Meet the Other Phone. A phone that grows with your child.

Meet the Other Phone.
A phone that grows with your child.

Buy now

Please or to access all these features

Conflict in the Middle East

"The only purpose of these endless marches is to intimidate British Jews" (part two) ***MNHQ has tweaked the title in order to make the quote more clear***

1000 replies

stomachameleon · 13/01/2024 21:43

Only the few apparently........these pictures are from todays March. Footage to follow..

"The only purpose of these endless marches is to intimidate British Jews" (part two) ***MNHQ has tweaked the title in order to make the quote more clear***
"The only purpose of these endless marches is to intimidate British Jews" (part two) ***MNHQ has tweaked the title in order to make the quote more clear***
"The only purpose of these endless marches is to intimidate British Jews" (part two) ***MNHQ has tweaked the title in order to make the quote more clear***
OP posts:
Thread gallery
58
windowframer · 14/01/2024 17:38

What small detail do you mean?

noblegiraffe · 14/01/2024 17:40

windowframer · 14/01/2024 16:08

@noblegiraffe

Of course he's saying the state of Israel should be eradicated, yes. Some flavour of that (whether meaning violently eradicated, deprived of its status as a jewish state, amalgamated with Palestine or whatever) is what anti-Zionism is.

So here:

So, these people are calling for the eradication of Israel. To deny that this has anything to do with antisemitism and purely to do with Israel deserves closer scrutiny.

The question is: do you think that they would be calling for the eradication of Israel if it wasn't a Jewish state (the only one in the world, in fact). Do you think they would be saying this if it were a Muslim state?

There are plenty of other, even newer countries in the region where people have been displaced and land has been grabbed. Are there calls to wipe them off the map?

And then, when you look at groups like the Houthis who don't even bother to hide it, they say "Death to Israel, a curse upon the Jews". The anti-Israel sentiment and the antisemitism are clearly linked.

So denying that this sort of fervent antizionism isn't at all linked to antisemitism or motivated by it doesn't really wash.

you're basically saying that anti-Zionism is antisemitic by definition.

It's not actually a question of scrutinising specific examples of anti-Zionism and working out whether they're actually coded antisemitism. You're saying that they are antisemitic by virtue of being anti-Zionist. It's not necessary to prove or even to know whether they mean anything other than "the state of Israel shouldn't exist". That statement is itself antisemitic.

You may be right, I don't know. Your questions certainly deserve consideration. But the first step is to be clear, and honest, about what we're arguing about.

you're basically saying that anti-Zionism is antisemitic by definition.

No, I specifically say fervent anti-Zionism such as the one demonstrated by the man calling on people to wipe out the Zionist death cult has clear links to antisemitism. Denying that would be futile.

And if you are on the streets of London giving a speech and calling for people to wipe out the "Zionist death cult" is the sane and sanitised version of your views, presented for public consumption, then it would be wholly unsurprising to find antisemitism not far from the surface.

It usually doesn't require much digging to find it.

If there are people out there who are casually antizionist - i.e. merely think the creation of Israel was a mistake (like so many other issues caused by lines on maps, a lot of them drawn by the British), then perhaps they should consider why they think that the solution should be the eradication of Israel, which has now been around for 75 years, rather than trying to make the best of things with a solution that is a bit more of a compromise. And why they aren't going around insisting that other lines drawn on maps that have caused wars (of which there are many) aren't also rubbed out in a similar way. Why are they picking on Israel, the world's only Jewish state? Is it possible that they might have been influenced in some way by the antisemitic anti Zionists?

SomeCatFromJapan · 14/01/2024 17:45

I would say any flavour of anti-Zionism that calls for the destruction of Israel as a Jewish state, is by definition anti-Semitism. Hence "from the river to the sea" is problematic.

Trulywonderful · 14/01/2024 17:46

Leeds, the Palestine Solidarity Campaign comrades today

One of their number thoughtfully thanked the Houthis. I don't think it was a large protest so easily noticeable by the police and the organisers

"The only purpose of these endless marches is to intimidate British Jews" (part two) ***MNHQ has tweaked the title in order to make the quote more clear***
Maireas · 14/01/2024 17:53

They're just so flagrant, aren't they? It's not even a small banner. Unbelievable.

noblegiraffe · 14/01/2024 17:56

Of course he's saying the state of Israel should be eradicated, yes. Some flavour of that (whether meaning violently eradicated, deprived of its status as a jewish state, amalgamated with Palestine or whatever) is what anti-Zionism is.

It should also be pointed out, @windowframer that wanting the eradication of Israel is a fairly extreme position, which is why so many people have spent time on here claiming that 'from the river to the sea' doesn't mean that.

Trulywonderful · 14/01/2024 18:02

Maireas · 14/01/2024 17:53

They're just so flagrant, aren't they? It's not even a small banner. Unbelievable.

Yep, seriously messed up isn't it

noblegiraffe · 14/01/2024 18:05

Someone on another thread was claiming that the Houthis were only attacking ships that were headed for Israel.

I mean, it's possible that these banner-wavers also don't have a clue what they're talking about.

Maireas · 14/01/2024 18:06

I think it's more than possible, it seems to me to be probable.

SomeCatFromJapan · 14/01/2024 18:13

Ah yes, the Houthis as brave defenders of vulnerable civilians. Whoever does their PR must be a genius.

windowframer · 14/01/2024 18:13

@noblegiraffe OK, I think I get what you mean.

It also could be pointed out that considering anti-Zionism to be antisemitic by definition is not an extreme position either. It's part of the IHRA definition after all. And this:

If there are people out there who are casually antizionist - i.e. merely think the creation of Israel was a mistake (like so many other issues caused by lines on maps, a lot of them drawn by the British), then perhaps they should consider why they think that the solution should be the eradication of Israel, which has now been around for 75 years, rather than trying to make the best of things with a solution that is a bit more of a compromise. And why they aren't going around insisting that other lines drawn on maps that have caused wars (of which there are many) aren't also rubbed out in a similar way. Why are they picking on Israel, the world's only Jewish state? Is it possible that they might have been influenced in some way by the antisemitic anti Zionists?

is fine as far as it goes, but that isn't very far really. It's not really saying much to tell people they should consider whether their opinions are influenced by extremists. They'll generally say no, and none of us are in a position to prove what other peoples' motivation is, particularly when we're trying to claim it's other than what they say it is. You either think those opinions, as stated, are inherently offensive or you don't. You seem to want to keep the door open here to be clear that you basically think they are, while acknowledging that you can't actually prove that because it relies upon assumptions about their underlying motivation.

Trulywonderful · 14/01/2024 18:14

Back to yesterday's protest again.
If you are going to stage a march, it makes good sense of course to put someone convicted of harassment at the head. I mean why wouldn't you what someone like that to represent your course 🤔

Claudia Webbe at yesterday's London protest.

"The only purpose of these endless marches is to intimidate British Jews" (part two) ***MNHQ has tweaked the title in order to make the quote more clear***
noblegiraffe · 14/01/2024 18:16

You either think those opinions, as stated, are inherently offensive or you don't. You seem to want to keep the door open here to be clear that you basically think they are, while acknowledging that you can't actually prove that because it relies upon assumptions about their underlying motivation.

Yes. See the people waving the Houthi banner. Are they supporters of antisemitic sex-slavers or are they merely idiots?

Either way they should not be waving that banner.

Trulywonderful · 14/01/2024 18:24

London protest yesterday

In case people don't know already, Leila Khaled is the first known woman to lead an airplane hijacking.

This is clear support for terrorism

"The only purpose of these endless marches is to intimidate British Jews" (part two) ***MNHQ has tweaked the title in order to make the quote more clear***
stomachameleon · 14/01/2024 18:29

I have just read 25,000 there today in support of Israel. Lots of flags including Iranian. Very different from the hate filled speeches of yesterday!

OP posts:
Maireas · 14/01/2024 18:43

Very different scenes. Very different banners and placards. It's important to remember that the hostages have endured 100 days of captivity. Including an 11 month old baby. Shocking.

Trulywonderful · 14/01/2024 20:33

Piers Cobyn doing a new world order banner

The man holding the other end looks like he was dragged into things because the rant on the banner was too long for Piers to hold alone😂

The McDonalds banner is more of a rant too

I don't think they get that nobody can read their banners unless the writing is larger, less of it and less creased up. Though probably for the best they don't understand this. I mean do we really want to read every word the likes of conspiracy theorist Piers has to say

"The only purpose of these endless marches is to intimidate British Jews" (part two) ***MNHQ has tweaked the title in order to make the quote more clear***
Maireas · 14/01/2024 20:40

Oh dear god, get out the tin foil hats.

noblegiraffe · 14/01/2024 20:51

Respect to the guy on the left for his lettering, it is very good.

There's a website listed on the bottom, I just went there. They are cross about ULEZ, vaccines and the climate hoax. There's also a link where you can donate money to Piers, presumably to pay his ULEZ fines.

Maireas · 14/01/2024 20:57

Anti vaxxers? Quelle surprise..

Trulywonderful · 14/01/2024 21:47

Sir Keir Starmer has condemned antisemites on protests and declared that he would keep Britain safe for Jews while speaking at the Jewish Labour Movement conference.

The Labour leader restated his support for a “humanitarian truce” in Gaza and the return of Israeli hostages.
"The bloodshed in Gaza must stop urgently,” he added.
Sir Keir also announced that five years after she quit the party after facing racism Luciana Berger 🎉 would take up an official role. The Jewish former MP will work alongside Shadow Health Secretery Wes Streeting to create a long-term cross-government strategy for mental health.

Referencing pro-Palestine marches in the UK, Sir Keir told JLM members: "I want to say to the Jewish community who look upon these events and can see hate marching side by side with calls for peace, people who hate Jews hiding behind people who support the just cause of a Palestinian state, we see what you see and we understand that to be targeted for who you are, attacked for things beyond your control, for your children to be afraid to walk the street or go to school is the greatest anxiety that a parent or any community could face.”

"So let me assure you we will never let antisemitism sneak back into the Labour party under cover. I see no greater cause in my leadership than this, this is my role. I dragged my party away from the abyss and I will never let Britain go anywhere near it either. This country will be safe for you and your children.”

Sir Keir repeated his support for the two-state solution. He insisted Labour, "will have to fight for the two-state solution in ways we haven't done for years, that the era of lip service and complacency must end.”

saveallthewhales · 14/01/2024 22:06

Some disturbing scenes in this event yesterday compared to a peaceful one today.

www.thejc.com/news/palestine-protestors-chant-in-support-of-houthi-rebels-t3rlbac1

saveallthewhales · 14/01/2024 23:03

Doesn't make their cause look good.

Trulywonderful · 15/01/2024 00:06

After the Express reporter posted about the fuckwits at Palestine Action planning to attack the London Stock Exchange.
The replies he receives are crazy.

This person takes it further though. It is a not very coded message suggesting "Kill Yourself".

"The only purpose of these endless marches is to intimidate British Jews" (part two) ***MNHQ has tweaked the title in order to make the quote more clear***
Please create an account

To comment on this thread you need to create a Mumsnet account.

This thread is not accepting new messages.