Dorothy, Agatha or Agnes?

[Owlyhedgehog]

Which one?
I love Dorothy and Aggie as a NN.
Already have a Delilah.
Also love tallulah, Jemima,

Jamima is best for me.
Dorothy could be a second name.
Nick names - Mimi, Jam or Dottie

Agnes is my favourite, followed by Agatha and Jemima. I do think the latter two sound better with Delilah.

As an aside, I'll never understand the "harsh" comments on names like these. Surely that just means... they're consonant-heavy? Contain plosive stops? What makes that ugly or "worse" than other names? I prefer to think of them as having substance! 🤷🏻‍♀️

Dorothy is lovely. The others are awful in my opinion

Love Dorothy and Agnes. My favourite though is Jemima. Not keen on Agatha.

Love Dorothy! Dorrie is a nickname that hasn't been mentioned yet for it. I am not too keen on the Ag sound of your other two choices. Delilah is a great name too

Dorothy

Agnes / Aggie is awful! Don't do this. We had an Agnes at our school. She was nicknamed Haggis.

Tallulah is the most common name that princesses give their VW campers. 😆 or cookapoos.

I like all the names except Jemima.

Agnes is my favourite. It's probably a bit marmite but I love it

I must have awful taste as people are commenting all these lovely names are so bad.

I know a 10yo Dorothy non Dot/Dotty and it's a lovely name! Agatha and Agnes are not harsh at all!

I love Delilah but I did have a cat called that and it reminds me of Tom Jone's song whereby no one seems to care he murders her!

I like them all.

Dorothy is my favourite but I think it’s better to avoid using the same first letter as her sister.

I slightly prefer Agnes over Agatha. Aggie is cute.

Jemima and Talullah are too rhymey with Delilah.

Dot is bloody awful...you are so insignificant you have shrunk to nothing. In my personal experience.

Edith has the same sort of vibe?

Agnes and Agatha are lovely.

They do have a hard g in them but what follows is quite soft.

Dotty is cute

I think we have similar taste. DD is called one of those names. I also love Tabitha.

Dorothy is nice.Jemima is ok. Tallulah is too cutesy. I have to agree with those who say that Agatha and Agnes are harsh unattractive named.

This.
Tallulah probably 'goes' best, if you don't mind Lilah and Lulah as sisters

Delilah and Dorothy seem too different yet matchy
I don't like Dorothea or Senga.

I love all your choices, but Tallulah is too similar in sound to Delilah. I always think of names in terms of what I'd like to be called myself, and I'd love to be named Dorothy or Agatha.

I like Jemima the best, by a lot! It is a bit similar to Delilah in sound but I don't think that matters. I find Agatha and Agnes very harsh sounding, and Tallulah and Dorothy quite twee... but Dorothy is probably my second favourite.
Agree with pp that Edith might be a similar vibe, and I think that's a nice name!

Dotty is second in bloody awfulness to Dot. Call me either and I will never forget. Not in a good way 😉

I don't think these names have aged well

I really don't like any of them. They are very old fashioned and don't sound nice. I like Tallulah and Jemima.

Dorothy, Agnes and Agatha are just awful, harsh sounding and outdated. Jemima is far nicer.

None tbh. Angès the French way less harsh, A nyes, but no doubt it would be midpronounced. Can't you use one of these for a middle name?

All awful except Jemima, I really like that one.
Who wants to be Aggie (Saggy Aggy), Dottie and Tallulah Loo.
No, no and thrice no.