Which penguin is nicest?

[MummyTheTramEngine]

For a 4yo boy. Help me decide! First one is 60cm

This one is 30cm

20cm

3rd one

I really can't choose. #firstworldproblems.

I'd go for the first one. The second looks like a caricature of Mumble form Happy Feet.

Oh the first one! Definitely.

Looks like a proper character. Second one looks a bit generic/mass-produced.

I like no.1 the best.

First or third (but I am a Jellycat fan!)

For a 4yo boy...number 1.

I would really need to stroke them to judge but for a 4 year old boy I would say 1. Its more realistic.

3rd. Very snugly

First one, I think too. First one is an adult one, second a baby and third a caricature. So I think it depends on the child. Do you think he would prefer an older or younger penguin as s companion?!

I just asked ds who's 4.5 - he said the second one is the cutest (I didn't do sizes with him though, just showed him photos! )

I'm still torn. Maybe I should go in store on a penguin stroking expedition in the interests of science!

I'd have chosen the second one!

Second one.

Second or third one

Jellycat fan here too so I'd say 3. Looks cuddly!

First one!

Second one.

I like the 1st!

Second one.

WE have one virtually the same as the first one...it came from our penguin encounter in Dubai and is very realistic!

DS2 is 5 and loves him!

(We have number 3)

I think my 4 year old would like the first one, the others look babyish.