Georgie, Sophie, Emilia or Annie

[RainbowFish4]

How would you rank these names?

Georgie (full name Georgina, but I don’t think we’d use it that much)

Sophie

Emilia, shortened to Emmy

Annie (I feel like we need a longer name for this, but struggling - I like Annabel but Baby Annabell is already a key individual in DD1’s life, husband likes Anastasia but I worry that it sounds too Russian which might be a bit weird when we’re not!)

And any other suggestions very welcome!

If I’m honest, I really dislike the names Georgia and Sophie. But Emilia/Emmy is adorable and I’ve always liked Annie!

So I’d say 1) Annie, 2) Emilia, 3) Sophie, 4) Georgia!

In order of preference:
Anna nn Annie?
Sophie
Emilia (I'm not a fan of Emmy though)
Georgie (too cutesy for me)

Sophie
Annie
Emmy (not Emilia though)
Georgie (really dislike)

Emilia
Annie
Sophie
Georgie

My preference would be
Annie
Sophie
Emilia
Georgie

Emmy is cute but I think Emilia would be called the more popular Amelia quite a lot. I would opt for Emma or Emily instead.

Emilia is beautiful. Emmy is ok, I know an Emmeline shortened to Emmy and it's alright but I think Emilia is just gorgeous.

Annie is ok, seems to be popular amongst my friends as I know a few now. I love Annabel and Anastasia though.

Sophie is classic but really dull and over done I think. Hundreds of them

Georgie I don't like. Georgia is nicer. I know a Georgina shortened to Ginny and... Hmm. Yeah. Not keen. It's just so harsh sounding to my ears.

All a bit meh and well used apart from Annie which is totally dated.

I know a Georgia nicknames Gigi which is cute.

Sophie is a lovely name, really not overdone where I live.
I love the way Emelia looks written down, but don’t like Emmy and people hear Amelia which I don’t like.
Don’t like George, Georgie, or any variants, it’s dull and lumpy.
Annie is nice but I feel it needs to be more formal and then shortened. Anna? Annalise? Annabel?

Annie is lovely as it is imo but also like it as Anna.

Georgina/Georgie - like
Emilia is lovely but too close to Amelia - not keen on Emmy
Sophie - really like it but Sophia/Sofia too popular
Annie - fine, wouldn't use a longer name, Annabel(le), Anastasia etc too disney

I really can't see the point of naming a baby Anna then calling her Annie, I'd go with Ann/Anne.

Georgie is the nicest. Definitely no mealy sounding names like Emelia.

Sophie.

The Emelia misspelling is awful.

Emilia
Annie
Sophie
Georgie

Also I adore Emmy, perfect nickname or I'd use it as a full name personally.

Emilia is my favourite. If you need a longer name for Annie how about Annalise?

I love Sophie but appreciate it is very common. Annie is also nice, and Emilia is OK but agree that it would get mixed up with Amelia. Not a fan of Georgina or Georgie, sorry!

I think Anna and Anastasia are both fine for Annie! Other ideas:
Anneliese
Ariane/ Ariana
Julianne/juliana
Susanna
Eliana
Rosanne /Rosanna
Liliana
Alana

Sophie

Annika could work if you want Annie as nn? I also just like Anna too.

Annie 🥰🥰

Emilia is lovely but I don’t like Emmy at all - I would shorten it to Mimi/Millie
Sophie is a nice name, gentle sounding
Georgina too is a great name, and Georgie/Gigi are cute
Annie is one I really don’t like at all, too old-ladyish , whereas I like Anna which is much more elegant

How about Savannah, with nn Annie?

1. Georgie sounds great to me, having the longer Georgina gives them the chance to pick a different nn later if they prefer which is always good.
2. Emilia is very cutesy but hits as an Olivia type to me so reads as trendy
3. Sophie
4. Annie