Help me decide on sofa swatches

[cakecakecake98]

See image - I’m wanting the navy for one sofa, then I’m thinking a cream/beige for the other sofa. I’ve also thrown in a random olive swatch too.
Any opinions? Will it work or not? DP would rather have matching and not keen on beige/cream but really it’s my decision
😁

Honestly the navy could work with any of those, I prefer the olive but I like colours not endless beiges and greys. 😂 BUT what colour is the room? Walls, floor, rugs, curtains etc? Or are you choosing these first then working the rest out?

Thanks for your quick reply! Well that’s the thing, the walls are going to be sage green with one wall in this wallpaper:
https://www.grahambrown.com/uk/product/clavering-birds-night-wallpaper/121450-master/?gadsource=1&gclid=CjwKCAjwnqK1BhBvEiwAi7o0Xyqu01xkwiK4pSvR4OE4ACtn2rif8Pn7COP4pFdtuFGLP-cpMXZRoCMa4QAvDBwE

The floor is oak hardwood (more orangey). Haven’t chosen curtains yet.
I don’t like endless beige either but thought it’d be a little more interesting with two mismatched sofas!

I'm with your husband I'm afraid, I think matching sofas generally look better in matching colours. I think a chair in a contrasting colour looks good. But that's just my opinion so ignore it you want!
If you do for 2 colours I think top row no 3 and middle row no 3 and no 4 go best.

I like the olive. In fact my favourites are immediately above and below the navy swatch.

Olive

Olive seems to be winning - my only thought is that 3 of the walls will be this shade:

https://www.dunelm.com/product/dunelm-sage-matt-emulsion-paint-1000185240

So not sure if the olive sofa will be too matchy with that?

That wallpaper is 😍!
But opens up SUCH possibilities! One navy sofa, one pink? Or one navy one emerald? Or...one pink one patterned with complimentary leaf design?
Or would any of that be too wild? 😆

I have chosen unmatching sofas for years but I'm getting matching next time so it must be the fashion or I wouldn't have thought of doing it.

Yes! Don't do that wallpaper a disservice with beige!

Are you sure about that paint with the wallpaper?
I'm not feeling it.
Obviously you might be convinced and that's fine, I'm just chucking in some dissent.

Can I be cheeky and ask for a link to the sofas? I’m currently sofa hunting.

From the wallpaper photo, it would look lovely with navy walls and pink sofas?

@MissyB1
https://www.next.co.uk/homeware/sofas-chairs/wilson/size-large-sofa-fabric-fine-chenille-easy-clean-mid-taupe-feet-low-retro-tapered-standard

www.next.co.uk/homeware/sofas-chairs/michigan-ii/size-large-sofa-fabric-fine-chenille-easy-clean-dark-navy-feet-slim-block-light

The two different sofas - already decided on the navy one of course but the Wilson one could change colour!

I take the point about the sage paint and the wallpaper - my heart is set on it though! I love navy but as the wallpaper is predominately navy I think it’d make the room too dark.

Also appreciate the suggestions about not going with beige - let me have a further look at colours!

Go for fuschia pink! My husband wouldn't agree with that sadly !

I'm going to be honest and say I don't like the fact that the two sofas have different feet/legs.

@cakecakecake98 on the point of the paint, it's just the fact (for me) that the greens in the fabulous and definitely not to be changed wallpaper are a bit more bluey. I agree navy walls and then the room's dark, so if you are not going for dark winter snug that's no good. Doing this on my phone so bit tricky with comparisons but what about a green more like this instead of the sage?

https://www.dunelm.com/product/dunelm-seafoam-matt-emulsion-paint-1000185239

@cakecakecake98

Definitely not beige.

I would go for a pink tone or even a mustard / burnt orange / gold colour.

I don’t think the navy goes with the wallpaper. It’s the wrong tone of blue.

So they have teal blue or a brighter green?

I agree, I think it's because one has legs and the other is on the floor.

Bottom left

I think this is a great point - I couldn’t actually decide between these two shades but now I look again I can see what you mean.

Regarding the sofas this is all becoming a minefield.. I’m rather thinking I’ll just go for the two navy sofas and get a chair in another colour!!!

Love both sofas, but I agree you need two of the same. Two navy would be lovely.

Two navy sofas and either a pink or mustard yellow chair?!?!

If you're going for two different colour sofas I'd be going with the olive and if you're worried about the olive paint then put the olive sofa against/close to the wallpaper wall because it will contrast nicely with it.

Burnt orange, raspberry pink, cherry red are the sort of colours I'd go for with sage walls