer games now and that’s not something I would expect people to buy as party presents. He goes to private school and the parents are quite well off so it’s not a cost thing, but know myself what a stress it is trying to choose a present.

(All the kids are very good at doing written thank-you cards after the event, and DS has done his meticulously every previous year).

Some parents have opted for a book swap where everyone brings a wrapped book (new or used) and each child picks one in a lucky dip to take home. I love that idea.

The problem is that DS is a spoiled little prince and while he acknowledges that he hasn’t played with some past presents, he still really loves the idea of a pile of wrapped gifts and sees them at other kids’ parties.

I thought that maybe I could just ask for books only as presents and that way DS gets a nice selection of books suggested by his classmates, but not ridiculous money spent if they don’t appeal to him. DH thinks that asking for books is very “worthy” and prescriptive and could annoy people.
Asking for cash or voucher contributions eg to a new game he might want to buy just seems a bit transactional.

Any tips on what works best in these situations? Parents would welcome “no gifts”, surely, but is it possible that a child attending might feel put out if they weren’t getting the chance to give a gift? (DS does have a couple of friends where he’s said “oh, we should buy X this for his birthday, he’d love it).

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
countrysidelife2024 · 23/08/2024 18:19

ive gotten a few no present invitations. i have never listened because i just cannot turn up to a party empty handed, i was brought up to never go to someones house or event empty handed unless its just a coffee meetup

HotCrossBunplease · 23/08/2024 18:20

WoolyMammoth55 · 23/08/2024 18:16

OP, this was the wording we used in the invite for my 7yo's birthday:

"No need to bring a gift… If you have something in mind for him then we would be very glad, but he’d also be thrilled with a £ or two to put in his money box towards a(nother!) Jurassic World dinosaur toy…"

We had to say something because he was inviting the whole class and we just don't have room for 30 gifts, on top of what he got from us and the grandparents!

Plus some kids in his class come from really disadvantaged backgrounds so I wanted to give cover for those who were struggling.

In the end it worked out great - he got very thoughtful gifts from about 10 close friends to open when we got home, and then £150 in cash which got him all his dream list of dinosaurs.

I don't think you have to just go with the status quo if you'd rather not.

Thanks. All the other parents now think you are a twat though, apparently. 😉

OP posts:
Sunshineclouds11 · 23/08/2024 18:23

I'd also think poor kid and put money in a card.

Let him get the gifts then just donate after use

Interested in this thread?

Then you might like threads about these subjects:

longdistanceclaraclara · 23/08/2024 18:24

Mean to the kid. Regift/ charity for what he doesn't want.

WoolyMammoth55 · 23/08/2024 18:24

HotCrossBunplease · 23/08/2024 18:20

Thanks. All the other parents now think you are a twat though, apparently. 😉

Yes but I don't care and my kid is happy! Best of luck 😉

Starlightstarbright3 · 23/08/2024 18:33

Ds Isn’t keen - charity bucket as well seems crap .. I have always seen birthdays as the one thing that is about them .

so someone else gets to come to the child’s party , share their birthday cake and take a party bag home .. so yes if your Ds wants presents then let them get gifts .. some may well not hit the mark but others will - I think their is learning in that too ..

My D’s is a teenager now - however what I would say is he got some gifts I would never have bought him that he loved .. Anyway of prolonging the play is also extremely positive

tiggergoesbounce · 23/08/2024 18:38

A lot of people think it's the parents taking something special away from their child unnecessarily to look "virtuous" , and maybe it would be better for the parents not to over shower their "little princes'" with gifts throughout the year, if it means they have to miss out on presents on their birthday. At 8, presents are fun and exciting - you can teach a child to be grateful and thoughtful of others ,as well as allowing them presents.

At this age, I would still arrive with a present my child had picked out for his friend and bypass the no presents rule. I have to agree with the PP, we would look negatively at those parenting choices.

HotCrossBunplease · 23/08/2024 18:47

This is all good. Last year we did a joint party with another child so all the parents brought 2 gifts and I was quite shocked at how much some had clearly spent. I’ve spent a year thinking they must hate us for being greedy (two gifts in exchange for only one party, though we did have quite a lot of stuff laid on). Now I hear that it’s all about the kids and nobody sees it as a transaction at all so that is great.

OP posts:
Magnolia1234 · 23/08/2024 18:56

Can he donate the ones he hasn’t played with.

at eight ripping the paper off presents is still part of the birthday fun.

2boyzNosleep · 23/08/2024 18:56

No 8yr old has a party not expecting presents. Yes he may be 'picky' and 'spoilt'. However, no 8yr old will be happy about no presents or only getting books

If you don't want any presents then it's unwise hosting a party.

Tbh, if some families are struggling, they are likely to just give a card. Or a small amount of money/cheap present.

If anyone asks what your son wants just say he's got most things, tell them a couple of his interests/hobbies, then mention money or vouchers.

Sonia1111 · 23/08/2024 19:34

In my experience, and I have 2 children older than yours, there is no way you can mention any condition for presents and not offend someone. It is best to not say a word beforehand, not expect anything, do a detailed thank you, and find a way to get rid of anything that you don't want. Regift, donate, etc. The most inoffensive way is to let your children use the item, even if they already have one or it isn't age appropriate, then remove it however you prefer.

Craftycariad · 23/08/2024 19:37

HotCrossBunplease · 23/08/2024 17:38

It was lighthearted about being a spoiled little prince!. I just meant he is lucky to have lots of nice material things.

Thanks for the perspectives. I’m interested that someone would still feel they had to bring a gift to a “no gifts” party, seems odd they’d see it as some sort of double bluff but if there is a chance it will make some people feel confused I’ll just let everyone make the usual assumption that presents are expected.

I guess there was precedent for no gifts at other parties where they’ve done the book swap thing, but it’s definitely not the norm amongst his peer group. I take on board that it would seem mean to the child.

Edited

We went to a no gift party invite said we want you presence not your presents, the child was 4. Some parents bought gifts which were them taken straight from the child and she took them to the local charity shop the next day. At the next years party. No one bought presents for the child. They always bought lovely presents when they went to other children's parties. They just didn't want the children to feel spoiled and others to feel obliged to buy gifts hey may not be able to afford

BePerkyMauveBee · 23/08/2024 19:40

Oh my gosh, when my girls were younger, they always had a joint party-usually around 50 kids, birthdays weeks apart and party beginning of December. I always go overboard for birthdays and Christmas so for their joint parties I would ask for a toy to be donated to the local radio stations Christmas toy drive. Their closest friends would generally bring a present (didn’t ask them to or expect) everyone else would bring whatever they wanted. One of the school mums worked for the radio station and asked if the girls wanted to go on and talk about it which they did and loved for a few years. They both liked the idea of giving to children who weren’t as lucky as they were! Now I’m wondering if everyone thought I was a twat 🤣🤣

SunshineStreamingThrough · 23/08/2024 19:43

Personally when my DD has been invited to parties before and parents have said gifts aren’t necessary it’s been in more of a “you don’t have to if you don’t want to” sense. No one’s ever said explicitly that they don’t want gifts. Therefore everyone gets a gift because no one wants to be that one parent who doesn’t get one when everyone else has😂

HateThese4Leggedbeasts · 23/08/2024 19:44

Sorry I haven't read the thread. We do group presents, where by one parentbof the guests does the buying and everyone chips in 5 -8 pounds and the child gets a better present that they actually want. It works well. Could one of the parents of his better friends collect the money for that? It doesn't feel as transactional that way.
Plus if it takes off, it alleviates present stress for the whole year 🤞

DreamW3aver · 23/08/2024 19:47

IOnlyNeedTheSilence · 23/08/2024 17:52

I think people would still bring a gift because they'd think 'poor kid' which should tell you something.

It's not your birthday, I don't think you should decide on someone else's behalf that presents are a burden or a chore.

Really, if I saw no presents on an invite I wouldn't take a present, why would I assume to override the wishes of the parents, thats weird, no?

Surely you're implying that you either think you're special and don't need to respect their request or you know better then they do how to parent

It's literally the easiest thing to comply with

IOnlyNeedTheSilence · 23/08/2024 19:55

I don't care, an 8 year old's birthday is really all about getting excited about presents.

If the kid already has too many things that's another issue, but no reason to ruin his birthday.

Jellybeanbag · 23/08/2024 19:57

Please let your child have birthday gifts. 8 years old is young and the thrill of opening the gifts at that age is lovely.

I really dislike no gifts, please donate to charity, requests for cash etc. Let guests choose what they would like to gift with no clauses. People know if they can or cannot afford to attend parties and will decline and others know how much they can spend. Let them get on with the gift part and you get on with making sure your DC and guests have a brilliant time!

JustOneDD · 23/08/2024 19:58

Kindergifts is popular with my daughter’s class - no one wants loads of unused gifts and the charity element is nice! We do the invites through them too.

Ljcrow · 23/08/2024 19:58

I don't think you should dictate to other parents either way to be honest. I think I'd find it a bit grating. Just donate the presents on if they're not appreciated.

gamerchick · 23/08/2024 20:02

You can't do that to the bairn OP. How will he feel when you take a gift for birthday kids who's parties he attends?

Donate to kids who have nowt of he doesn't play with them

Whynottrythis · 23/08/2024 20:16

HotCrossBunplease · 23/08/2024 18:20

Thanks. All the other parents now think you are a twat though, apparently. 😉

As a guest I'd be happy with this though. No need to bring a gift if times are hard, and also recognises that some people will be inspired and know your child's taste well, but others won't and can give money.

Very similar really to a lot of weddings surely?

I'd never prevent my child being given birthday presents at their party. But equally I hate waste and was shocked at the massive pile at the last birthday party I went to (for a two year old!).

I would also tell my dc he had to decide on X nr of toys to sell/donate before the party though.

Alwaytired44 · 23/08/2024 20:27

You CANNOT let your child have a party and not receive presents! They’re far too young to adopt the sensible approach you’re trying to take.

Could you not allow your son to receive and open his presents then sell them on eBay to make some money for his computer games?!

BurbageBrook · 23/08/2024 20:36

He's not a spoiled prince for wanting presents at his birthday party. Kids see that as a sign their friends like them and it's important for children, rightly or wrongly. He's not spoiled, he's eight. Let him have his presents. Not only will it be mean not to let him, but also it'll be one of those stories he tells as an adult about the birthday party with no presents!

BurbageBrook · 23/08/2024 20:37

and yeah I would think you were a mean Mum and an idiot and I would still take a present.

Swipe left for the next trending thread