Vio, glad you are loving kicks!!!
Interesting debate. Particularly interesting for me as I am going to have to do it all very differently this time. I had no routine with ds and he never got into one himself, but I never put him to bed at specific time (he usually went to bed with me). His feeds would be in 'routine' for 1 week or so and then he would have growth spurt and they'd go crazy, then settle for a bit, then all over again...he never cried for more than about 30seconds, I couldn't bear it. He was the most confident, happy,(and rather fat even though exc. bf'd) and independent baby/ toddler. When he turned 2 though, he suddenly got quite clingy and still is, so I guess that is a bit of his own nature/ awareness coming out. Yorky, I do empathise with you, but see now that sending ds to playschool 2 mornings a week has really helped him, he is a lot 'better' at leaving me now and has a great time there though it took a couple of weeks to settle him. I did this to ease the transition to when babies come (he will be going 4 mornings by then) so that I can spend some time with them without him around and then focus on him when he is around.
Back to having no routine...I won't have that option this time a) with toddler and b) with two babies (yes, am fairly panicked at that!). I am dreading 'having' to have a routine tbh - they make me feel like I am in prison (that's why I am on mumsnet at 3.48am!). But I'll have to get into a routine of sorts if life is going to work for me, toddler and 2 babies, so am interested in your bedtime/ wake-time, pinky, maybe that is a place to start. In terms of feeds, a friend of mine actually used to wake her baby from sleeping to bf her, and get her into a bf routine. Seems to have worked. I may try that as I would prefer to tandem feed the twins (at least when I am at home!). I don't think I can rely on 2 babies getting into their own feeding routine, esp. after my experience with ds. Anyone know how I can do this, or books which are specifically good on it (apart from GF).
Oblomov, good thing to raise the issue of the first child. The issue of adding a toddler to the mix makes a huge difference I think. And I definitely believe the toddler has to come first within reason. That's 'cos I am the elder of 2 and have been insecure about it for most of my life ! (In terms of always believing my parents loved my sister more, though they have never done anything to indicate that). Before finding out it was twins, I was already planning how I could make it as easy as possible on It's going to be hard to leave a baby to cry while you get lunch ready for toddler, for example, and I will see how it goes. I think you get a bit more 'hardened' with 2nd or 3rd kids, and know the babies will probably not remember a bit of a cry whereas toddler definitely will remember if they always come second to a demanding baby. Misdee, would definitely appreciate your comments on this, having THREE!
I am also interested to see that with several people their second child was the more confident/ outgoing etc. I think this is fairly common. And personally, rather than having anything to do with specific parenting 'doctrine', I think it is because the parents are A LOT more relaxed about their parenting, and feel a lot more confident about what they are doing. So, my advice to people is to do what makes you feel relaxed and confident, as I am sure in the end that affects the baby far more than anything specific (like whether you choose to co-sleep or not - I felt great doing it, and loved (so did dh), but I know it makes others worry, so obviously that is not going to do the baby any good). If the parent is feeling guilty all the time that they are not doing something 'right', I think that affects things more, so ChocO and other first time mums, try and do whatever makes YOU feel the most relaxed and confident.
Sorry long post...it's all a very interesting debate.