Elizabeth Lilly or Margaret Anne

[Rosemary2022]

Which do you prefer?

Neither, they are both very old fashioned.

I like both, and would call them classic rather than old fashioned.

Margaret Anne , though both are lovely and classic

I like both!

Margaret Anne

Elizabeth Lilly, by a long way

Elizabeth, although both are boring.

Both lovely though I prefer Lily with one 'l'.
Congratulations on choosing 2 such lovely choices.

Both are beautiful names. Elizabeth was on our name list it's a beautiful name. However Elizabeth lily is quite a mouthful and quite alot of l sounds. Margaret Anne is easier to say. Can you switch them round so Elizabeth Anne or Margaret lily. Elizabeth still my favourite of the two!

Prefer Elizabeth to Margaret by a long shot, but Elizabeth Lilly is a bit too samey in my mind.

Other options:
Elizabeth Rose
Elizabeth Anne

Or, if you like flower names, Margaret Anne, nn Daisy (which is an old-fashioned pet name for Margaret) - personally I love Daisy as a nn. Cute on a little girl, but with a name like Margaret she'd also have the possibility for more professional nn or using her full name when older.

Also with a vowel at the start of the middle name, take care that the initials don't spell out anything eg MAD, MAN, MAP etc

Margaret 🤢

Both are beautiful, classic names. Elegant and timeless.

That said, I think Elizabeth Mary is slightly more elegant than Elizabeth Lily (I appreciate I am suggesting a new name!).

Margaret Anne is also beautiful. Maybe Elizabeth Margaret is another option?

Mary Margaret is also lovely.

I think Lily is often used as a shortened version of Elizabeth

Too many L’s in Elizabeth Lily.

I prefer Elizabeth to Margaret though, could Elizabeth Anne work?

Elizabeth Anne

Margot Lily

Very royal family

I don't dislike Elizabeth, Lily (one L) or Anne, but here in North-East Margaret has a very bad association!

It is, so for that reason I'd go with Elizabeth Anne.

Not Margaret, it's horrid.

I really dislike Margaret so would go for Elizabeth but not too keen on that either. I do love the name Lily though.

Elizabeth Lilly is really lovely.

Lily is a pet name for Elizabeth. I actually like Margaret. Maggie is lovely.

I love Elizabeth but Lily is a diminitive form of it so I think it would be odd to have both.
Elizabeth Anne or Elizabeth Margaret work though. Or what about Elizabeth Margot, Elizabeth Rose, Elizabeth Alice?

Both are lovely, but to be honest I'm really loving Margaret at the moment! It's an underused pretty name. I know a Margaret in her early 20's

Elizabeth Anne is my choice.