cleo Welcome to the thread, and of course your opinion is just as valid as anyone else's. I would say though, to echo in part what iggi has said, that if you read through all of the threads in this chain (and there are 12 of them, we've been going for quite some time) that I don't think anyone here would really wish to "knock" Mr S - but some of us have had different experiences with him and there's no reason why their opinions aren't just as valid. For myself, as one of the 'long-termers' here (like iggi and free who originally started this whole thread chain), I would say although I deeply respect Mr S and indeed like him personally, he did not have the answers for me as my particular issues run deeper than he was prepared to test for or indeed treat. I am very glad to see that tests that I had to really push him to do after quite a while of seeing him, he now does offer, and treatment that he dismissed as irrelevant (that I need) he also now offers. It's a good sign when a consultant is willing to change his stance on things; unfortunately it was too late for me.
I remain on this thread as I have a genuine interest in everyone here and the problems they face, although I am no longer under Mr S's care. I do wish for myself that my own issues had come to light much earlier - as they would have done if Mr S had tested for all the things that others, such as Dr Gorgy, routinely do - but I still have a great respect for Mr S and his work, and I never found him to be in any way rude or abrupt. Having said that, it's over a year now since I've seen him, and perhaps things have changed.
Anyway, just to say that if you haven't read the whole 12 pages of discussions you may not realise the history of some of the ladies here and these all have a bearing on what is being said here. You shouldn't take the comments on this particular part 12 thread as stand-alone - but as I say, everyone's opinions are valid, as are everyone's individual experiences - and yours are just as welcome as everyone else's! I am so pleased that Mr S had the answer for you, and your friends are just as happy. We have all suffered on this nightmare journey, and it's always a joy to hear of someone for whom this nightmare has ended happily.