I know about the other thread and can't be bothered to post on there.
Some apologies have still not been forthcoming and posters are making the same knee-jerk Daily Mail reader judgemental type comments.
I hope that in some way I helped Ema76 have the courage to ask for her choice of birth on the NHS so I feel O.K. about not wading in again in defence of elective c-sections for "personal circumstances" reasons.
Starlight Mackenzie's post says what I've believed for many years now about both elective c-sections and formula feeding.
" LadyThompson I agree passionately that women should be able to choose the method of birthing their children.
However, I have come across many people on MN who would also say this but what they mean is:
A women has the right to make an 'informed' choice of how she gives birth. However, if she then 'chooses' an elective, she is obviously not yet 'informed' enough! "
People are not necessarily unable to interpret/understand the risks as is assmued by so many posters, leading to a wrong or uninformed decision taking place. They have simply processed that information taking into account there own personal circumstances.
I believe it applies to the "choosing to formula feed" debate too.
People deny this is what they mean about informed choice but some simply aren't able to think deeply enough about the issue to realise that we are all different in the risks that we will/won't accept in life and it comes down to personal circumstances and personal choice over risks we are willing to take in our lives.
Your life is not the same as mine what suits you may not suit me and vice versa.