Meet the Other Phone. Only the apps you allow.

Meet the Other Phone.
Only the apps you allow.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Ethical dilemmas

Would you report someone for working a second job cash in hand

207 replies

dammit88 · 28/03/2026 19:05

…. And not paying tax? Earning around £100-200 extra per week on top of their normal pays job.

has anyone ever done this? Did anything happen?

OP posts:
dizzydizzydizzy · 28/03/2026 20:41

therockingbird · 28/03/2026 20:09

Hardly.. as a parent of two nhs diagnosed boys with autism the sudden incline of adults who are throwing this shit in the ring makes my blood boil. Totally understand the need to get the support of a child but an adult finding a way to fleece the system baffles me.

You still sound dismissive, which is surprising with your experience.

The NHS diagnoses adults with ADHD. You have to have had significant difficulties all your life to get a diagnosis. For women, ADHD starts getting worse around menopause due to falling estrogen levels (this impacts dopamine activity.).

CaptainMyCaptain · 28/03/2026 20:42

likelysuspect · 28/03/2026 19:08

I couldnt really care less about the tax take from someone like this, I am concerned about how little taxation is paid by other means, some of which would affect you and me both, and this other person probably. Certainly the tax arrangements of big corporations concern me but then its said that if governmens come down hard on them and change the laws then they'll operate out of other countries to avoid it anyway

I would be keen to tax foreign home buyers.

If by 'foreign home buyers' you mean people who buy houses as investments but don't live in then I totally agree.

FindingMeno · 28/03/2026 20:46

Just don't advertise it.
Most people are savvy enough not to delve.

HoneyNutsandLoops · 28/03/2026 20:50

I have tried in vain, in my professional role, to get HMRC interested in some extreme tax evading operations which the police have also declined to take on (hopefully that might change soon). If they can’t give a monkeys about the case I mentioned, I doubt they have the resources to pursue you OP. So frustrating.

But keep schtum in any event as much as possible.

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 28/03/2026 20:50

I'd only do it if I had a really good reason, for example if this person was fiddling the books to avoid paying me child maintenance.

But I doubt that's what you're doing OP, so I'd stay out of it. I have a friend who's a self-employed cleaner and she told me that she doesn't declare all of her jobs. But she lives alone and is not exactly wealthy, so I don't know if she could make ends meet otherwise.

Nincompoo · 28/03/2026 20:54

I wouldn’t even consider it.

RollOnSunshine · 28/03/2026 21:03

No I don't think so for that amount. Given that times are hard and the government would only give it away to the feckless and bone idle anyway.

If it was a multiple thousands a month and an already rich person then yes I would probably report.

NFPorterkeeponkeepingonNsoul · 28/03/2026 21:15

For considering it you deserve to be on the HMRC phone line for all eternity.

socialdilemmawhattodo · 28/03/2026 21:18

Always. I paid my taxes for years. Why shouldn't everyone else. Also to say any job i have ever had done where the trades person wanted cash was inevitabkt a poor quality job. I no longer ever pay cash.

Growlybear83 · 28/03/2026 21:21

Of course not.

OliviaBonas · 28/03/2026 21:33

Just because people choose to pay you cash doesn’t mean you’re not declaring it. They can pay cash and assume you’re paying tax on it. I think it’s fine as you’re paying tax on your main salary. You can earn £1k on a side hussle anyway tax free per year so you could just say you earn less than that.

socialdilemmawhattodo · 29/03/2026 02:35

EstoyRobandoSuCasa · 28/03/2026 20:50

I'd only do it if I had a really good reason, for example if this person was fiddling the books to avoid paying me child maintenance.

But I doubt that's what you're doing OP, so I'd stay out of it. I have a friend who's a self-employed cleaner and she told me that she doesn't declare all of her jobs. But she lives alone and is not exactly wealthy, so I don't know if she could make ends meet otherwise.

Yes the basic tax rate kicks in at approx £13k. A full time job on minimum wage is approx £26k. So if she is working more than 50 % she needs to be declaring her income,net of reasonable expenses. Enough is enough. This country needs all its citizens to be paying the correct taxes. Not just employees.

socialdilemmawhattodo · 29/03/2026 02:36

OliviaBonas · 28/03/2026 21:33

Just because people choose to pay you cash doesn’t mean you’re not declaring it. They can pay cash and assume you’re paying tax on it. I think it’s fine as you’re paying tax on your main salary. You can earn £1k on a side hussle anyway tax free per year so you could just say you earn less than that.

Edited

You sound naive. Utterly naive. No one is taking cash, if they are not declaring it as income.

Itsnaptime · 29/03/2026 03:29

Just seen the update it's about yourself..... How would anyone know unless you tell them? Just don't mention it and no one would know to be able to report you

W0tnow · 29/03/2026 04:20

Badbadbunny · 28/03/2026 20:17

@EstrellaPolar

We’re not paying more tax because someone is avoiding paying it on £100 a week they earn extra.

It's not just one person though. The black economy costs the country tens of billions per year. The largest component of the official "tax gap" is small evasion. By contrast, the evasion by millionaires/billionaires is a much smaller proportion of the overall tax gap. Literally millions of people each evading relatively small amounts adds up to massive amounts.

If two million people in the lowest tax bracket earned on average 100 quid a week per year in cash, how much lost tax would that be? And what percentage of that would it be if total tax revenue. I’d say it would be minuscule.

mathanxiety · 29/03/2026 05:47

No way.

YYY to you'd be a vicious poisonous jobsworth to do it
@PiglingBlandings

mathanxiety · 29/03/2026 05:52

Badbadbunny · 28/03/2026 20:17

@EstrellaPolar

We’re not paying more tax because someone is avoiding paying it on £100 a week they earn extra.

It's not just one person though. The black economy costs the country tens of billions per year. The largest component of the official "tax gap" is small evasion. By contrast, the evasion by millionaires/billionaires is a much smaller proportion of the overall tax gap. Literally millions of people each evading relatively small amounts adds up to massive amounts.

And presumably all those people will be spending their undeclared billions in the official economy. What goes around comes around.

bronnibro · 29/03/2026 07:11

Yes I report my ex often, unfortunately nothing happens, but it's not a second job, it's his main job that he does to avoid paying and says to child maintenance he earns 7 pounds a week...which they accept 🥴

bronnibro · 29/03/2026 07:12

And I don't feel bad or think im a twat 😆 but in other circumstances no I wouldn't report people for this at all

Climbinghigher · 29/03/2026 07:16

dammit88 · 28/03/2026 20:16

It was something I was considering as struggling to make ends meet and this was on my mind and I’m not sure it’s worth it.

If you’re worried about it just do self assessment. I had income in small amounts from multiple sources for years. Usually below or only just above the tax threshold. Self assessment was easy enough - you just need your P60 from any employment. I never used an accountant as I didn’t earn enough.

I don’t think anyone is likely to report you (how would they know anyway?) but if it will worry you just declare it. It’s honestly pretty straightforward.

BlueDressingGowns · 29/03/2026 07:20

No, none of my business.

overnightangel · 29/03/2026 09:03

W0tnow · 29/03/2026 04:20

If two million people in the lowest tax bracket earned on average 100 quid a week per year in cash, how much lost tax would that be? And what percentage of that would it be if total tax revenue. I’d say it would be minuscule.

£100 pw x 52 weeks = £1,040
£1,040 x 2 million = 2 billion and 80 million pounds.

The tax would be 20% of that, which is the cost of 15 million prescriptions to the NHS, or 9,500 teacher’s salaries (using the median salary).

TY78910 · 29/03/2026 09:06

Not for that amount no. If they were working for thousands, yes.

likelysuspect · 29/03/2026 09:07

overnightangel · 29/03/2026 09:03

£100 pw x 52 weeks = £1,040
£1,040 x 2 million = 2 billion and 80 million pounds.

The tax would be 20% of that, which is the cost of 15 million prescriptions to the NHS, or 9,500 teacher’s salaries (using the median salary).

Edited

I think your maths is wrong there, its 5k a year income

Or 10 if we're using 200 a week which is what OP put out initially

likelysuspect · 29/03/2026 09:08

overnightangel · 29/03/2026 09:03

£100 pw x 52 weeks = £1,040
£1,040 x 2 million = 2 billion and 80 million pounds.

The tax would be 20% of that, which is the cost of 15 million prescriptions to the NHS, or 9,500 teacher’s salaries (using the median salary).

Edited

You edited after I posted!