I love the whole nature vs nurture debate and like a lot of you who parent differently I also have happy, confident and outgoing Lo's and they were in routines Therefore, can we assuem for the purposes of this discussion that we are all wonderful, rounded parents who have raised amazing kids despite using very different methods?!!!
mum2becks DS1 was in hospital for the first 3 weeks of his life and the SCBU put him on a strict 4 hour feeding routine (I pumped for the first weeks then successfully breastfed for the next 9 months, amazing myself as he made the switch from breast milk in the bottle to boob no problem!)
When we finally got him home, we went with the flow (ie demand feeding, sleeping when he wanted, where he wanted) and by 12 weeks of age he was cranky, colicky, and couldn't be settled. Several friends were following GF and my SIL who swore (by it and had given me the book when i WAS ABOUT 6 MONTHS PG) LITERALLY told me to give it a go...When I had initially read it my first thought was no way as it was really rigid but by this stage, we were desperate.....we decided to adapt it for us and our lifestyle so followed the feeding/sleeping patterns but ignored all the nonsense such as 0815 have your breakfast, 0820 go to the loo etc etc
It changed all of our lives..literally! DS was so happy in a routine, he changed into a totally content, happy boy and his colic literally disappeared overnight.....due to him getting proper long feeds and taking the hind milk (gold top!) rather than snacking on the skimmed milk every 30mins or so...
I also changed from a very tired stressed out mother to someone who really started to enjoy parenting....
DS2 we did it staright away and he was a dream baby/toddler (Although he always wakes at 6am!)
Heartmum - what is AP him??!! (also nice to see you posting, it;s been a while!
Off out with the girls soon, really looking forward to it!