I've bypassed most of the responses so that I don't twitch!!
I always think these threads get derailed by differing opinions of what is 'enough', 'too much' or 'not enough'.
Doesn't matter really though does it? Each to their own.....
FWIW, my kids get one present from us for under the tree (this year it's a fancy dress costume which one DD spied so I had to take it off the stocking list) - most of the presents go in the stocking so in fact, they get quite a lot in the stocking.
This year each stocking includes:
Leapfrog tablet (DD6) and Leapfrog Reader pen (DD3.5) + games/books
Colouring pens, colouring books
A dress
A swimsuit
Cuddly toy
Barbie doll and a Barbie dvd
Craft kit (e.g. Djeco/Aquarellum)
Books + audio cds (lots.....went a bit mad at the Book People)
Hair bobbles and clips
Character knickers and socks
Games (Party, party party!, a Kloo game, Coppit)
Jigsaw
Tangleteezer
Plus a few extra bits like fairy dust (got that idea from the Christmas thread), and probably cute pencils, key rings etc. DD2 is also getting a duvet cover.
I would much rather pad out the stocking with useful items (clothing, socks, pants etc - my kids seem to love this!) than putting plastic tat in.