Please or to access all these features

One-child families

Got questions about only having one child? Find the answers here.

I don’t want another DC but feel guilt for DD’s future

52 replies

Oneandonex · 10/11/2026 12:13

Name changed.
DD is 6. She is a wonderful kid and I am loving this stage of parenting. She is very happy and settled and gets a lot of love and attention from me and DH and we have a good family life.
I have founs the baby stage incredibly difficult. Had a traumatic birth where we risked losing her and she was a high need baby and we didn’t sleep for years. I never want to relive those first 2-3 years again.
In addition to this, we have no family support, work full time, have an expensive mortgage for a small 2 bed home (which we are hoping to upgrade in a few years) and live near London where house and childcare prices are crazy. I am 39 and DH is 45. I have always felt we were one and done and DH is also aligned.

I could continue to list the reasons why I think an only child is the best choice for us as a family and I do truly feel this way. However, I sometimes feel a sense of guilt imagining the day we will no longer be around and feel as if we are letting DD down. I try to stay rational and think that it isn’t necessarily a given that a sibling will be a good source of support later in life as they might not get along or live in different countries etc. I also have plenty of friends who are only children and had/have a lovely life.
Does anyone else feel this guilt? Please refrain from replying things like “we have 2/3/4 kids and you should too, only children are sad” etc. I am interested to speak with fellow parents of only children that share the same thoughts or found a way to get over that.

OP posts:
Are your children’s vaccines up to date?
Archymum · 10/11/2026 12:19

We have an only child. Chose to be one-and-done for similar reasons to you, including no family support nearby, a very happy life with little chaos because of just one child, and I also found the baby stage tricky and didn't feel a strong drive for #2. It was challenging for me to get pregnant the first time and I didn't want to put myself through that emotional rollercoaster again. I know this was the right decision for all of us but of course, the niggling concern you express occasionally rears its ugly head for me as well. That said, neither my DH nor I are particularly close to our siblings, so we are both aware that a sibling guarantees nothing. I think as our child continues to grow up, I'm more and more at peace with our decision. Our DC is not spoiled, nor do they struggle socially. They have lots of friends and are an incredibly kind, generous friend. We have a truly wonderful life as a family unit of 3, and our child is happy and thriving. I think my own mental health is significantly better as well because we stopped at 1.

Oneandonex · 10/11/2026 12:22

Archymum · 10/11/2026 12:19

We have an only child. Chose to be one-and-done for similar reasons to you, including no family support nearby, a very happy life with little chaos because of just one child, and I also found the baby stage tricky and didn't feel a strong drive for #2. It was challenging for me to get pregnant the first time and I didn't want to put myself through that emotional rollercoaster again. I know this was the right decision for all of us but of course, the niggling concern you express occasionally rears its ugly head for me as well. That said, neither my DH nor I are particularly close to our siblings, so we are both aware that a sibling guarantees nothing. I think as our child continues to grow up, I'm more and more at peace with our decision. Our DC is not spoiled, nor do they struggle socially. They have lots of friends and are an incredibly kind, generous friend. We have a truly wonderful life as a family unit of 3, and our child is happy and thriving. I think my own mental health is significantly better as well because we stopped at 1.

Same, could quote almost all of your words! I don’t think DD is spoiled, infact her teacher recently congratulated us to say how sweet, thoughtful and loving she is with all of her friends at school. I think we are doing a great job (if I might say so) but I know we (or I at least) wouldn’t be as good a parent if I had more DC to look after

OP posts:
ILoveKits · 10/11/2026 12:25

@Oneandonex I am an only child (of two only children). I very much wanted a sibling and feared being wholly alone in later life. That was what kept me on to have a second child despite secondary infertility and a torried time getting there.

However, DH is one of three. His two siblings live thousands of miles away and inhabit different planets from the one DH and I live on. They rarely visit, they rarely call their frail and very elderly mother.

DH looks after his mum; I look after mine.

My view regarding siblings has changed. It's the luck of the draw, and DH might.as well not have any.

Do as feel best now. You cannot predict the future.

OnlyIsNotLonely · 10/11/2026 12:31

I am an only child. It is fine. My son is also an only child, and based on my own experience, I do not feel any guilt.

Peonies12 · 10/11/2026 12:32

i feel the same as you, although ours is only 2. We’re heavily swaying to not having another. I do worry about when she’s older. But she has cousins and we have a few friends who have only one child so I hope they might form a little network if they live near each other! I have two siblings but we don’t have any relationship really. I know my mental health would be awful if we had another. And I think that is more important than the future.

ratheralotofnonsense · 10/11/2026 12:37

I think we have more children for us, not our existing children. Only children get 100% of all our resources, time and money. They are very lucky .

RandomMess · 10/11/2026 12:38

I have a “large” family which I’m happy with but the high needs one nearly broke us!

It is absolutely great that you are happy as you are and even better your DH is in complete agreement. Enjoy having made the decision.

There is no correct number or children or spacing or all that bollocks!

Leopardspota · 10/11/2026 12:40

I have two children and feel guilty for many different reasons. Partly I worry about fairness between them, what if one has to look after the other etc. point is, mum guilt (parent guilt) happens whatever we do as we’re damned if we do and damned if we don’t in so many circumstances (sibs vs only, work vs sahm etc etc) don’t have another child because of the one you already have.

Voltaroldemort · 10/11/2026 12:41

Absolutely don't have a child out of a sense of guilt about your existing child being an 'only'. As others have said, you can't predict how things will turn out. The siblings could dislike one another, they could rub along ok but drift apart in adulthood, your existing child could resent the new baby so much that she will carry a burden of bitterness all her life. The new sibling could have an illness that overturns family life and makes you feel guilty that the elder child has inadequate attention from you.

There is no crystal ball. Every decision is a leap in the dark. But if you have a child that you don't in your heart really want, just to try and dodge the mum-guilt that follows every single aspect of our parenting, then that child may lead you into a whole new arena of mum-guilt.

Go with what you love, what brings you joy. That is at least as good a metric as any. It sounds like you love having an only child.

mumonthehill · 10/11/2026 12:44

I am an only child in my 50's and I can honestly say that seeing my friends with siblings dealing with their parents makes me glad I am an only. They fall out, want to care for their parents in different ways, get fed up with each other. I think this stress can often break sibling bonds. I have my own family so will not be alone when my parents die.

Pashazade · 10/11/2026 12:45

I'm an only with an only. Never regretted it, yes the very occasional pang, but never truly wanted another. He's awesome and has some really close friends. Honestly siblings really can be luck of the draw. Plus your DH is on the same page, enjoy the luxury of one! They get all your time and effort, you're not pulled in multiple directions and you get your life back quicker!!

shuffleofftobuffalo · 10/11/2026 12:47

Of my DD’s close friends (group of 8) only one has a sibling. They are all perfectly formed with normal social skills!

A sibling isn’t any guarantee they would get on.

ILoveCwtches · 10/11/2026 13:00

I thought I wanted two, then when I was being stitched up after having DD and they were discussing how much blood I was losing I made my peace that one was fine. I forgot that and went along with friends asking when we were having another and said when we have sold the flat and have a house (lived in a tiny 1 bed). Then, when webhad the house and DD was about 3, my husband was talking about his plans for his business and I realised he wasn't factoring in another baby and it releases something in me. I said I didn't want any more babies and he agreed. He would have had one of I'd wanted but our team of 3 was enough for both of us. It was such a relief.

I have occasionally felt proper guilt for having only 1 since then; during lockdown when DD was 6/7 and was alone and maybe once or twice on holiday. Other than that I know she benefits greatly from having parents who only have her to consider. It's natural to wonder what if, but it's all just that - wondering- there are no certainties.

She's 13 now and has plenty of friends and is kind and generous. I do not envy the parents of her football team mates when they are trying to sort logistics every weekend to get one child to one sport and another to something different. We both go to all of her matches (work allowing) and I wouldn't have it any other way.

DP had an older sister and isn't particularly close to her. I had a younger sister with severe physical and learning disabilities, who I helped my parents care for until her last breath, at the age of 39. When my DM decided to have a second baby so that I had someone to play with, she could never have foreseen how our lives would turn out.

So, in summary, you may occasionally feel a bit guilty but do what is best for you and your family. Having one is perfectly wonderful, and if that suits you and your family then that is all that matters. I bet the times when you feel guilty are outweighed by the times you are thankful for your lovely only.

TheOchreJoker · 10/11/2026 13:11

Nothing wrong with just having one.

I say this as an eldest child who begged for siblings, I got them and then realised I preferred being an only child 😂.
My siblings and I didn't actually get along with each other until after adulthood, I love them now but would have still been happy as a singleton and they say the same.

Also siblings do not and are not a preventative for future loneliness, they grow up and have their own lives.

The only thing your daughter will miss out on is sibling arguments, family drama and fighting over inheritance.

Don't feel guilty, you're doing fine.

theprincessthepea · 10/11/2026 13:20

Mine isn’t an only anymore, but she was for 13 years.

I think I felt the most guiltily in primary school because everyone had more than one child, and after a bad break up I chose to focus on myself and DD. I think for me, I just had to keep reminding myself about the life we had and how that was as important as my thoughts of having another to keep DD happy. In late primary school she would come home and tell me she wanted a sibling, and that made me feel bad, but also, she had an amazing set of friends, she was (and still is) so loved. She holds great conversations as she spends a lot of time time adults too. Had so many play dates. Has cousins so has extended family. And I could give her everything, she had her sports and activities and I knew not every family could always afford this.

When her sibling came along she was a teen and honestly, although she loves him she will say “I realised I had a good gig while I was an only because I actually like my life and all of the stuff I got to do”. Every now and then she will say “oh I forgot I have to share you now”. As they get older they find people. Not all siblings are close.

I say this to say that children are every resilient and they deal with whatever we give them. Siblings or no siblings, my DD was alright. By the time they are teens they really hone in on friendships anyway. And I feel like I am raising 2 sets of only’s (if that even makes sense)!

So if it does happen for you? Great. If not, your DD is lucky.

I also get so many compliments about my DDs character. A friend even said to me that she has noticed a maturity in onlies that she doesn’t see generally in people with siblings. I know only adults and they are fine. They build their own communities, lives and it works out. Equally, some people with siblings struggle a whole lot.

I hope the day comes when you are at peace with your decision. I definitely got to that point eventually.

Ponderingwindow · 10/11/2026 13:27

We stopped with one and I am very happy with that choice. We are able to parent dd exactly the way she needs without compromise. No, we won’t be around forever, but there is no guarantee of sibling closeness. Most people build their own chosen family with a life partner or friends who share their interests.

Godfreyjelly · 10/11/2026 13:30

I have 2 dcs but I wouldn't be concerned about having siblings when they are adults. DH and I both have siblings but we have very little contact with them. Most adults make friends and are competent in dealing with things as independent adults, they don't need a sibling to hold their hand through life.

You've said yourself that you wouldn't want to relive the first 3 years of babyhood and that should be enough really. You need to make the decisions in life that are right for you, and put your own needs first.

Ponderingwindow · 10/11/2026 13:33

Another plus, my child will be moving on in life soon and may choose a different location. Once she has lived a bit and settled down, we plan to follow and spend our retirement years near wherever she has chosen. She is aware of this plan and knows we will give her space. We won’t move in next door. Most likely we will still be a bit away, but we will be close enough to visit without it having to be an overnight stay.

with two children we wouldn’t necessarily have that luxury. They might choose places too far apart.

Savvysix1984 · 10/11/2026 13:38

I have one child. A dd15. I love it! Apart from when she was about 3 she has never asked for a sibling. She tells me she loves being an only child. We’ve always made sure she had access to clubs, groups, sports and friends. She plays a sport to a high level (think 6am training) and I don’t think we’d be able to facilitate this with more than one. She has always been kind, sensitive, loving and friendly.
we are lucky that we have enough resources for us all to have a really lovely life. Dd and I do several city breaks/ concerts a year. We go on holiday 4-5 times a year and on at least one of these holidays allow her to pick a friend (past 3 years). She has cousins of a similar age and a large extended family.

we are extremely close and have a very special relationship. We spend loads of time together since we share interests and hobbies. just yesterday her best friend sent her a meme saying that my dd was her favourite person and I said what did you say and she said ‘same’ then turned to me and said ‘but really you’re my favourite person’.

don’t feel guilty op. Having a sibling isn’t a guarantee of a loving and supportive relationship. Most of my friends have 2 kids and when I see the kids fighting or them being pulled from one child’s needs to the other I thank my lucky stars for my situation. My bf says she would’ve been very happy with just one, but her youngest has a range of additional needs and can be challenging. The oldest gets overlooked.

yellowrosesontable · 10/11/2026 13:39

I have an only due to secondary infertility, I considered adopting but she would hate to have a sibling, I hope they have DC in the future but honestly I’m mostly estranged from my younger brother who makes life much, much harder when we have to make decisions or deal with issues regards our aging parents.

redboxer321 · 10/11/2026 13:45

I would have much preferred to be an only child. Siblings are not always a good thing. Nothing horrendous but I think I would have fared better without my sibling.

Mydogisagentleman · 10/11/2026 13:47

We have an only DD. She was a complete pita between about 8 and 20. Me and dh often said that we were glad we only had 1.
She is now a delight growing up we made sure that she felt able to have friends over, drove her to clubs and sports.
She has masses of friends and has often said that she is glad she never had siblings

ProtestantTraybakeQueen · 10/11/2026 13:49

By the time you die and she’s alone, she’ll have made her own family/chosen family/connections/life. Don’t worry about that. DH has a brother but is essentially an only child as they have nothing to do with each other. You sound like all 3 of your are happy :)

Elliesbelly · 10/11/2026 13:51

I have 3 but I have entirely different circumstances to you that allowed that to happen. I can completely see where you are coming from, as I would probably make the same choice to have 1 in your shoes.

Having one child is the big change, that is the one that makes you a parent.

There are pros and cons that need to be weighed up deciding on more children and you are being eminently sensible.

MrsBennetsPoorNervesAreBack · 10/11/2026 13:59

I had an only child due to secondary infertility. She is a young adult now.

I felt terribly guilty for a few years, especially when random strangers kept asking me when we were going to have another one and telling me that dd needed a sibling. And then I realised that it really didn't matter because dd was happy and thriving.

Honestly, if I had my time again now, I would plan to have an only. DD has never wanted a sibling. She doesn't fit any of the nasty "only child" stereotypes - quite the contrary, in fact. I never had to divide my resources or my attention. I never had to referee or deal with sibling rivalry. And I was able to maintain my career while building an incredibly close relationship with my dd that has endured into her adulthood.

I used to worry about what would happen when we get old, and whether the burden on dd would be too much. But then I realised that having a sibling didn't prevent me from having to do all of the care for my elderly father independently. As dd herself pointed out, she won't have anyone to disagree with the decisions that she makes for us, and she won't have anyone to resent for not pulling their weight.

I get on ok with my sibling as an adult, but my friends are the ones who really give me support. My dd has fantastic social skills and she will always have people around her.

As long as you surround your child with love and give her plenty of opportunities to socialise with other children, she will be fine. Don't let the false stereotype of a lonely only guilt you into having a child that you don't want. It wouldn't be fair on anyone.

Swipe left for the next trending thread