Help me narrow down my girls list please.

[Notlong]

Could you tell me your fav 3 and least favourite 3 please. Sorry it's a long one.

Fleur
Verity
Libby
Josie
Flora
Seren
Wren
Naomi
Alexandra
Sadie
Pippa
Felicity
Lara
Maeve
Erin
Margot
Thea
Eliza
Alice
Matilda
Emily
Rosie
Freya
Olivia

Freya is my favourite. Sorry I dislike all the others

Sadie
Maeve
Thea

I love Wren, Eliza and Matilda!

probably least favourite are Naomi, Felicity and Libby. Just find all a bit dated somehow.

Favourite:

Lara
Emily
Rosie

Least favourite:

Sadie
Fleur/Flora
Libby
Wren

Fave: Rosa nn Rosie fine for a child but not for an adult
Eliza
Margot

not keen on:
Libby, Flora & Sadie

Favourite: Lara, Erin, Freya

Least favourite: Maeve, Pippa, Naomi

Such an interesting list OP! Two distinct vibes going on there I think.
More than 3 from your list that are just lovely:
Elizabeth (Libby and Eliza)
Alexandra
Philippa (Pippa)
Felicity
Maeve
Alice
Josephine (Josie)

Least favourite:
Fleur (unless you are French) I'm not keen on Poppy/Daisy etc either.
Rosie (see above)
Wren (ditto)
Seren ( I know it's become popular for girls now but the two I know are men so in my head it's a boy's name.

Favourites:
Naomi
Felicity
Fleur

Don't like
Maeve
Sadie
Olivia

Least: Verity, Margot and Thea.

Most: Matilda, Alice, Naomi, Felicity and Maeve.

I also like Rosie if short for a longer Ros- name, and Josie if short for Josephine

I like Rosie, Thea or Eliza

Missed the part about least fave, I think Seren, Naomi and Verity

Fleur
Verity
Libby - fav
Josie
Flora
Seren
Wren - fav
Naomi - least fav
Alexandra
Sadie - least fav
Pippa
Felicity
Lara - fav
Maeve
Erin
Margot
Thea
Eliza - least fav
Alice
Matilda
Emily
Rosie
Freya
Olivia

Love Sadie, Matilda and Maeve although it was hard to pick just three.

Not sure about Verity (verucca) Fleur (vomit noises) or Olivia (way too common.)

Favourites: Naomi, Alexandra, Josie. All lovely names, I like ones that are not too 'out there' but not too popular.

Least: Wren (very trendy in certain areas, will sound dated IMO), Alice, Emily

I have an Erin myself so obviously that one is my fave. Also got my eye on Maeve for number 2 so really like this one as well (do you have Irish links?)

We had Freya on our list for DD but ditched it due to it's current popularity - but you might not mind that and it's a lovely name.

Not a fan of Seren unless you have Welsh links. Least faves are Verity, Felicity and Sadie.

Favourites, sorry I had to have four because I can't choose between them, Eliza, Olivia, Alice and Emily, all gorgeous and classic.

Three I most dislike although they seem to be recently popular, Wren (small brown bird, not even a nice sound, why?), Pippa, (try hard posh girl, rude meanings in several foreign languages), Maeve (sounds frumpy to me).

Love Wren, Sadie, Margot

Would ditch Josie (sounds childish/ incomplete), Rosie (same as Josie in this room and so many of these around in every long form name), Olivia (again, overdone)

Favorites:
Flora
Lara
Alice

Dislike:
Fleur
Libby
Felicity
Rose

• 'Rose' is a typo

Also dislike:
Verity
Wren
Thea
Emily

Like: Matilda, Alice, Sadie

Dislike: Erin, Libby, Naomi, Felicity, Pippa

Really dislike: Freya and Maeve.

Fleur - it’s quite nice but someone said it sounds like ‘bleugh’ and now that’s all I can hear
Verity - I don’t like it, sounds like ‘ferrite’
Libby - nice as a nickname for Elizabeth but not a full name
Josie - lovely as a nickname for Josephine but I also love.
Flora - LOVE
Seren - it’s overdone
Wren - it’s okay
Naomi - love, beautiful sound and timeless and biblical. Can’t go wrong
Alexandra - nice
Sadie - lovely
Pippa - dislike, it’s slang for ‘blowjob’ in some European countries
Felicity - nice
Lara - pretty but prefer Zara
Maeve - very cool but very trendy, will date
Erin - nice but prefer Merryn
Margot - nice but very trendy
Thea - pretty
Eliza - pretty
Alice - pretty
Matilda - pretty but will date
Emily - a bit boring
Rosie - much prefer Rose or Rosa
Freya - I find this a bit ‘meh’
Olivia - done to death

I’d choose
Flora, Josephine or Naomi.

Fav. Naomi. Alexandra and Eliza.
Least Fav. Fleur. Pippa and Seren.

Best; Naomi, Freya, Olivia

Worst: Maeve, Matilda, Seren

Favourite 3: Alexandra (nn Lexi), Matilda (nn. Tilly) and Thea but prefer it as full name Theadora with Thea as the nn

least favourite 3: Wren, Seren, Josie