Unusual but not wacky Girls names

[Sussex34]

Trying to think of some more girls names to add to my list as currently DP and I only agree on two names (Cleo and Jemima). For my first DD I feel as though I was quite successful in finding a name that was uncommon but not outlandish, but struggling more for this baby. Basically I don’t want anything where there’s going to be 5 of them in the class with the same name. Any ideas?

Nothing wrong with Cleo or Jemima. Why go wider?

Jemima is a gorgeous name.
Tabitha
Meredith
Coraline

Harriet
martha
nancy

Jemima sounds good.

How about, Emma?

I like Cleo a lot, Jemima is sweet too.

Lois
Ines
Jocelyn
Stella
Thora
Honor
Adela
Claudia
Cassia
Fernanda
Marianne
Genevieve
Caroline

Merryn

Lydia

Myrtle. Bloody love it.

I love all of these so much! Merryn I had never heard of, Tabitha is also on our list. 😊 Thank you all!

Aurelia, Lucia, Astrid,
I like Jemima but stick to the J. I saw an adult Gemima the other day and it just didn't seem right!

Celine
Rhiannon
Kathleen
Mary
Marieanne
Phillipa

Romilly
Marina
Catriona

Prudence
Isadora
Verity

Celeste
Tallulah
Jocelyn

My daughter is Delilah! Classic but still unusual :-)

Beatrix?

Heidi
Lorelei
Henrietta
Christabel
Rosanna
Helena
Amy
Louisa
Lavinia
Francesca
Edith
Esther
Hester
Leonore
Naomi
Georgina
Josephine
Martha
Cara
Cora
Nancy
Audrey
Fearne
Heather
Chloe
Jessica
Beatrix
Verity
Natalie
Laura
Andrea

If I had a baby girl right now, I would call her Clemency.

Of your two names, I prefer Cleo. Jemima is very racially charged in the USA and names which travel well are important to me (wouldn't choose Pippa for this reason either).
Other classic but underused girls names are:
Adelaide
Cecily
Claudia
Frances
Gaia
Louisa
Odette
Pandora
Rowena
Vita

Hazel
Beatrix
Juno
Orla
Clementine
Hope
Selene
Celine
Celeste
Imogen
Greta

Cleo is lovely

Stevie
Robyn
Olympia
Honor
Tegan
Marley
Frida
Zola

Eleonora
Beatrice
Miranda

I have a Tabitha and there's quite a few of them around here, but we also liked Meredith, Merryn, Imogen, Willow and Rowena.

My two cats are Cleo and Jemima but I think they are lovely for human names too 😄

Zita
Sigrid
Leona