I really don't know. One has said he probably prefers Bristol. The other has not committed yet to a choice even verbally.
We are seeing family tomorrow so the one question you can be sure the twins will be asked by everyone is where they are going - they are fed up of being asked it. Perhaps that will help them make up their minds.
My father went to Durham and I'm from the NE. Their cousin went to Durham (and oodles of time ago it was always second to Oxbridge in the very very old days). My view is the decision should be based on job prospects but I don't see much difference between the two so they would therefore be choosing on other grounds.
Their older sister who had the same choice and went to Bristol which she liked very much found Bristol obviously closer to London where was are so easier to get to for us. I do loads of choral and church singing (and the twins have music scholarships at school) but Bristol is hardly lacking in classical music and I doubt that's top of the twins' reasons to pick a unviersity anyway whereas I was looking at where I'd go to church, before I went to university. I certainly agree with you about the smaller city point and I love how Durham looks. It's cold up there . I've lived up there so know about the temperature but that's hardly a major issue.
This is why it's hard for them to choose.
I will be content with whatever they choose although I have never driven all the way up to the NE without an over night stop and am not sure I'd be prepared to now either - i don't like long drives so that makes it harder in terms of logistics of getting there and train fares cost more.
Nice dilemma. Whether they then get the grades will be another matter of course. Nothing is certain particularly in this guinea pig year when some of their subjects are old system A levels and some new system.