Yes, ridiculous GP. I just stared him down and said 'You need to take it up with your staff.'
Spotty, I'm just struggling a bit with evidence. There's so little out there, and I am very evidence-minded, and due to the dearth of good evidence have been talking to friends and gathering anecdata (which doesn't sit well with me to begin with). I asked him about birthing pools and the Epino after being interested in both, and he was blunt about the Epino having no evidence as to safety, and mentioned concerns about pools being ineffective in reducing tearing and may increase risk of infection. I just felt as though my plans were shrinking, which is a bit of an overstated response. I think I'll email him to ask for references, as I may still opt to have some time in the pool if not the birth itself (if there is evidence of analgesia and reduced labour time). And then my next thing will be to stop thinking about birth plans (about which I have been tremendously relaxed) and start thinking about finding out more about parenting, settling etc.
Bah. In some ways I think it wouldn't have mattered what the doctor had said, I was in a bad mental state and so anything might have been upsetting.
I just ate a whole bag of Jelly Belly beans to make myself feel better (and now feel a bit sick).