Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

News

SAVE TOP GEAR Petition link here

94 replies

Pixiefish · 24/09/2006 12:00

SAVE TOP GEAR Petition link here

OP posts:
DumbledoresGirl · 24/09/2006 14:15

Shame we can't vote to get rid of some other tv programmes............

beansprout · 24/09/2006 14:20

I won't be signing it. Sooner Clarkson crawls back under his rock, the better.

catsmother · 24/09/2006 14:25

I will sign it in a seecond.

I deplore the little oiks who think it safe to drive fast with no regard to conditions and speed limits (let alone, it often also seems, a valid driving licence, insurance or tax) but I truly believe tw*ts like that are not Top Gear's audience.

Top Gear does feature glamourous, luxury cars but whilst on public roads often refer to speed limits. In their regular "races" (JC vs RH & JM across Europe or whatever) frequent reference is made to JC being held up by speed limits. Indeed, the Stig has been shown being pulled over by the Police for allegedly speeding (though this was almost certainly a comedy moment set-up). Only on private land, do they exceed speed limits ..... the fact they are on an airfield etc. is always made clear.

Non-viewers may also be surprised to learn that Top Gear does do safety features too, though I admit it is best known for its escapism, commaraderie and high jinks. I think most people tune in for a bit of fantasy .... to oooh and aahhh over cars they could never afford, and to be entertained. The vast majority of its viewers, if any, do not then immediately rush out and push their own cars to the limit.

The sort of irresponsible oik who does do that will probably have been too busy hot wiring someone else's car to be watching TV at all. I don't mean to diminish or belittle any concerns other people have for road safety but that is a far wider issue which needs to be tackled with proper, deterrent and punishing sentencing ..... the same as you'd get for manslaughter in many cases when people are killed (what else is getting into an uninsured car without a licence?) rather than "dangerous driving".

Were Top Gear never to appear on TV again, does anyone really believe the repulsive tw*ts who drive with no regard to anyone else would suddenly disappear ? I doubt accident statistics would alter at all.

stephanieplum · 24/09/2006 14:36

Signed by whole family who are up in arms. I agree they watch brainiac and have a healthy disregard for caravans watch top gear and tell me off for speeding. They laugh so much sometimes though I think they are going to burst a blood vessel and by the way I am a girl racer!

charliecat · 24/09/2006 14:38

THEY HAVE POSTPOSED IT FOR NOW

pageturner · 24/09/2006 14:38

Signed.

redsky · 24/09/2006 14:52

signed - TG is loved by all our family

makemineadouble · 24/09/2006 15:26

signed

KathH · 24/09/2006 16:10

signed

PeachyClairHasBadHair · 24/09/2006 16:40

Signed and forwarded

janeite · 24/09/2006 16:56

Not signed - think it's a horrible programme, sorry.

Enid · 24/09/2006 17:05

I think its mad to cancel it because of the accident

but I think the actual programme is boring beyond belief so I won't be signing

PinkTulips · 24/09/2006 17:08

signed by me and dp

love the show and i'm by no means a speed demon, neither is dp. we drive a lovely big family ford focus estate and i challange anyone to speed in it!

catsmother put it best (as usual!), the little prats who speed astras around housing estates are not doing so because top gear 'made them do it', they'll still be there if the program is pulled (unfortuanately )

PinkTulips · 24/09/2006 17:10

its up to 9578 btw

jenkel · 24/09/2006 17:34

We also love TG in this house. I will sign the petition, but the one thing that worries me is that are the presenters are under a lot of pressure to do stunts like that. If its up to the presenters and they can and do say no to some things then thats fine, but the slightest amount of pressue makes me uneasy. Saying that, my DH would jump at the chance to do some of the things that they do, they are just not readily available for the man in the street to do.

Can you remember the episode where RH had to sail a camper van across a lake, had us all in hysterics that one.

jenkel · 24/09/2006 17:34

We also love TG in this house. I will sign the petition, but the one thing that worries me is that are the presenters are under a lot of pressure to do stunts like that. If its up to the presenters and they can and do say no to some things then thats fine, but the slightest amount of pressue makes me uneasy. Saying that, my DH would jump at the chance to do some of the things that they do, they are just not readily available for the man in the street to do.

Can you remember the episode where RH had to sail a camper van across a lake, had us all in hysterics that one.

jenkel · 24/09/2006 17:36

Sorry, clicked twice.

But just wanted to add that I dont think stopping TG will stop the maniacs on the roads, as long as we have cars and roads we will have idiots behind the wheel.

Pixiefish · 24/09/2006 17:50

no pressure on the presenters

OP posts:
edam · 24/09/2006 18:13

I don't even drive yet I love Top Gear. It has engaging presenters with a real love for their subject, a superbly well-written script and high production values. Quality television.

Plus J Clarkson is a reformed sexist. I don't know many public figures who have changed their behaviour after legitimate criticism. But he certainly did (all those awful comparisons between cars and women he used to make).

PeachyClairHasBadHair · 24/09/2006 19:24

I used to think JC was a prat, I still do on some subjects (vegetarians etc), however I also think he is a sensible enough prat not to want to be dead, he is an intelligent amnd and probably the least likely one to be bullied into doing anything that i can think of. I've also grown to like aspects of his attitude sucha sthose depicted in that Sun article- when you come round from a coma, you want someone being vaguely offensive to you in a joshing manner- at least I would, I hate sympathy!

Top Gear is a BBC2 programme, boy racers don't know you can get BBC2!

NotAnOtter · 24/09/2006 19:43

signed

hulababy · 24/09/2006 19:46

Signed.

I am another one who doesn't think that shows like Top Gear leads to joy riding and speeding. I think they are just idiots who would just do it regardless of such programmes - they are probably out doing it when TG is on.

Thomcat · 24/09/2006 19:49

signed

tinbus · 24/09/2006 19:51

signed

MuddyMum · 24/09/2006 20:10

Signed.