Meet the Other Phone. Protection built in.

Meet the Other Phone.
Protection built in.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Craicnet

Sphe 'irish family'

155 replies

Orders76 · 04/09/2024 00:28

Has anyone seen the gript article that sphe books have Irish family v multi cultural...it's absolutely nuts if true

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
DublinFemale · 08/09/2024 23:05

I feel I clarified my post re the free book scheme in my post @10.48ish

The government most definitely did not fund school books for this sole purpose of course not

However based on past history it is not conspiracy theory to suspect that an activist could have taken advantage of the opportunity to advance their cause

The past history is a video discussing how self Id was snuck after the SSM referendum.

A poster posted a link in another thread but I have but unable to find it or remember the poster.

With my 3 colleagues with children in secondary all 3 got the books last Monday 2nd when they started/returned to school.

Maybe now the expense of school books is not on parents they may not have regular new editions, meaning replacement of books.

DublinFemale · 08/09/2024 23:18

I found the thread it is self ID snuck in back the original video however has been changed to private so not viewable anymore

Lightfromtheoak · 09/09/2024 00:26

I know how self id came about @DublinFemale.
I still think some of the places this thread has gone are a bit mad.

A government conspiracy regarding the book scheme was certainly being alluded to earlier in the thread.
"The free book scheme seemed to be a good thing but it is looking more insidious.
Lesson to be learned government don't do anything for the greater good."

And a pp referred to the prospect of banning mobile phone use in schools as 'sinister'.

Yes, there are problems, we all know that - the original point of the thread as an example -
but there are some wild imaginings going on here too. A bit of focus would be good.

DublinFemale · 09/09/2024 08:59

@Lightfromtheoak

It was me that said that and I believe I explained myself in my next post @10.48 yesterday.

It is very plausible that activist used the opportunity to sneak this in.

Based on government history this is not beyond the realm of possibility

DublinFemale · 09/09/2024 09:04

Also for all why is it only in the English version, the whole chapter is not in the Irish edition.

If this the curriculum why is it not in both version.

The curriculum is the curriculum is the curriculum.

If English speaking schools are telling children teaching this about Irish culture why isn't the Irish version teaching the same?

Lightfromtheoak · 09/09/2024 09:15

DublinFemale · 09/09/2024 08:59

@Lightfromtheoak

It was me that said that and I believe I explained myself in my next post @10.48 yesterday.

It is very plausible that activist used the opportunity to sneak this in.

Based on government history this is not beyond the realm of possibility

Ok, I've lost track of who said what, sorry.

Your 10.48 post just says parents mightn't see the books as much now the free book scheme is operational.

I take it you think that was a deliberate ploy so?

Parents can see the books if they're interested . The only difference is they don't purchase them and have them at home before school starts in Sept ( though as I say ours were collected from school anyway to be labelled, but not all schools will do this). They still come home for homework. Also, they're available online when your child has the code (from the hardcopy). Or just ask your child to bring home any particular book of interest some evening.

Lightfromtheoak · 09/09/2024 09:19

DublinFemale · 09/09/2024 09:04

Also for all why is it only in the English version, the whole chapter is not in the Irish edition.

If this the curriculum why is it not in both version.

The curriculum is the curriculum is the curriculum.

If English speaking schools are telling children teaching this about Irish culture why isn't the Irish version teaching the same?

Yes, that is certainly an interesting question and I'd like to know tge answer to that.
Maybe the translators had a bit of sense? I don't know. Hope it's investigated and we find out.

Abhannmor · 09/09/2024 09:37

Lightfromtheoak · 08/09/2024 09:52

I agree entirely!

I don't see any link at all between the new free book scheme ( very welcome imo), or suggestions to reduce smartphone use, with the sphe content being discussed.

Some of the ramblings on this thread really do sound like conspiracy theories and quite mad. Seriously, get a hold of yourselves!

I am GC by the way but it's got nothing to do with providing schoolbooks for free (at last). It's not like parents chose the books themselves before this scheme.

No it isn't a conspiracy as such. They tend to be organised in secret whereas this nonsense is very upfront - apart from the odd decision to remove this chapter from the Irish language version of the book.

Neither is it a literal new religion. More a secular cult? It does have many features shared by traditional religions though. Mantras , excommunication for heretics and a sacred caste who cannot be questioned or criticised. We , of all people, are quite familiar with these little rules and pieties.

Abhannmor · 09/09/2024 09:44

DublinFemale · 09/09/2024 09:04

Also for all why is it only in the English version, the whole chapter is not in the Irish edition.

If this the curriculum why is it not in both version.

The curriculum is the curriculum is the curriculum.

If English speaking schools are telling children teaching this about Irish culture why isn't the Irish version teaching the same?

Perhaps the authors thought that Irish speakers would take more offence at these stereotypes of our culture? They probably imagine Gaeilgeoirí as the ultimate form of Oirish peasant.

Aranknickers · 09/09/2024 09:51

I think they felt it was pointless to put in the Irish speaking version.
The whole point of it was to make Irish children feel awkward, embarrassed & inferior in multicultural classrooms.

DublinFemale · 09/09/2024 11:00

As I have said not all children got the books in August.

And when my kids in school there was no homework as such from SPHE, pastoral care as it was called then do no reason for book to come home once they got lockers.

I do believe someone saw an opportunity and took it.

If this was not deliberate it should have been in both versions.

There is no reason to exclude it if it to be taught as part of the curriculum.

DublinFemale · 09/09/2024 11:05

Aranknickers · 09/09/2024 09:51

I think they felt it was pointless to put in the Irish speaking version.
The whole point of it was to make Irish children feel awkward, embarrassed & inferior in multicultural classrooms.

That's my feeling, more chance of different cultures in English speaking schools than Irish speaking schools, do more opportunities to demean Irish culture.

DublinFemale · 09/09/2024 11:14

My family and I tick at least half the boxes

Red hair
Self employed
Farming background
Several family members play Gaa
Love bacon and cabbage

Should we be ashamed?

Lightfromtheoak · 09/09/2024 11:22

Abhannmor · 09/09/2024 09:37

No it isn't a conspiracy as such. They tend to be organised in secret whereas this nonsense is very upfront - apart from the odd decision to remove this chapter from the Irish language version of the book.

Neither is it a literal new religion. More a secular cult? It does have many features shared by traditional religions though. Mantras , excommunication for heretics and a sacred caste who cannot be questioned or criticised. We , of all people, are quite familiar with these little rules and pieties.

I was talking specifically about how some pp have seen sinister motivations in the free book scheme and in the proposals to lessen smartphone use in schools @Abhannmor.

That's talking it too far imo, whatever your opinion on the sphe chapter that's the subject of this thread (which I agree is appalling btw). Or on the way trans ideology is being taught to kids (which has far too much activist imput imo).

But I think linking the book scheme or possible phone bans to that, as some pp have done, is crazy. It's not all a plot.

Lightfromtheoak · 09/09/2024 11:38

Input I mean. Too late to edit.

Aranknickers · 09/09/2024 11:52

I think the whole gender shite is going out of fashion with the teens eg pronouns are now "cringe" & the activists are trying to get a foothold whatever way they can.

Demented101 · 09/09/2024 15:17

Apart from this way of thinking having a negative effect on children's mental health, the lack of trust you can see on this thread is another major symptom. It is doing massive damage to public institutions.

If an institution is being used by ideologues as a vehicle to shove the new religion down people's throats, trust is lost and eventually over time that institution is no longer fit for purpose. National Women's Council of Ireland is a prime example of this.

Apart from the offensive stereotypes used in that lesson, what was the overall purpose of that lesson? To teach children to judge their class mates? Why does anybody need to have an opinion on what somebody else is having for their feckin dinner!? The only purpose I could see in it was indoctrination.

I don't believe that could be put in a text book without oversight. I know they pulled it quickly when it got attention but to my mind, this and other issues create a lack of trust around what influences and agendas are at play here.

I was happy enough to get the free school books as well this year but I'm sending them for education not indoctrination and there needs to be trust in that system. At the end of the day it's the public who are paying for that education as well as the books and the Department need to be accountable to us rather than to activists

Demented101 · 09/09/2024 15:50

Aranknickers · 09/09/2024 11:52

I think the whole gender shite is going out of fashion with the teens eg pronouns are now "cringe" & the activists are trying to get a foothold whatever way they can.

I hope so!!

Demented101 · 09/09/2024 17:42

DublinFemale · 09/09/2024 11:14

My family and I tick at least half the boxes

Red hair
Self employed
Farming background
Several family members play Gaa
Love bacon and cabbage

Should we be ashamed?

Oh dear, honestly it's not looking good for ye is it?

Maybe if ye recite a few rosaries of 'trans women are women' and clock up some air miles ye could redeem yourselves from your bigotry?

Sunlightinclouds · 09/09/2024 17:44

Aranknickers · 09/09/2024 09:51

I think they felt it was pointless to put in the Irish speaking version.
The whole point of it was to make Irish children feel awkward, embarrassed & inferior in multicultural classrooms.

I think this is a good point.
This is aimed at classrooms where there are more mixed nationalities and cultures.
It was probably intended as a way of saying being Irish in 2024 is something different to what it had been in the past and that new immigrants and cultures should also consider themselves Irish.
But it was clumsily done and was extremely insulting and sneering of traditional Irish culture and traditions in favour of the more progressive multicultural family B.
It also promotes the idea that being traditional Irish is inferior to the more modern definition.

DublinFemale · 09/09/2024 18:40

@Demented101

It has been a weird and wacky day. I'm going to assume you are slagging.

So based on that

DublinFemale · 09/09/2024 18:42

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

Demented101 · 09/09/2024 18:57

DublinFemale · 09/09/2024 18:40

@Demented101

It has been a weird and wacky day. I'm going to assume you are slagging.

So based on that

I am indeed :)

DublinFemale · 09/09/2024 19:48

SmileSmile

MarieDeGournay · 10/09/2024 10:05

It was probably intended as a way of saying being Irish in 2024 is something different to what it had been in the past and that new immigrants and cultures should also consider themselves Irish.
But it was clumsily done and was extremely insulting and sneering of traditional Irish culture and traditions in favour of the more progressive multicultural family

I think you've got a point, Sunlightinclouds, the attitude that you have to 'look like you're Irish' to be Irish [e.g. the racist posts about our ParaOlympian Deaten Registe] needs to be tackled. My usual reply to that is two words:
PHIL LYNOTTSmile
The only positive I can take from this appalling imagery is that the outrage it provoked shows how awful it is to be reduced to stereotypes - in this case 'red-haired bacon-and-cabbage-eating small minded peasants'.

If even a fraction of people who indulge in reducing asylum seekers/refugees/immigrants to stereotypes like 'dangerous violent child-molesting raping scroungers' stop for a moment and think 'Maybe those stereotypes are as bad as the red-haired etc ones... maybe everybody is an individual..' some good will have come from this outrageous imagery.

Swipe left for the next trending thread